←
melody3,349 posts
melody avatar

melody

@melkuo

master of fate

◷ Joined January 2011▧ 386 Photos and videos
melody avatar
melody@melkuo·11h

A timeline of immigration, how data shapes policy, and how targets can negatively shape behaviour: 2024: Recall, after a few years of unprecedented international student growth, the federal government set targets to reduce temporary residents to 5% of the population and grant permanent residency to 380,000 people per year. For context, TR population at the time was ~6-7% and PR grants were ~500k a year. The thinking was that by lowering overall PR targets, it would be harder for temporary workers in the country to have a viable path to permanent residency, and many would voluntarily leave. 2025 - early 2026: StatsCan population data seemed to suggest that this was working! There were steady drops in TRs every quarter. Earlier this year, it seemed like our population would actually decrease this year. September 2026: Curveball – StatsCan issues a major revision. They update their population counting methodology to include Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) data, ie counting people who actually crossed the border. It turns out that we have 240,000 more temporary residents still in the country than previously thought. This is because permit holders whose documents were expiring had applied for extensions, and were still legally in Canada while awaiting a decision. Previously, they they were assumed to have just left. These 240k extra people meant that the feds were further from the 5% target than they thought (see image). November 2026: The new immigration plan is released. The feds continue to hold the course on targeting 5% TR population and granting 380k PRs per year. Except! There's an additional 200k PRs being given out. This is a time-limited measure and is separate from the main PR target. It also lines up pretty well with the 240k extra people in the country... --- So I think we can now deduce why this was done. There are about 200k more TRs in the country than previously thought. We can: 1. Do nothing. Let them move through the system, qualifying for a PR or leaving voluntarily eventually. But, this would mean that the 5% target will take much longer to achieve. 2. Convert them to PRs. This will reduce the proportion of TRs in the country, allowing us to get closer to the 5% target. These people are already here, we just need to change their immigration status. But this would drastically increase the "380k PRs per year" target. 3. Convert them to PRs, but through a separate accounting measure. This lets all the "topline" targets stay the same and keep progress towards them. For the record, I think this separate time-limited target is bad. What we need to have above all is understanding in the system. But I also think that if all critics are going to focus on are certain numbers, well, you get what you ask for.

Post attachment
Dan Seljak avatar
⟳ melody retweeted
Dan Seljak@anotherglassbox·Nov 17

Did anyone else notice that between the haze this AM and the low sun, the CN tower was casting a shadow UP???

Post attachment
melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 13

That we can't easily agree on what is even happening – how many people are here, in what status – is perhaps the biggest problem with the system right now

Okay, let's do that. Here's the actual numbers for inflows. There were 495,000 in total, along with 584,000 outflows. That's nowhere near the net -445,000 in the Levels Plan.

Post attachment
melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 12

jensen gets ousted for sleeping with a subordinate meanwhile elon gets a pass – again with the different standards for africans

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 10

Some thoughts on London as someone visiting from Toronto: 1. I truly do not understand how young people make it here without family wealth. Housing and food are so expensive and salaries are lower to boot. 2. Globalism has made it extremely easy to eat "authentic" cuisines in any decently-sized city around the world. As such, I have no interest in eating "really good Vietnamese". I have that at home. What's the thing I can only eat here? What actually makes you unique in this world? 3. British food gets a worse rap than it deserves. When it's good it's great. Full english breakfasts, meat pies, pasties, Sunday roasts. The problem is that it's easy to make, and frequently experienced, as mediocre. 4. They consistently know how to make good potatoes here. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. 5. I truly believe that you have experience things yourself to really understand it. For example, you might hear someone say "the beans really bring the whole thing together" and nod along, but it's not until you eat a proper full english breakfast that you're like "mm yes the beans really do bring the whole thing together." 6. It's incredibly grounding to be surrounded by layers and layers and layers of history. So much has come before us to bring us to where we are. 7. It is quite a moving place to be around Remembrance Day. To visit the war museum, see sites of historical importance, watch the ceremonies. The poppy takes on an entirely different meaning. Not only is it to commemorate veterans, but its a symbol of unity. Two sides of an ocean, Canadians and Brits wear poppies, remembering that our countries fought side-by-side, from the very beginning, together. 8. The urbanism is fantastic. Pedestrian-friendly, mature tree-lined streets, beautiful facades. Canadians may wave this away and say, "These cities were built before cars." But even new neighbourhoods like Canary Wharf are very pleasantly designed. Planning in Toronto is very broken. The guidelines and rules we've set lead to bad results. And the frustrating this is that it's all a choice. 9. It is wonderful to be able to pick two neighbourhoods on a map and have a decent transit connection between them. 10. You never see anti-social behaviour on transit. They are constantly running these PSAs over the speakers to text a number if you see anything. "See it. Say it. Sorted." I love it so much. Particularly the "sorted" and the accountability that the system takes on. Interestingly, I also heard a PSA that was like, "If someone asks you for money, donate to a charity instead." Extremely based to encourage the public to deter this behaviour. 11. There is no consensus for if pedestrians should walk on the right or the left. Maddening. 12. I do not understand how Brits get the reputation for loving to queue. I had some downright egregious experiences. Canadians are way more polite and respectful. 13. I have yet to see a child glued to a device. On transit, they're looking out the window, reading, or drawing. Curious if anyone knows why?

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 9

Telling my husband to not fall for the honeypot any time he talks to another woman

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 8

There’s also this transit PSA that’s like, “If you see a homeless person or someone asks you for money, donate to a charity instead.” Really makes you think.

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 8

On the London transit, they’re always playing this PSA that’s like: If you see unusual behaviour, text this number. See it. Say it. Sorted. I like it a lot. Particularly the “sorted”.

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 7

One of the interesting things about London is I think it just has a higher baseline expectation of its people. Ex: - Walk up and down the stairs of a moving double decker bus - No railings along the canal - Streets are not as brightly lit at night

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 5

We used to make sculptures of the gods. Now we make sculptures of overweight men from the streets.

Post attachmentPost attachment
krishn avatar
⟳ melody retweeted
krishn@KrishnRamesh·Nov 4

Dems may be less openly hostile to us but they’re still going to choose America-first (as they should). we gotta continue pursuing our own growth agenda to secure our sovereignty and prosperity

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 3

I like that every bus stop is labelled with a letter, which is part of Google Maps. Makes it very easy to know if you’re at the right one / right direction.

Post attachment
melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 3

Being in London has been a nice reminder that public transit doesn’t have to be bad

melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 2

The aversion to this is a classic example of people preferring organized systems over solving actual human problems. It's a clear win for people to get more daylight. Who cares if the map doesn't look orderly.

As of today until March 14, the North American time zone map looks like this. 🌎

Post attachment
melody avatar
melody@melkuo·Nov 1

I am glad to see this investment into building the Canadian Pacific Rail. It is obvious to me that rail is the bedrock for future economic activity and prosperity. And yet, as Canadians know, the US is massively ahead in expanding its rail network. We should treat this an inspiration for what we can achieve, but also a threat to our security and sovereignty if we do not act. Imagine the future where trillions of things can move around the world everyday, but Canadians had to go through the US to ship anything. Not only does this stunt our economy, but critical supplies could be at threat of foreign interference. We should not let our country be dependent on foreign trade routes, at the whim of foreign economies. Building this rail is a matter of securing our country’s sovereignty.

Cohere@cohereOct 30

We’re expanding our commitment to Canada 🇨🇦 Cohere is advancing plans to invest more than C$4 billion in R&D and AI infrastructure and create over 1,500 jobs through 2031.