←
Lavar Edmonds4,078 posts
Lavar Edmonds avatar

Lavar Edmonds

@lavaredmonds

Economics PhD candidate @StanfordEcon. On the 26-27 job market!

◷ Joined September 2017▧ 686 Photos and videos
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·15 Aug 2022

🚨 Working Paper Alert! 🚨 I’ve basically been soft launching this for a while now, but I’m ready to share my first Big Kid working paper. Join me for a 🧵 on HBCUs, teachers, and Black student achievement! Comments and suggestions are much appreciated! lavaredmonds.com/uploads/1/4…

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

In summary: desegregation didn't just displace Black teachers at the time; it shaped the Black teacher workforce we have today. A temporary demand shock can persist when the institutions that train and hire workers (HBCUs, Black principals) are disrupted and don't recover

Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

This matters particularly because Black principals hire Black teachers. In admin data from six states: when a Black principal arrives at a school, the Black share of its teachers rises 26–36% within three years; when a Black principal leaves, Black hiring falls

Post attachmentPost attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

Second, desegregation affected not only Black teachers, but also Black principals. Court-ordered districts that closed more Black schools still have fewer Black principals today

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

I find no effects at the South's (mostly White) non-HBCUs exposed to the same orders. This is consistent with a Black-specific, local labor demand shock leading would-be Black teachers to choose other majors as opportunities in teaching shrank

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

Why has this persisted? I point to two factors, one on the supply side and one on the demand side. First, teacher training: at Southern HBCUs, after a court order in their local district, the share of graduates earning teaching degrees fell by about a fifth and never recovered

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

4️⃣ Those who would have taught didn't necessarily find better jobs: young Black women college grads in court-ordered counties fell 7–9 percentiles in their state's earnings distribution, even after adjusting for who lives there, while young White women there didn't

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

3️⃣ These areas never recovered. 40+ years later, the Black share of teachers in court-ordered counties is about 30% lower than it would have been without an order: roughly 50,000 fewer Black teachers, a fifth of the nation's Black public school teachers

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

2️⃣ In the short run, the Black share of teachers fell in Southern districts after court orders, more so where more Black schools closed, and ordered districts hired a smaller share of Black teachers

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

Using these data and a stacked DiD design that uses variation in court orders and Black school closures, I find: 1️⃣ After a district came under a court order, Black schools became 10 percentage points more likely to close than White schools in the same district

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

To study these questions, I build a few new data sets, including (1) the first comprehensive database of desegregation-era school closures and (2) a district-level panel of teacher employment by race for 10 states that links districts from the 1950s and 60s to today

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

My JMP asks: Was this a transitory shock, or did desegregation leave lasting scars on Black teacher labor markets? And, if so, what explains the persistence?

Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

Desegregation swept through the country in the 1960s and 70s, often through court orders that compelled districts to act. It was meant to advance racial equity for students, but one consequence was the displacement of thousands of Black teachers

Post attachment
Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

In this period, teaching was THE profession for Black college grads: constrained outside options + demand in Black schools + prestige in Black communities + relatively high pay (in 1960, the median Black woman teacher out-earned 80% of full-time women workers in her state)

Lavar Edmonds avatar
Lavar Edmonds@lavaredmonds·Nov 9

Background: Up until the 1960s, much of the US (especially the South) operated dual systems with racially segregated schools: Black and White students were separated into their own schools, along with racially separated teachers and principals