
Now that the RI media have, at long last, discovered that our state's labor force trends are significant (and negative), here's a glimpse of what I have been talking about for quite some time.

Professor of Economics, University of Rhode Island

Now that the RI media have, at long last, discovered that our state's labor force trends are significant (and negative), here's a glimpse of what I have been talking about for quite some time.

I have, at long last, gotten through to RI's local media: They now realize (better late than never) that RI's labor force has been declining, and this has played a significant role in producing our low (meaningless) jobless rates. Will they incorporate this into future reports?

RI's September labor market data show an apparent end to the string of nightmarish annual declines, with a suggestion of monthly stabilization. But where else can the jobless rate fall from 4.3% to 3.6% annually when resident employment declines by 11,000?

We are currently witnessing an all-time high in diesel fuel prices, or so we are told. Never base this assessment on current dollar values. Adjusted for today's purchasing power, we see the record high actually occurred in July 2008.

The RI labor market somewhat parallels the US: Cyclical employment is not as strong as overall employment, which is supported by education, healthcare, and government. Manufacturing here though is doing very well, though.

A clarification of the recent employment change debate: monthly employment numbers are net changes, job gains minus job losses. As long as there are job losses (almost always) job gains exceed employment change. The debate traces the green line, but job gains are the blue line.

4/ At least monthly changes have settled down, so the string of recent implosive declines in our labor force and resident employment may well (hopefully) be coming to an end.

3/ I fully expect the recent implosions in our labor force and resident employment measures to be eliminated with data rebenchmarking in January. In the meantime, I suspect that the only people naive enough to believe the 3.9% July jobless rate will be our media.

2/ If our labor market were deteriorating as much as recent household survey data suggest, retail sales would be plunging, initial UI claims would be exploding, and benefit exhaustions would be surging. None of this is happening, in fact just the opposite is true.

1/ Bizarre continued with July's RI household survey data. According to the data (which I have very little confidence in), our jobless rate fell from 4.2% to 3.9% as resident employment was decimated (-13,800 or 2.4%) while our labor force fell by 16,700. Only in RI!

3/ Even with my reservations about RI labor data accuracy, we can see a longer-term pattern: A falling unemployment rate, the result of a declining labor force. This has been RI's historical "secret sauce" for reducing its jobless rate. Too bad the media is so oblivious to this!

2/ According to official data, RI's labor force has fallen off a cliff in absolute terms or relative to the US. I find the last four months of data difficult to believe. I view them as makeup for abnormally low growth rates in 2025. Data revisions will eventually clear this up.

1/ Good news! My Current Conditions Index for June has at long last moved into expansion territory. RI's recession thus ended in either April (50) or June (58). RI labor data is very messed up (see following posts), which makes this determination difficult.

My May Current Conditions Index shows a basis for optimism about RI's economy. We are not yet in the expansion range, but have moved to neutral for two of the last three months. Hopefully, this signals our moving from recession. But with data difficulties, this remains uncertain.

If RI's labor force participation rate (% of resident population aged 16+ in the labor force) were the same as before the pandemic, June's unemployment rate would be 7.7%. This and the actual rate are bizarre. When in doubt, average them: 5.9%, my best guess of the actual rate.

For anyone who believes RI's June unemployment rate really was 4.1%, below the national rate, I have some swamp land in South County they might be interested in. Sadly, the local media will just report the number absent context, so presumably they are potential swamp land buyers.