
Not your legal title, not your coins.

@winstonlaw |AdjunctProfessor @NYUStern / @NYUlaw |No legal/financial advice |#crypto |#Miami |#Phish | all views are my views | all errors are mine.

Not your legal title, not your coins.

Excellent news: The Peraire-Bueno brothers have been acquitted. Congratulations to them and their defense teams! Coin Center filed an amicus brief challenging the SDNY’s “honest validator” theory of wire fraud. In Ethereum, “honest” validation has a specific technical meaning. It does not create an open-ended legal duty to meet prosecutors’ expectations of fair play. Had the SDNY’s theory prevailed, the government could use wire fraud law to impose its own code of conduct on Ethereum validators, backed by criminal penalties. Anyone participating in an open network would have to wonder whether prosecutors might later declare their behavior “dishonest” and haul them into court.
[ ZOOMER ] JUDGE RULES $25M MEV HEIST THAT HONEYPOTTED SANDWICH BOTS WAS NOT WIREFRAUD AS IT DID NOT HAPPEN ON A REGULATED MARKET, ACQUITS MIT BROTHERS: RTRS

Hate to see it. This is not something SCOTUS will have multiple times to consider. Read TDC's amicus brief prepared by @propelforward, @ThaniaCh, and others on the phenomenal Winston Taylor digital asset team to see what SCOTUS missed out on: supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/2…
🇺🇸 SUPREME COURT DECLINES TO HEAR CUSTODIA BANK'S CASE AGAINST THE FEDERAL RESERVE OVER A MASTER ACCOUNT

Control matters in DeFi, but it shouldn't be the defining test for securities regulation. In our latest article, our General Counsel @TuongvyLe12 examines why immutability and control aren't what the securities laws turn on, how constrained discretion can protect users, and why the analysis must always start with the law. Read more ↓ veda.tech/blog/on-immutabili…

"A framework that treats the absence of discretionary control as a prerequisite for avoiding securities regulation could encourage developers to eliminate useful safeguards, even where carefully constrained intervention would better protect users." Couldn't agree more 👏👏👏
Control matters in DeFi, but it shouldn't be the defining test for securities regulation. In our latest article, our General Counsel @TuongvyLe12 examines why immutability and control aren't what the securities laws turn on, how constrained discretion can protect users, and why the analysis must always start with the law. Read more ↓ veda.tech/blog/on-immutabili…

Fun couple of days connecting with #crypto industry, lawyers and academics at the @UChicagoLaw 2026 Digital Assets Symposium. Grateful to join friends @propelforward & @Andrea_Tosato on a panel with Jusge Lane and @Tony_J_Casey on the intersection of private law and regulation

Not quite sure anybody needs this… But for those who want this, they may want to read LoPucki (repository.library.washu.edu… ) and Bayern (papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.… ) who explained how to do this under existing law about 10 years ago.
SITUATION DETECTED: Delaware is drafting a proposal for a new form of corporate entity called an Artificial Intelligence Company (AIC). An AI managing an AIC would be able to provide services, sign contracts, hold property, and even file or defend lawsuits in the company’s name.

The new Congress may herald an era of oversight, investigations, and enforcement. The White House has argued that private-sector communications are protected by executive privilege. How does this new argument change the response playbook? Read more here... winstontaylor.com/insights/p…

Proud to have assisted Aave with this important effort.
Aave Labs and its co-authors have submitted a legal framework for decentralized lending protocols and non-custodial vaults to the SEC’s Crypto Task Force and Division of Corporation Finance. Today, we are releasing a public summary of our paper.

I’m launching “With All Due,” a Substack focused on the frontier of finance. I’ll be writing about the myriad products disrupting the current market structure, the rules for them & where this all goes next. Subscribe: withalldue.substack.com/p/st….

Today, @veda_labs, @aave, and @kamino are publishing a new legal framework for applying U.S. securities laws to decentralized lending protocols and non-custodial vaults. It draws from a joint submission to the @SECGov last month. Here's why it matters for the future of onchain finance: 🧵

I share the sentiment. Not the generalization. Custody of digitals is a complex private law topic 🧵 1) Under its terms, @Binance holds customers' tokens on trust. Customers' have pro-rata property interest 2) @Binance's promise to make customers whole is entirely diff. matter
Customers of a crypto exchange that lost billions last week are being told to trust a promise they’ll be made whole. Under the Clarity Act, customer assets would sit with a qualified custodian, legally walled off from company money. Protection shouldn’t depend on a pledge.

Encouraging to see the @SECGov staff recognize in today's updated guidance that decentralized governance can involve discretion without necessarily creating centralized control. I think this is an important distinction. Immutability shouldn't be the dividing line for what gets regulated. The ability of protocols to adapt to changing conditions and emerging risks and respond to live security incidents is an important form of user protection. There is room for distributed governance while constraining the powers any one actor can exercise / avoiding single points of failure. @veda_labs has been working with some of our industry peers on a broader legal framework for applying existing securities laws to onchain financial activity, including questions like these. Excited to share more tomorrow!

1.6 addresses the terms functional and decentralized and clarifies they are distinct concepts that address different aspects of a system's functionalities. TLDR- decentralization is not the same as functional, and each concept has diff. meanings/significance under the interps.

problem 2. "Modify the crypto system’s rules-based code" is "drive -a -mack -truck -thru -it" wide. As written, this basically means any governance that affects code, which is exceptionally broad.

problem 1. This FAQ answer disincentivizes attempts to limit /condition access for compliance purposes. It could be that compliance never happens at this layer of the stack, but it strongly argues against any form of compliance & potentially puts builders in a bad spot.