←
Manusights178 posts
Manusights avatar

Manusights

@manusights

Pre-submission manuscript quality control that helps researchers clear the editor's first gate.

◷ Joined December 2025▧ 4 Photos and videos
Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·Jun 2

Manusights reviews your manuscript the way a tough, fair peer reviewer would: pressure-testing the science, the statistics, and the reporting before an editor ever sees it. It catches what a quick read misses - a mean that's arithmetically impossible, a within-group test passed off as a real effect, a missing CONSORT spine that means a desk-reject (a few real examples below) and then does the part no other tool does: it tells you which journals to actually target, and the gaps to close before you submit. It's trained on how 35+ active peer reviewers, including current Nature, Cell, and Science reviewers, judge real manuscripts. The best way to see it is on your own paper. Try it now → manusights.com

Post attachment
Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·Oct 22

Manusights is now in ChatGPT. Check citation details, retractions and corrections. Look up a journal’s AI policy. Connect your account, select Manusights, and ask: “Use Manusights to check these references.” Try the public example: manusights.com/chatgpt

Post attachment
Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·Sep 25

Finding the closest paper to your claim is not bad news. It shows what your manuscript still contributes and which journal readers may care. We worked with @LitmapsApp on a practical workflow from citation map to a defensible three-journal shortlist. ↓

How to protect your sanity during journal submission? Choosing a journal shouldn’t start after you finish the paper. Shortlist 3 potential homes before you submit: 🎯 Ambitious best fit 🎯🎯 Strong alternative 🎯🎯🎯 Specialist journal We looked at how citation mapping can help ↓ litmaps.com/articles/a-new-s… @manusights takes the workflow a step further ↓ manusights.com/blog/literatu…

Post attachment
Erik Jia avatar
⟳ Manusights retweeted
Erik Jia@erikinscience·Jun 8

One thing we heard over and over in conversations with reviewers: "Don't make me decode your paper." Reviewers are volunteers. They're often reading manuscripts at night, between meetings, or on weekends. The easier you make it for them to understand what you did, why it matters, and how the evidence supports the claim, the better your chances of getting a fair review. A surprising number of review comments come down to confusion, not disagreement.

0:10
Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·Jun 4

One thing we heard repeatedly from researchers is that choosing the right journal can feel surprisingly opaque. Most journals publish author guidelines. Far fewer explain how editors think about fit, contribution, novelty, and audience. That's one reason we spent so much time interviewing reviewers and editors when building Manusights. A technically strong paper can still end up at the wrong door.

0:10
Erik Jia avatar
⟳ Manusights retweeted
Erik Jia@erikinscience·Jun 3

One thing we heard repeatedly from researchers is that the hardest part of publishing isn't always the science. It's understanding what journals are actually looking for. Most journals publish author guidelines. Far fewer publish how editors think about contribution, fit, positioning, and novelty. That's one reason we spent so much time interviewing reviewers and editors when building Manusights.

Bo Cowgill avatar
⟳ Manusights retweeted
Bo Cowgill@bocowgill·Jun 2

The feedback I got from @manusights was both candid (and correct) about the strengths and limitations of this manuscript. I've seen some of the feedback before (the hard way) -- which is itself validating. Seeing this feedback earlier would have been useful.

Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·Jun 2

The "hidden curriculum" framing is a great way to put it.

I tried @manusights -- different/complementary proposition than @RefineDotInk. Refine seems focused on technical correctness (obviously valuable). Manusights motivated by "hidden curriculum" questions like journal choice, fit, contribution, and positioning/framing. Clear value in both approaches.

Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·May 31

exactly why we are building Manusights

Researchers audited 111 million references across 2.5 million papers and estimated that 146,932 hallucinated citations entered the scientific literature in 2025 alone. The finding that stood out to me is that many of these citations made it through existing moderation and publication processes. A lot of discussion around AI in science focuses on generation. This feels like a reminder that verification may be the more important problem. arxiv.org/abs/2605.07723

Post attachment
Erik Jia avatar
⟳ Manusights retweeted
Erik Jia@erikinscience·May 31

The biggest misconception in AI for science is that writing is the hard part. Writing is becoming cheap, but verification is becoming expensive. Does the citation exist? Does the DOI resolve? Does the cited paper actually support the claim? Does the figure support the conclusion? At Manusights, we built our review process around verification. Every review includes live citation checks, figure analysis, and feedback trained on patterns from 200+ pre-submission reviews. Curious what your manuscript would look like through that lens? Comment "manusights" and follow @manusights. We'll give away a free review (normally $39) to a few researchers this week.

Manusights avatar
Manusights@manusights·May 23

Save the prompts. Want the version that checks your citations and reads your figures for you? Comment "manusights" and follow, and the $29 review is free.

Three prompts you can use to surface problems in your paper before submission: Prompt 1, the skeptic: "Act as Reviewer 2 for [target journal]. You want to reject this. List the 3 things most likely to trigger a desk rejection or major revisions, most severe first, and quote the exact sentences." Prompt 2, find the contribution: "Read only my abstract. In one sentence, what is the novel contribution? If it is not clear in the first two sentences, tell me where it finally shows up." If the model has to hunt for it, so will the editor. Prompt 3, steelman the rejection: "State my main claim in one sentence. Now make the strongest argument that my evidence does not support it. Do not be nice. I am fixing this before a reviewer does." Even well-prompted, a general LLM still will not verify your citations or read your figures. If you would rather not run all of these prompts and babysit the output, try @manusights: pre-submission review trained on 35+ real peer reviewers, with live citation checks and figure analysis. It is normally a $29 review. Comment "manusights" and follow @manusights, and I will DM you one free.

Erik Jia avatar
⟳ Manusights retweeted
Erik Jia@erikinscience·May 23

Three prompts you can use to surface problems in your paper before submission: Prompt 1, the skeptic: "Act as Reviewer 2 for [target journal]. You want to reject this. List the 3 things most likely to trigger a desk rejection or major revisions, most severe first, and quote the exact sentences." Prompt 2, find the contribution: "Read only my abstract. In one sentence, what is the novel contribution? If it is not clear in the first two sentences, tell me where it finally shows up." If the model has to hunt for it, so will the editor. Prompt 3, steelman the rejection: "State my main claim in one sentence. Now make the strongest argument that my evidence does not support it. Do not be nice. I am fixing this before a reviewer does." Even well-prompted, a general LLM still will not verify your citations or read your figures. If you would rather not run all of these prompts and babysit the output, try @manusights: pre-submission review trained on 35+ real peer reviewers, with live citation checks and figure analysis. It is normally a $29 review. Comment "manusights" and follow @manusights, and I will DM you one free.

Erik Jia avatar
⟳ Manusights retweeted
Erik Jia@erikinscience·Feb 22

the peer review system is breaking down and the field is having trouble saying it out loud. it was designed for a world of maybe 100,000 papers a year. we now publish 4-5 million. there aren't enough qualified reviewers, and the ones who exist are already full-time researchers doing it for free, for journals that charge $5,000-$15,000 in APCs and return nothing. what that produces: sloppy reviews, slow turnarounds, conflicts of interest that never get disclosed, and a selection effect where the most contrarian or surprising findings get blocked by entrenched reviewers while incremental work that confirms existing beliefs sails through. the cancer immunotherapy timing paper. the GRAIL trial design. the entire replication crisis in nutrition, psychology, and social science. these aren't random failures. they're a system operating past its design limits. the answer isn't "more peer review." it's transparency, post-publication scrutiny, registered reports, and actually compensating reviewers for the work they're doing. the current system is a prestige laundering machine and we keep acting like the laundering is the point.