←
Level398,891 posts
Level39 avatar

Level39

@level39

#Bitcoin

◷ Joined March 2009▧ 2,736 Photos and videos
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 4

1/ Everyone take a deep breath. Texas data centers aren't going anywhere. The Texas governor has very limited authority to stop them. Calls for a pause or moratorium must be approved by TCEQ—the permitting authority of Abbott appointees. Here's how Texas permitting really works👇

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

18/ Legal pathways aside, a governor does exert considerable informal influence over agencies that might otherwise be opposed to the governor's directives. Words of wisdom from this former TCEQ commissioner.

A bunch of folks are about to learn how the governor and legislature hold considerable leverage and influence over state agencies, regardless of what the laws might say.

Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

1/ Gov. Abbott left a kill-switch in the Texas data center permit freeze. He directed TCEQ to pause permits “until ERCOT completes its review”—the basis lapses December 10, when conditions are met. Furthermore Hinojosa's industry-wide freeze is legally vulnerable. Here's why...👇

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

17/ Abbott's TECQ/PUCT/ERCOT appointees can't be replaced instantly. Their staggered terms and required Senate approval prevent rapid changes in policy. That said, by late 2027 and onwards Hinojosa will begin to have real impact on those agencies.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

16/ A governor can’t order TCEQ, can’t suspend “shall grant,” can’t reach a power plant that never says “data center,” and can’t count on no one suing. She can slow review, amend standard permits, and ask the Legislature to define the target. A moratorium is a bill, not an order.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

15/ Texas’s permit system never sees the words “data center.” The permits that matter most are often for power plants, filed by power companies under power-industry codes. A governor’s pause aims at a noun the forms don’t use. Only a statute written by function can hit the target

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

14/ The pause has few natural plaintiffs. Developers depend on the state for grid access, water and incentives. Green groups want TCEQ to have this discretion. TCEQ and Abbott both have reasons to avoid a ruling. The likeliest challenger is an outsider worried about precedent.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

13/ What would hold up: (a) a statute, like SB 1758’s “may not issue” language for cement kilns; (b) case-by-case delays tied to real gaps in emissions data; (c) amending TCEQ’s standard permits for generators via rulemaking. Slower than a directive—but each has a legal basis.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

12/ How would it be tested? An applicant would sue the commissioners for acting ultra vires—beyond their authority—or seek mandamus to compel a ministerial duty. Whether anyone sues is another matter: developers may not want to fight a governor who controls their future.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

11/ The practical problem is bigger than the legal one. A governor can’t order TCEQ. Its 3 commissioners serve staggered 6-year terms, are Senate-confirmed, and aren’t removable at will. All three are Abbott appointees. Abbott’s pause worked because his appointees chose to comply

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

10/ Many expect Hinojosa to use emergency powers. The Disaster Act (Gov’t Code ch. 418) lets a governor declare a disaster for an “imminent threat” and suspend regulatory statutes that would “prevent, hinder, or delay” the response. 30-day declarations renew indefinitely.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

9/ Then the Texas Constitution, Art. I §28: “No power of suspending laws in this State shall be exercised except by the Legislature.” If a directive stops TCEQ from performing a mandatory duty for an entire industry, challengers will call it a suspension by another name.

Post attachment
Level39 avatar
Level39@level39·Nov 9

8/ A blanket policy may also be an unadopted “rule.” Under the Texas APA, an agency statement of general applicability that prescribes policy is a rule—and rules need notice and comment. “No data center permits until the Legislature acts” is about as general as policy gets.

Post attachment