←
Marc Hye-Knudsen531 posts
Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar

Marc Hye-Knudsen

@marchk

PhD @AarhusUni. Research on humor.

◷ Joined May 2009▧ 209 Photos and videos
Will avatar
⟳ Marc Hye-Knudsen retweeted
Will@Evolving_Moloch·Oct 12

Dolls are incredibly widespread but not universal cross-culturally. In addition to functioning as toys, dolls are commonly used for supernatural purposes to punish enemies, heal or protect, increase fertility, or embody spirits. New paper in EHB with @NachitaRosun.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Koenfucius 🔍 avatar
⟳ Marc Hye-Knudsen retweeted
Koenfucius 🔍@koenfucius·Sep 17

Humour <huh!> what is it good for!? Well research by @marchk identifies four common comic themes across hunter-gatherer communities, suggesting it represents a response to benign violation of norms, evolved to signal and reinforce mutual trust: buff.ly/MpxPfUb

Post attachment
Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

Lots of fun tidbits like this ↓ + you’ll learn why almost all humor everywhere seems to come down to four basic themes: pain and misfortune, sex and obscenity, the foreign, and the sacred.

😸"Multiple observers report being bashfully taken aback when finding themselves on the receiving end of raunchy overtures from natives couched in humor" link.springer.com/article/10…

Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

Lots of cool stuff in this article: I track the evolution of humor from animal social play through great ape teasing to full-fledged humor as we know it, and I review all the different things that hunter-gatherers joke about and the purposes they use humor for.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

Specifically, I review 745 descriptions of humor in the ethnographic record of the ten hunter-gatherer societies in the Probability Sample Files (PSF) within the Human Relations Area Files (HRAF) World Cultures database, finding support for my account.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

To test this idea, I systematically survey what humor looks like among hunter-gatherers living in conditions like those in which our ancestors originally evolved.

Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

In other words, in humor we play around with saying and doing the wrong thing for fun, and when two people can do this without either party taking offense, imputing bad motives, or otherwise reacting negatively, that signals, and thereby reinforces, the strength of their bond.

Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

Humor, I argue, originally evolved to signal and reinforce trust and affiliation through reciprocal play with benign violations of socially charged norms and boundaries. [Summary of the paper, posted by @DegenRolf ↓]

The most common form of humor among hunter-gatherer societies is teasing, which also occurs among great apes and may have its evolutionary roots in rough-and-tumble play. Across cultures, people find many of the same things funny. Adopting a view of humor as an evolved response to benign violations, I argue that four comic themes characterize most humor across cultures: pain and misfortune, sex and obscenity, the foreign, and the sacred. [The benign violation theory of humor states that humor arises when something is perceived as a violation—wrong, threatening, or at odds with how the world ought to be—and, at the same instant, as benign: safe, acceptable, or of no real consequence.] Yet, data on humor among hunter-gatherers has remained wanting. I review 745 descriptions of humor in the ethnographic record of the ten hunter-gatherer societies. If all humans up until 10–12,000 years ago lived as hunter-gatherers, then this is in large part the environment we evolved to live in. In all ten societies, pain and misfortune was the most common theme. While each of the other four comic themes accounted for roughly a quarter of all humor descriptions (between 26 and 30%), 88% involved pain and misfortune. However, as expected, most of this was teasing, playful interpersonal violations directed at another person.. Since the other great apes are also capable of teasing, this would seem to suggest that most humor, at least as it is practiced in traditional societies, is of a kind that is not entirely unique to humans. The fact that teasing, the variety of humor that is not unique to humans, is the most common subtheme among hunter-gatherers, accounting for a majority of humor descriptions, suggests that it may have been the original form of humor. It is also the variety of humor that most resembles the rough-and-tumble play from which humor likely evolved, with the physical violations of play giving way to the more abstract interpersonal violations of teasing. Multiple descriptions of humor involved someone mocking (theme: pain and misfortune) the religion (theme: the sacred) of another culture (theme: the foreign). Foreign ethnographers studying the surveyed societies commonly describe themselves becoming the butt of humor on account of their “naïvete and ineptitude” in native affairs. However, native religious figures such as shamans may also be mocked as ineffective or frauds behind their back. In some societies, shamans are said to be acutely aware and wary of these insults.

Marc Hye-Knudsen avatar
Marc Hye-Knudsen@marchk·Sep 15

What exactly is the point of humor? I mean: Why do we have it, as a species? What is its evolutionary purpose? In a new (open access!) paper out now in Human Nature, I propose a theory and offer evidence from hunter-gatherers in support of my account.

Post attachment
Edgar Dubourg avatar
⟳ Marc Hye-Knudsen retweeted
Edgar Dubourg@EdgarDubourg·12 Aug 2025

Today’s popular fictions can be extremely far from reality: The Lord of the Rings, Avatar, The Legend of Zelda, Avengers: Endgame. But has this always been the case?

Post attachment
Recreational Fear Lab avatar
⟳ Marc Hye-Knudsen retweeted
Recreational Fear Lab@RecFearLab·16 Jun 2025

🚨 Kids LOVE fear?!🚨 Our new study led by Mihaela Taranu from the Recreational Fear Lab uncovers something surprising: Children across all ages actively seek out scary experiences - for fun! 📄link.springer.com/article/10…