←
Kirsten Han98,621 posts
Kirsten Han avatar

Kirsten Han

@kixes

🇸🇬 Journalist, writer and activist. Champion of clauses. Author of The Singapore I Recognise: Essays on home, community and hope (Ethos Books, 2023)

◷ Joined March 2009▧ 5,750 Photos and videos
Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

“The Government only seeks to correct falsehoods,” MHA says in its Correction Direction to @ADPANetwork. It’s my opinion that that is itself a falsehood, and that POFMA has been thoroughly weaponised as a political tool to ensure that only PAP narratives are allowed to prevail.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

It’s bullying & gaslighting—designed to coerce while maintaining plausible deniability, cloaking oppression in legalese/bureaucracy, making things convoluted so the public is left with confused impressions that deter them from exercising their own political agency.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

Shanmugam and MHA’s POFMA direction against ADPAN is a classic example of the Singaporean authoritarian modus operandi: harassing and intimidating activists while insisting that they are doing no such thing.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

This is how, in Singapore—a country that exhorts its people to “Speak Good English”—it’s possible to have illegal assemblies/processions of one person, for as little as 15 secs. Just because it’s legal (cos they legalised it) doesn’t mean it isn’t harassment or intimidation.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

Singapore doesn’t disappear activists off the streets or engage in overt displays of state violence. However, the People’s Action Party uses its overwhelming majority in Parliament to pass wide-ranging legislation that grants the state broad powers to police and punish.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

(Rajah has also written about the role of POFMA in “normalising authoritarianism” in Singapore and how POFMA “undermines rule of law and democracy by deploying the relational dynamics of contempt and epistemic injustice inherent to political gaslighting”.)

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

Ofc the govt will point to all sorts of legislation, from POFMA to contempt of court to the Public Order Act, to say that all this was because we broke the rules. But that is, as Jothie Rajah articulates in her book, a function of the authoritarian rule of law.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

Other comrades have similarly been subjected to interrogation, warnings and criminal charges. Just this month @tjc_singapore has been POFMAed and our planned exhibition rejected by IMDA even as they refused to give us a comprehensive list of their issues with our exhibition.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

I’ve been an active participant in 🇸🇬’s anti-death penalty movement for 14 years. I have been investigated by the police, issued warnings “stern” and “conditional”, POFMAed, accused of wanting to cause harm to 🇸🇬 and doxxed by both the Attorney-General’s Chambers and Shanmugam.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

And then we get to the other “false statement” that MHA accused ADPAN of making: that the Singapore government “targets, silences and harasses” TJC and others speaking out against the death penalty regime. How does one go about POFMA-ing a POFMA?

Post attachment
Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

Once again, the differences between MHA and ADPAN was a matter of perspective on what constitutes “due legal process”—MHA is satisfied with Singapore’s current practices with regard to the use of the death penalty, ADPAN is not.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

(I’m a current executive committee member of @ADPANetwork, but recused myself from the decision-making so as to allow my colleagues to discuss and come to a conclusion without feeling like they had to defer to my wishes. I am also writing this post in my personal capacity.)

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

This timeframe was so short that most members of ADPAN’s executive committee did not even have the chance to see the Correction Direction or consider it.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

Last night (9 October), @ADPANetwork, a regional network consisting of death penalty abolitionist groups, received a POFMA direction demanding that they publish “corrections” by 9 a.m. today. ADPAN is not registered or based in Singapore.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

We complied with these orders because the costs of appeal or non-compliance are high and not a good use of the limited resources that we have, but issued statements to make it clear that we did this only under duress.

Kirsten Han avatar
Kirsten Han@kixes·10 Oct 2024

The differences were in the narrative; TJC and MHA had different views on what constitutes due process and fairness. These were matters of opinion. Yet POFMA was used to attack TJC and to force us to publish “Correction Directions” we do not believe in and categorically reject.