
A creator asks for $1,000. You offer $500. What are the chances they accept? Probably higher than you think. We looked at negotiations across 10k unique creators at @1stcollab to help brands make better offers. Here’s what stood out: 1. As expected, acceptance rates fall sharply as brands request larger discounts Using approximate discount levels: • 10% discount → 78% acceptance • 50% discount → 39% acceptance • 90% discount → 6% acceptance That said, there’s still a chance, even with a steep discount. 2. A low offer can still start a conversation. At a 70% discount, over 50% of creators still submitted a counter offer. Your opening offer doesn’t have to close the deal to move the conversation forward. 3. More expensive creators hold firmer on price. A roughly 10% discount showed almost no drop in acceptance for creators asking $2,500 or less. For creators asking over $2,500, acceptance was nearly 30% lower. 4. Rebook sooner if you want to keep the same rate. Same-deal acceptance was about 80% within 1–3 months of the prior contract signing. That fell to 66% at 3–6 months and 50% at 6–12 months. The tradeoff behind all of this: better rates require more outreach. Negotiating aggressively can stretch your creator budget. But you’ll need more sourcing, outreach, negotiations and time spent on the campaign to fill your campaign. In our latest post, we share the findings and practical tips for putting them to work: how to set offers, plan outreach, and balance performance with scale and your team’s time. Read the full breakdown here: 1stcollab.com/blog/creator-n… How do you decide what rates to offer creators?










