←
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)7,052 posts
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)

@lmaia

Lecturer (assistant professor) @SPAISBristol. Ph.D. @UCSanDiego. Former Pre-doctoral fellow @MIT. Collaborator @revistapiaui, ex-@estadao and @exame. He/him/his

◷ Joined March 2009▧ 93 Photos and videos
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·3 Dec 2022

My paper “No Evidence of Backlash: LGBT Rights in Latin America”, with Albert Chiu and Scott Desposato, is out @the_jop. Did the increase in LGBT rights in Latin America motivate the election of people like Bolsonaro? Read on for our findings: journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10…

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

…and that probably does mean doing things the FT and the Economist don't like very much: redistributing income and wealth, providing greater security, strengthening infrastructure.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

Maybe these clichés aren't so innocent after all. Insisting that there is some magical solution out there distracts from the fact that not really knowing how to grow the economy is an argument for just building the society we want…

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

They lead to magical thinking: that there is a politician out there with extraordinary talent, who will propose a growth plan that works and tell the public the "hard truths" it doesn't want to hear, overcoming social media algorithms and the spread of misinformation.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

First because the punditry always reach for the same clichés anyway (lack of talent, lack of vision, lack of honesty). If one is going to repeat oneself, one might at least do so while telling the truth. But these clichés also do real damage.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

Repeatedly writing that no politician can be talented with zero economic growth – that nobody really knows how to create growth, that Britain is subject to global forces beyond its control – can only fill so many columns (and makes for bleak reading). But my sympathy has limits.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

These clichés allow political analysts to sound serious and hard-nosed, while doing no hard thinking themselves. In one respect, I am sympathetic. One must keep the papers and newsletters fed.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

Rather than admit these hard truths, to use a cliché the press likes so much, the commentariat just writes that British politicians aren't serious. They lack talent or they have no theory of economic growth – usually both. Meanwhile, voters are said not to want to hear the truth.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

Growth is only one of these forces too, most of them global: a fragmenting information environment, a revanchist Russia, an erratic United States, an economically dominant China. No politician can wish them away.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

Because no political talent survives contact with two decades of zero real income growth. And why does this government have no growth strategy? Because no one knows, really, how to generate economic growth. We have many theories, no final answers.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

The circumstantial cause is more interesting. British punditry avoids deep thinking because the forces that shape Britain's fortunes are largely beyond anyone's control. Why has Britain lacked political talent?

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

The structural one has deep roots in the British educational system. Students are taught to argue, not to think. The Economist is an expert in beautiful argumentation without much thinking at all. I'm hardly the first to notice this, so I need not labour the point.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

What these writers usually mean is that Labour has not made a centre-right offer they like. But grant the premise — say there is no vision. No one asks why. As I see it, there are two causes for this lack of curiosity, one structural and one circumstantial.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

Stephen Bush writes some version of this several times a week, every week, in his Inside Politics newsletter for the FT. The Economist will have at least one cover making roughly the same argument once a month.

Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social) avatar
Lucas de Abreu Maia (@LdAM.bsky.social)@lmaia·Jun 22

This was more or less the point of Tony Blair's essay a few weeks ago (or at least the point worth taking). This was what Wes Streeting meant when he told Peter Mandelson that this government had "no growth strategy at all".