Building a company is a confrontational act.
Introducing Knuckle Up: conversations with people who’ve operated at the highest level.
Recruiting. Culture. Intensity. The inner game of being a CEO.
First episode with Frank Slootman drops today.
Trailer ↓
The most contrarian thing you can do in SF: turn off the group chats and go make things.
@qasar on why that's even harder for investors than for founders:
"If you're a founder specifically and you're bringing a new company into the market, almost by definition, you have to have a different view...
I think the best way to be contrarian is actually do as much as you can to create and do things and make things, rather than just consume things from your peers. Ironic thing to say on a podcast... The whole drinks crowd and everyone constantly texting each other group chats about what's going on. Try to turn that noise off a little bit...
Investors are sometimes the worst at this. I think group chats have made people hundreds of millions and lost hundreds of millions of dollars, just because you ask a buddy, well, what do you think about company X that's raising at maybe a crazy price? ...And they're like, oh, that person isn't very good. And that's it. And they might be thinking of a different Rohit or a different Rohan...
I think it's even harder to be a contrarian investor actually than it is to be a contrarian founder."
Don't ship a minimum viable product. Ship a minimum awesome one.
@grinich on why you only get one shot with a developer:
"The minimum viable product, which is like ship early and ship often and get stuff out and get feedback from customers... It's generally the right sentiment. But the counterpoint here is that people are really busy in the world and you really only get one shot. Especially with developers, their first experience with your product ends up becoming a defining brand moment for you as an organization. You don't have that many of them.
And so for us, when we build product, we actually try to make something that's notably impressive. It doesn't mean it needs to be done, like feature complete everywhere. It's just a certain part of it has to be impressive. It has to be different. It has to be unique.
And I think if we can't discover that or articulate it, we usually don't understand the market well enough. We don't understand the product well enough... Maybe we shouldn't build it. I think we're only really in the business of doing things that other people aren't doing."
"Think of AI as a Ferrari: the speed is thrilling but it’s also dangerous if you skimp on good tires and responsive brakes.
Attacks now move at machine speed, while cyber patches and legacy defenses still move only at human speed. You have to plan to recover at machine speed, to be resilient."
2 tests for whether an exec has plateaued:
1. Look one layer below them. Could those people do the exec's job?
2. Are they delivering, with no excuses?
Mercury's @immad:
"I'd say honestly, it becomes pretty obvious by the time you make that decision, and you're normally like, wow, I should have decided a while ago...
I find that the best execs, you look one layer below them and you're like, wow, these people could do your job... They normally have two people there, at least, maybe three people, that you're like, wow, these are amazing leaders of the company.
...The higher up a company you go in the chain, the less excuses you can have. Me as a CEO, I have no excuse. If something's going wrong, it's my fault. But I think it's the same one level lower...
I don't care how good your reports are. You could do these amazing presentations. I don't care... I don't think execs can have excuses. The job is to deliver on that."
10 takeaways from my conversation with @paraga, founder of @p0 and former CEO of Twitter.
From a happy-go-lucky kid chasing hard problems to running Twitter to building search for AI agents.
Which one would you push back on?
Akshay Kothari's playbook at Notion, run on function after function:
1. Do the job yourself first
2. Hire the next couple of ICs, and learn the function through recruiting
3. Build the right system
4. Hire a leader and take yourself out of the job
By 2023, one of Notion's co-founders had zero direct reports.
@akothari on why that's underrated:
"I sort of run after the problems, sort of the biggest problems we have inside the company. I try to do that job myself first. Once I feel like I understand the job, then I spend time hiring the next couple ICs. And actually through the recruiting process, I learn even more about that problem or that function.
...Once I feel like, okay, we're doing the right thing, we've built the right system... I try to hire a leader and nuke myself out of that job. And I've done this many times over. There was a year, 2023, where I had zero reports...
It's actually kind of crazy underrated to have a founder that is an individual contributor, because essentially for me, my only optimization function is Notion winning. I don't care about who reports to me. I don't care about any of the underlying bureaucracy or politics companies have. For me, I'll just run after the problem I see companies facing, and I will try to fix it, and then I will hand it over to the right person who wants to lead it."
An interview tells you how someone comes across. Their bosses, reports and peers tell you how they actually work.
Frank Slootman on why the real picture comes from back-channel references, and the one "trouble" answer he likes to hear:
"What you're getting from an interview is a vibe, which is a word we use a lot lately with AI. But a vibe is just a feeling, an impression, a sense, and it matters...
But you can only find out about people for real... by talking to superiors they've had, subordinates they've had, and peers they've had. One of my favorite questions is that most people in their careers have had trouble with either superiors, subordinates, or peers. Which one did you have?
...People sometimes ask me, what about you? I had trouble with peers. Never had trouble with superiors or with subordinates. And the reason that happens is ambitious people will start to clash, because everybody has their own sandbox... And you assume great ownership, which often people in the organization don't like when you do that. So that's actually an answer that I like when I hear that. But your trouble with subordinates, that's usually not what you want to hear.
...When you talk to enough people, the pictures start to really solidify and crystallize. You really get a good sense of what you're dealing with."
From the outside, Decagon looks like a straight line: 450+ people and a $4.5B valuation in three years. Inside, like any other company, the founders are used to dealing with fires all the time.
@AshwinSreenivas on the part nobody sees, and what Frank Slootman told him:
"There's been probably a thousand of those, in every company. The thing about every company is, from the outside, everything looks amazing. But I guarantee you, every fast-growing company, probably without a single exception, they've had a thousand fires internally...
The person that you hired, that you thought was amazing, wasn't, and then they messed a lot of things up. The deal that you thought was a for-sure thing, that you were going to win, that you built a lot around, you lose at the last minute...
I know you had Frank Slootman on your podcast a while ago. Jesse and I were talking to him maybe two weeks ago... Snowflake was his third company that he scaled, and he was like, 'You know what? I was anxious the entire time, because there were always things blowing up.'
And so for us, we're also like, okay, this is someone that has built three generational companies, was also anxious the entire time. It's just normal. That's just how it is."
An interview test worth stealing: start a little late on purpose, and watch who stays calm.
@CameronLMcCord on adding friction to the interview day at Nominal:
"I think it's powerful to sometimes insert some friction into the interview process. I'm making lots of submarine stories now, but this is one where intentionally starting a little bit late, or potentially having an IT issue, not being able to set up... They're small things, but it can get someone really flustered. And you can really easily see who can take a deep breath and kind of roll with the punches.
And so if we have a suspicion, maybe from a phone screen... person's amazing, but are they a little too rough around the edges, or are they going to be too bombastic...
You can actually seed situations and scenarios on an interview day where you can suss out how that person will respond."
When marketing copy costs nothing to produce, the bottleneck moves to the one thing ChatGPT can't know about your company.
@thejamescad on why founders are now the API between reality and AI:
"Ideas. Original ideas. How do you tell the thing that knows everything something it doesn't know?
...I bet if I asked Chat or Claude a bunch of questions, it would give me a better answer about your own business than you would. But there are things that you know about Audacious right now that Chat and Claude simply don't know, because they have not experienced what it's like to step into your office. They've not experienced what it's like to do a deal with you.
You're an API between reality and AI at this point. The way in which AI understands your business comes through you.
...It sounds a bit trite when I say ideas are the limiting factor, but it's really your ability to communicate reality, or reality as you want it to be, with a very sophisticated intelligence."
.@paraga on the shift you have to make when you become CEO after being an exec at the company:
"You no longer try to adapt yourself to the company. You challenge yourself, but you adapt the company to who you are.
If you are trying to fit into somebody else's shoes, you're not going to create the best version of the company. You're doing injustice to the potential of the company.
You have to own the thing and own yourself."
.@paraga on where the alpha in hiring comes from:
"The best people want to be hired for things that are a challenge. If they have been there, done that, do they want to do that thing again? Or do they want a new challenge, which will push them on a journey to learn and grow?
That is what you mean by alpha. You have to make bets on people which feel like bets.
Now you also have to pull a team of outliers together. So for the people who build those teams, I want to see evidence they've done it, and then I challenge them on a different dimension they might not have encountered.
Early special teams are built off taking bespoke individuals and creating something out of that."
Most founders get more stressed as the company gets bigger. Immad Akhund built Mercury to work the other way.
@immad on why he could take a three-year swing on a new bank, and why the pressure should go down as success goes up:
"I have a relatively poor background. My parents were on welfare and we moved to the UK with very little... I just wanted to survive. There was definitely a phase where it was just survival and I was fine with any exit.
...I started the company and I was like, maybe this will take three years before I raise anything else or get to product market fit. And I was really committed... There's no way you could take that three-year big swing if you have a much more scarcity mindset.
...If you are always grateful for what you've achieved and you do think about it as, 'Oh, this is the bonus level'... I've tried to make it so the pressure goes down as success goes up, which I think is actually relatively rare. If you're more successful, why are you more stressed about it?"