←
Ed Grimshaw22,082 posts
Ed Grimshaw avatar

Ed Grimshaw

@mindmodeller

Fifty years studying form. Racing analytics, probability models & systems thinking on UK racing governance. Racing should own its own market.

◷ Joined April 2011▧ 1,838 Photos and videos
Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Oct 30

Dear @BHAHorseracing, You rushed to defend the fruit machine. Racing never needed it. Shops: down a third, 9,000 to 5,825. Levy: up, £65m to £108m. Punters get restricted, closed, funds locked and an auto-email is all you get. We ARE your customers. Who are you working for? #OpenLetter #HorseRacing #Budget2026 @Macbet1972 @AtTheRaces cuttingcomment.com/dear-bha-…

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·1h

A committee promoted itself to a commission. It cost one noun and no votes and managed to get past @CompaniesHouse The Gambling Policy Committee Limited AKA Commission has no statutory powers, one named funder and a budget it won't disclose. It wants racing's evidence by 12 February. My advice: send it a blank postcard. Five reasons in my piece below. Should racing hand its numbers to a body no minister or civil servant has to read? cuttingcomment.com/a-committ… #horseracing @RacingPost @itvracing @AKBets #GamblingX @nickgoff79 @NJ_Timothy @SMFthinktank @GamRegGB

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·10h

Put Britain's four big betting firms into one index, weighted by size, and £100 invested in November 2021 is now worth about £39, dividends included. Most of that went in the last 12 months: the index was about 98 in December and is about 39 now. This is the industry taking roughly £432m a year more from punters than in 2018/19. Higher take, tighter limits, more restrictions, and still the value drains away. Is the model breaking, and when it does, who pays: shareholders, punters, or racing? Should the bookmaking industry look for better representation than the Betting and Gaming Council, who have failed at every turn? #horseracing @BetGameCouncil @FlatStats

Post attachment
Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 15

More than half of the £432m rise in bookmakers' take since 2018/19 sits outside the starting price. The SP overround is worth up to about £200m a year, at this year's rate. The levy maths points to a £432m gap on today's betting. The rest is customer limits, early prices and each-way terms, promotions, and results. We cannot see the split, because those figures have not been published. If racing lives off a levy on that profit and media rights, should the split be in the open? #horseracing @AtTheRaces #GamblingX

InsidetheStable avatar
⟳ Ed Grimshaw retweeted
InsidetheStable@Insidethe2025·Nov 14

A lot of what you say is spot on Ed. The kit the courses use is prehistoric, tractor/hose/small pump - they have never had to invest in this, they need to now. They get a fortune per ficture and compare this to Football/cricket even golf, the the sport needs to catch up.

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 14

Cheltenham's ground row has reached the November meeting. Willie Mullins says firm Festival ground jarred up his horses. Dan Skelton pulled Kabral Du Mathan and Madara this week because it was too quick, even after watering. The clerk says his job is safe jumping ground, not ground that suits every horse. Here's the uncomfortable bit. Nobody has published a single number to settle it. No going stick readings in the open, no watering logs, no injury rates by going. So it comes down to who shouts loudest. And the loudest voices belong to the biggest yards. If "firm" ground really is a welfare problem, prove it with data. If it isn't, it's lobbying. Welfare issue or big yards wanting their ground? Which is it? #horseracing #BritishRacing #Cheltenham #PaddyPowerGoldCup @RacingPost

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 13

Willie Mullins says firm ground at the Festival jarred up his horses, and warns big owners may go to Aintree or Punchestown instead if Cheltenham doesn't water more. Is he hiding behind his owners? Fair point about welfare? Or the most powerful trainer in jump racing telling a racecourse how to prepare its ground to suit his horses? Ground should be set for every runner, not for the biggest yard. Who should decide the going at Cheltenham: the clerk, the trainers, or the BHA? #horseracing #BritishRacing #Cheltenham @RacingPost @LydiaHislop

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 12

Yesterday a trainer who admitted deliberately misleading the BHA with a doctored email was fined £2,000, with her licence ban suspended. Last month a champion trainer was fined £1,100 after his runner at the Cheltenham Festival had an undeclared prohibited substance in its body. A stable employee who took £1,950 for inside information got two years out of the sport. Who does the rulebook actually bite? #BritishRacing #horseracing @PJAOfficial @RacingPost

A stable employee paid £1,950 for inside information: two years out of the sport. A trainer found to have misled the BHA over a £42,033 payment: a £6,000 fine. Does the BHA penalise everyone equally, or does it depend on who you are? Are jockeys, trainers, and racecourses treated proportionately, or is there a hierarchy and underlying bias from the BHA in its governance of the sport? #BritishRacing #horseracing @BHAHorseracing @RacehorseOwners @NTFnews @PJAOfficial

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 11

A stable employee paid £1,950 for inside information: two years out of the sport. A trainer found to have misled the BHA over a £42,033 payment: a £6,000 fine. Does the BHA penalise everyone equally, or does it depend on who you are? Are jockeys, trainers, and racecourses treated proportionately, or is there a hierarchy and underlying bias from the BHA in its governance of the sport? #BritishRacing #horseracing @BHAHorseracing @RacehorseOwners @NTFnews @PJAOfficial

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 10

The statutory levy was sold as money to cut gambling harm. Some groups are now reported to be considering a judicial review of how the prevention pot is being handed out. The prior question is whether anyone can show the spending works. In April, OHID provisionally allocated £25.4m to 33 organisations. Its updated list last week shows £39.7m to 40, about £14m more, published after a period of legal challenges. No reason for the increase has been given. One of the later awards is £2.7m to Gamban. It was excluded in April as a limited company and is now funded, reportedly as a social enterprise. OHID has not publicly explained what changed. No full impact assessment was produced for the Gambling Levy Regulations 2025. OHID says it is still building the evidence base on what works in prevention. NICE found no economic evidence on interventions to improve access to gambling treatment. Before the next fight over who gets the money, will OHID publish the scores, and the evidence that this spending reduces harm? @OHID @GamRegGB @GambleWithLives @BetGameCouncil @SMFthinktank @HarryStewartMo1

Groups mull judicial review after latest statutory levy funding award: An upcoming legal challenge will argue the commissioning of gambling harms funds should be taken away from OHID . Read More ⬇️  go.next.io/4k2fOC9

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 10

Betting on British racing is down 37.5% since 2018/19, after inflation. Bookmakers' profit from racing is up 3.6%. How can both be true? Bookmakers pay a levy of 10% of their racing profit, meaning stakes minus winnings paid out. Multiply the levy by ten and you get roughly what they make from racing. Divide that by total stakes and you get what they keep from every £100 bet. In 2018/19 they kept £5.86 of every £100. Now it's £9.71. At the old £5.86, today's smaller betting would earn them about £657m. The levy points to about £1,089m. That £432m difference is what the wider margin is worth on today's betting. So a third less betting, and much the same profit. Customer limits, prices, promotions and results all play a part. Only the bookmakers' own figures can show how much each contributes, and they should publish them. Which do you think matters most? #horseracingtips #HorseRacing @RacingPost @japantimes @RacehorseOwners @NTFnews @BHAHorseracing

Post attachment
Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 9

Every great act eventually acquires a tribute band: same songs, similar wigs, and a name just close enough that your aunt books tickets by mistake. On Monday, Britain’s gambling regulator got one.

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 9

cuttingcomment.com/commissio… The pattern: praise racing, tax the bookmakers who fund it, then express surprise when they stop. A carve-out from a commission majority-owned by the co-author of the £100 cap is not a lifeboat. It is a complimentary deckchair. @GamRegGB @AKBets @BetGameCouncil @geoffbanksbet #horseracingtips @BHAHorseracing @NTFnews #GamblingX

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 9

Betting per race, 2020–25: Bookmakers promoting Horseracing, you are joking! 🇯🇵 Japan +20% 🇮🇪 Ireland +16% (Tote only) 🇫🇷 France +2% 🇬🇧 Britain −36% Britain is the only one in sustained decline. Even from 2021, after the Covid bump, it's down a fifth. That's online turnover per BHA race, so read it as the direction rather than an exact figure. Field sizes, prices, account restrictions, too many fixtures: what's driving it? To blame the black market would do nothing to create a healthy one. #HorseRacing #RacingData @RacingPost @BetGameCouncil

Post attachment
Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 8

The biggest change isn’t the amount of data. It’s being able to build a rating and test it against the market, rather than simply trust somebody else’s number. What tool or method have you stopped using because the results didn’t justify your confidence in it? System builder gives the confidence in the numbers with a full blown analysis in several dimensions

Ed Grimshaw avatar
Ed Grimshaw@mindmodeller·Nov 8

More data. Better bets—or just more confidence? From Phil Bull’s stopwatch and @Timeform to @proform_racing, RaceMetrics and AI, the tools have changed. The test hasn’t: finding value the odds have missed. Which advance has actually improved your betting—and which just added noise? cuttingcomment.com/the-horse… #HorseRacing #RacingData @RacingPost #GamblingX