
A timeline of immigration, how data shapes policy, and how targets can negatively shape behaviour: 2024: Recall, after a few years of unprecedented international student growth, the federal government set targets to reduce temporary residents to 5% of the population and grant permanent residency to 380,000 people per year. For context, TR population at the time was ~6-7% and PR grants were ~500k a year. The thinking was that by lowering overall PR targets, it would be harder for temporary workers in the country to have a viable path to permanent residency, and many would voluntarily leave. 2025 - early 2026: StatsCan population data seemed to suggest that this was working! There were steady drops in TRs every quarter. Earlier this year, it seemed like our population would actually decrease this year. September 2026: Curveball – StatsCan issues a major revision. They update their population counting methodology to include Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) data, ie counting people who actually crossed the border. It turns out that we have 240,000 more temporary residents still in the country than previously thought. This is because permit holders whose documents were expiring had applied for extensions, and were still legally in Canada while awaiting a decision. Previously, they they were assumed to have just left. These 240k extra people meant that the feds were further from the 5% target than they thought (see image). November 2026: The new immigration plan is released. The feds continue to hold the course on targeting 5% TR population and granting 380k PRs per year. Except! There's an additional 200k PRs being given out. This is a time-limited measure and is separate from the main PR target. It also lines up pretty well with the 240k extra people in the country... --- So I think we can now deduce why this was done. There are about 200k more TRs in the country than previously thought. We can: 1. Do nothing. Let them move through the system, qualifying for a PR or leaving voluntarily eventually. But, this would mean that the 5% target will take much longer to achieve. 2. Convert them to PRs. This will reduce the proportion of TRs in the country, allowing us to get closer to the 5% target. These people are already here, we just need to change their immigration status. But this would drastically increase the "380k PRs per year" target. 3. Convert them to PRs, but through a separate accounting measure. This lets all the "topline" targets stay the same and keep progress towards them. For the record, I think this separate time-limited target is bad. What we need to have above all is understanding in the system. But I also think that if all critics are going to focus on are certain numbers, well, you get what you ask for.
















