←
Jack Pardoe6,661 posts
Jack Pardoe avatar

Jack Pardoe

@pardoejw
◷ Joined October 2018▧ 997 Photos and videos
Stephen Stapczynski avatar
⟳ Jack Pardoe retweeted
Stephen Stapczynski@SStapczynski·Nov 9

GOOD NEWS FOR EUROPE? 🇪🇺 👍 China’s domestic natural gas prices are weakening, curbing the world’s biggest LNG importer’s appetite for expensive seaborne shipments This could free-up more LNG supplies for rival importers in Europe and Asia bloomberg.com/news/articles/…

Stephen Stapczynski avatar
⟳ Jack Pardoe retweeted
Stephen Stapczynski@SStapczynski·Nov 5

📉 European gas selloff 📉 Futures are down 18% this week due in part to Trump saying he has no immediate plans to strike Iran. There were fears of renewed escalation after the midterms Still, fundamentals remain the same. Hormuz disrupted and EU inventories low

Post attachment
Sam Richards avatar
⟳ Jack Pardoe retweeted
Sam Richards@sjarichards·Nov 4

Further thoughts on whether the Government is serious about taking costs off energy bills: For years governments of different parties built a shadow tax system; quietly piling policy, grid, and other costs onto consumer bills. While our most pressing problem this winter is the cost of gas, we’ve now added so many levies to bills that cheaper gas alone wouldn’t solve our energy woes. In fact, households won't even see the full benefit if wholesale costs fall, as the top-ups we pay to renewables will mechanically increase. Ministers need to tackle the whole bill. The Chancellor’s promise to fund new projects via bills only if they cut costs is therefore both significant and welcome. The immediate test of whether he really means it is the upcoming renewables auction, Allocation Round Eight (AR8). The Treasury have explicitly said the new approach will apply to the next auction. Five questions will determine whether they mean what they say. 1. What costs will count? The obvious place to start is the renewable energy contracts themselves. Contracts for Difference (CfDs) guarantee generators an agreed price: when the wholesale price falls below it, we all fund the difference on our bills. When it rises above it, generators pay us back. This hedge paid off after Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, and could prove handy again this year with gas prices high and rising. Around £346 million net was paid back by CfD generators during 2022. More often than not however, these payments have flowed the other way. According to the House of Commons Library, CfDs added around £180 to a typical household’s electricity bills between April 2019 and May 2026, even after accounting for periods when generators paid back. But these contracts are only part of what consumers pay. New renewable generation is distributed, it means lots of new transmission lines, additional balancing services, and payments to manage bottlenecks. When wind farms produce more power than the grid can handle, we end up both paying them to turn off, and also paying gas generators to replace their output. Last year these curtailment costs added well over £1bn to bills, this year they could hit £4bn, and the government’s own modelling suggests this figure could reach around £7bn by the end of the decade. Those costs - alongside the benefits - should be included. Renewable generation can reduce wholesale prices when it displaces gas. Grid upgrades can reduce existing bottlenecks. The right test is therefore the additional cost or saving across the whole bill. Looking only at the strike price of a renewable contract would miss the exact problems the Chancellor says he wants to address. 2. Cheaper than what? A claim that a project “lowers bills” doesn’t mean that much without explaining the alternative. How does the new offshore wind farm stack up vs a new gas plant, or against new nuclear after the much-promised, but yet to be delivered, Fingleton reforms have been implemented? The status quo is so bad that it represents a terrible baseline to judge future projects against. Ministers should properly test the alternatives, including both what they could cost and when they could actually deliver power. At the same time, assumptions about future gas prices, electricity demand and grid delivery of course all matter. Ministers should publish their central estimates and show whether the proposed savings from a new deal survive cheaper gas, slower demand growth or delayed pylons. 3. What contract price would they count as a cost saving? Once ministers have answered the first two questions, they should be able to give a clear number for the CfD strike price they’re willing to pay. This might vary project by project, with lower CfDs required for those that create greater additional grid or balancing costs. Ministers should set out the maximum prices they believe will cut bills, publish the supporting analysis, and explain how those limits determine the auction budget. 4. How much wiggle room does the “security of supply” component offer? The Chancellor has given himself a get out clause by saying additional policy costs must lower bills *or be essential to keeping the lights on.* Yet what are the criteria for this security-of-supply caveat? Almost any project can be justified on these grounds if you squint hard enough. Ministers will need to show their working so independent experts can scrutinise it: why would a particular project be needed and why could it not be replaced by another option? Without this discipline, we could end up in exactly the same position, but with a new energy security justification for adding ever more costs to bills. 5. Ultimately: will ministers accept a smaller, or even an empty, auction? Quite simply: if projects fail to pass a properly constructed and scrutinised affordability test, the government must be willing not to buy them. If none pass the test, ministers should be prepared to award no contracts unless procurement is justified by a clear and independently verifiable security need. AR5 offers something of a precedent. Ministers held to a price ceiling and in the end secured no offshore wind bids. While it was criticised at the time, in hindsight the subsequent sky-high prices demonstrate it was the right call to let that auction fail. That does not mean failure at AR8 is inevitable. Judged against the alternatives, renewable projects may deliver net savings once all costs and benefits are counted. We need the bids and the analysis to know. The Chancellor has set out what appears to be a significant shift in energy policy. Moving on from the Miliband era’s approach on hitting deployment targets at almost any cost is hugely welcome. AR8 will reveal whether the Chancellor is willing to follow through. Show your working, and let our energy policy follow the evidence.

I'm about to publish a piece on "can we take the Government seriously when they say they will no longer load policy costs onto energy bills?" and 7 days after the "no new levies" Budget they've published a Bill that includes a hydrogen levy on energy bills

Sam Dumitriu avatar
⟳ Jack Pardoe retweeted
Sam Dumitriu@Sam_Dumitriu·Oct 31

In the 1930s, you could get planning permission to build a block of 12 flats in 3 weeks (and a 3 page application). It is sensible to use AI to speed up over-complex processes, but it is no substitute for fixing the process.

Nearly 70% of planning applications are for everyday home improvements. By cutting paperwork and admin with AI tool PlanAssist, we're aiming to slash processing times from 8 weeks down to 4. Less bureaucracy, faster answers for families, and getting Britain building 🏠 🇬🇧

0:55
David Galbraith avatar
⟳ Jack Pardoe retweeted
David Galbraith@daveg·Oct 31

Residents of my parents' village have managed to eradicate road markings and it makes a big difference to the character.

Post attachment
Michael Hill avatar
⟳ Jack Pardoe retweeted
Michael Hill@Michael_J_Hil·Oct 31

In a better world the big developers would be forced to up their game because skilled small builders would be providing real competition. Our planning system means big developers instead spend on lawyers and consultants and the smaller builders don't get to build at all.

The average new-build property has 130 defects, according to specialist inspection company HomeSnag. I visited one with Tom Britton and his team to find out why so many of Britain's shiny new homes are scarcely fit for purpose. Read: telegraph.co.uk/money/proper… Credit: @HomeSnag

0:44
Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

We have 3/3 ingredients, so we can get the CCL in place by the spending review, using the upcoming Energy Independence Bill. This could be a turning point in British energy policy, towards a system that works for the country rather than being a bill-raising money printer. 👏

Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

Side note: In return for bringing the state's balance sheet into infrastructure delivery like this, clearly the state will want more say on costs. That appears to me what GB Grid is about: using state muscle to bust open monopolistic networks to competition. Also great.

Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

What's necessary for the 10 Year Plan is a financing ratio between taxpayers and billpayers, as well as general cost discipline. Cost discipline will naturally increase with more transparency over costs. I've written what that control could look like. substack.com/@pardoejw/p-222…

Post attachment
Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

But levy reform is another area where the government will need to be really bold. There's no getting around the fact it'll now cost money to lower bills. The Cost Control Framework can't just be about preventing wasteful procurement. It's been tried twice, it doesn't last.

Post attachment
Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

Evidence of this is cancelling the Gas Shippers Levy - the levy for subsidising hydrogen projects that households were simply never going to benefit from. The principle that we shouldn't place regressive levies on bills to fund industrial projects is very welcome.

Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

The turn to sorting out the levies is also fantastic. The Treasury appears to have identified that allowing a shadow tax system to develop on bills (in fairness to the Conservatives, a practice done before and after them) is in fact bad for growth.

Post attachment
Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

Banning projects behind constraints (projects often from the same companies that build the grid, who historically profit from under-delivery of grid) is good. It'll *prevent* some further bill rises. But market reform is necessary to actually cut bills from where we are.

Jack Pardoe avatar
Jack Pardoe@pardoejw·Oct 31

We'll never get to competitive electricity prices while we allow our market to be so wasteful, bloating (along with other factors) grid upgrade costs. Key stat: today’s electricity and gas grid companies are 20-25 times more expensive than in the post-war years.

Post attachment