
BIP-54 is being pushed so much by Bitcoin Core for one simple reason: the "timewarp attack" is not an attack but, if coordinated correctly by miners, a potential scaling solution that Bitcoin Core is afraid of. With enough miners on board (my calculations show that around a 90% supermajority is required), it's possible to "trick" Bitcoin's clock into ticking N times faster in a stable (!) way. So, instead of blocks coming up every 10 minutes on average, they could come up, say, every 5 minutes, doubling the throughput and improving the user experience. Yes, this may have the side effect of the block subsidy running out a bit faster, but considering that Bitcoin's already got a security budget issue, this would be a) a nice instant temporary remedy, and b) a long-term solution due to the possibility of collecting more fees thanks to the increased throughput. The "timewarp attack" vector by itself is purely theoretical nonsense. It either requires a 51% majority that would orphan "non-participating" blocks or a 90% supermajority. It's visible on-chain and requires weeks to get activated. So, "remaining block subsidy could be mined in roughly 40 days" is a bogeyman. A quick reminder: Bitcoin requires at least 51% of its miners to be "honest". Otherwise, it simply doesn't work, and a "timewarp attack" would be the least of our concerns in case of a 51% attack. Okay, back to scaling! Best thing about this approach? It doesn't require any kind of fork: neither hard nor soft. The possibility is already in the code. Considering that Bitcoin has huge issues with upgrades, it can be the last chance to actually scale Bitcoin. Instead, Bitcoin Core wants to remove that possibility. Why? Because they still push for their defunct Lightning. Who are the authors of BIP-54? @darosior who works for Chaincode Labs and @TheBlueMatt who is a Blockstream co-founder. A clear conflict of interest to benefit Lightning. @foundryservices, @AntPoolofficial, @f2pool, @ViaBTC, @SpiderPool_com, @MARA, @luxor, take notes! Do I need to spin up an explainer website with details and charts? 🤔
I don’t support BIP-54.





















