←
Matt Dimick14,621 posts
Matt Dimick avatar

Matt Dimick

@mddimick

“For progress today really does mean simply the prevention and avoidance of total catastrophe.” Law, capitalism, and standard disclaimers.

◷ Joined June 2012▧ 214 Photos and videos
Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·23 Oct 2023

On the @LPEblog I contribute to the recent debate on theory launched by @samuelmoyn. I do this by addressing two questions he raises: Is capitalism "a thing"? If so, what's our theory of it? Is Capitalism “a Thing”? lpeproject.org/blog/is-capit…

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

@chrisokane_nyc made the great point (in his own book presentation) that capital does not dominate "society" so much as it is a form of (as)sociation. This caused me to make quite a few wording changes 😉

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

In brief, capital, but not the market, exhibits (1) a purpose, or "will," (2) that will is arbitrary, and (3) this will subjects workers and market-dependent others to this purpose, production for accumulation. Still a draft, so comments welcome!

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

6/7 The paper engages with the "republican Marx" or radical republicanism literature. I don't claim that Marx was a republican but that if you want to understand Marx in republican terms, this paper is the right way to do it.

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

5/7 That distinction matters because, put crudely, markets can exist without capitalism, but not vice versa. Capital presupposes the market. Capital gives market activity a very specific direction and purpose: growth, valorization, accumulation.

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

4/7 By “capital,” I do not just mean wealth or productive assets. I mean a social system in which production is organized around the self-expansion of value: producing not primarily to meet needs, but to accumulate abstract wealth.

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

3/7 My argument is that this gets something important right, but ultimately identifies the wrong “master.” If Marx’s critique of capitalism is reconstructed in the language of domination, the real target is not the market as such, but capital.

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

2/7 A common answer today is: the market. That is, competition, market dependence, market uncertainty, and/or the "uncontrollable" fact of other people’s choices and preferences.

Matt Dimick avatar
Matt Dimick@mddimick·May 5

1/7 New draft: “Capital, the Market, and Republican Domination.” A lot of people say capitalism is a form of domination. My paper asks a basic question: who (or what?) exactly is doing the dominating? papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…

LPE Blog avatar
⟳ Matt Dimick retweeted
LPE Blog@LPEblog·3 Nov 2025

Today, @mddimick argues that while antitrust may promise to tame corporate power, it leaves untouched the deeper logic of capitalism that compels production for profit’s sake. The latest in our mini-series on Marxism and Antitrust. lpeproject.org/blog/marx-ant…

Jensen Suther avatar
⟳ Matt Dimick retweeted
Jensen Suther@jensensuther·18 Oct 2025

the key to philosophical learning is not just to know a bunch of texts or how to slot in one more argument among others but to access the logical space in which those arguments are made and to learn to “free sail” among them, with “nothing over you or under you.”