Feeling better at rest is not the whole story after a concussion. What happens with exertion tells us more about recovery. In the study below, passing the Multimodal Exertional Test at week 1 was linked to earlier clearance in a small study. A useful clue, not a green light 🚦
No single test replaces a full exam.
@M2MMAofficial@OrthoColumbia@davidwlawrence1@mghutchison@jonpatricios@EIMTeam
Before we had the label, the history of repeated impacts was there —just not always considered. Accumulated head impacts matter, and knowing the athlete’s story is still the first instrument I trust.
So many great athletes we can remember in this regard.
Cumulative head impact index is a solid instrument, but we can and will do better with biomarkers and neuroimaging soon.
@OrthoColumbia@proscope101
A clean drop jump in the lab is not the same as being ready for a game.
I see this after ACL work and after concussion. An athlete can look perfect on a simple screen and then move differently once they have to read the play, track the ball, and react. Before I clear someone, I want to see them move under sport-like demands.
VR and Biofeedback have promise.
@proscope101@jbjs@BJSM_BMJ@TheAMSSM@NATA1950@OrthoColumbia@JulieStammPhD@txsportsdoc@DrSeanWheeler
Perfect is the enemy of good. It's one of my favorite sayings. Whether you're a student athlete chasing the next level or a recent grad training for a marathon, perfectionism is working against you. In sports medicine, the goal is to meet your body where it is. Your body may or may not respond exactly how you want it to, so listen to what it's giving you.
@M2MMAofficial@DutchRojas@OrthoColumbia@proscope101
Clinically, there is no doubt we are missing the mark.
Over and over again, the toughest kids on the field, stay on the field despite symptoms.
Most common reason, they don’t think they’re concussed.
Relying on kids to tell us they are concussed is an extremely poor strategy.
We need diagnostics.
Now!
@proscope101@M2MMAofficial@cccannon10@contrariansmind
Partial knee Replacement has taken its place as a real, durable option for uni compartmental OA.
Being a non-surgical sports doc is more than concussions and ankle sprains.
It is knowing the evidence for surgical indications, best practices, and best surgeons.
And advising patients as such, so that when non-operative care is no longer their best option, the discussion can prepare them for coordinated surgical and post op care.
Tsukamoto et al, JBJS Am 2026. 2,234 consecutive UKAs, 85% revision-free at 15 years. Tech assistance, fixed bearing, and high volume: fewer revisions. Mobile bearing: more. Top reason: arthritis in the adjacent compartment. Single-center retrospective. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4298…@DaruStrong@M2MMAofficial@OrthoColumbia@contrariansmind@hjluks@TheAMSSM@BJSM_BMJ@NATA1950@AlixPopham@DutchRojas@CieslakDr@proscope101
Which partial knee lasts? In 2,234 UKAs followed to 15 years, revision-free survival was 85%. Tech assistance, fixed-bearing design, and high volume were linked to fewer revisions; mobile bearing to more. How you do the case matters as much as which implant.
Choose the best surgeon for the job.
Don’t be afraid to ask how many your surgeon has done with and without robotic assistance.
What their outcomes are in terms of successful return to activity and failures/complications. And never forget to ask if the surgery is necessary at this time or if there are viable non operative options.
In the same vein don’t delude yourself into calling surgery a “last resort”. The risk of doing surgery needs to be balanced against the real expected outcomes without.
@DaruStrong@M2MMAofficial@OrthoColumbia@contrariansmind@hjluks@TheAMSSM@BJSM_BMJ@NATA1950@AlixPopham@DutchRojas@CieslakDr@proscope101
1) ANS dysfunction is increasingly recognized as part of concussion syndrome. Leddy leads the way on this. I have been obsessed with HRV and HRV-BF for years. We need to refine ANS signal measurements.
The most convincing signal in the paper is the BP plateau during dysfunction.
We talk about BP response a lot as part of the cerebral blood flow mismatch.
2) Evidence Rating: 🚦Strong journal and clinically relevant physiology, but small case-control sample.
3) What’s New?
- Resting cardiopulmonary measures looked normal within 10 days of adolescent SRC.
- Graded exercise exposed the deficit: earlier stopping, symptom exacerbation, higher RPE, higher minute ventilation, and lower BP plateau.
- Acute exercise intolerance was not explained by simple aerobic deconditioning.
4) What’s Actually True?
This reinforces the pattern that concussion recovery deficits often appear under load, not at rest.
The useful signal is exertional cardiopulmonary/autonomic response quality, not a standalone autonomic biomarker.
5) Clinical Takeaway:
- Do not clear athletes from resting symptoms alone.
- Use standardized submaximal/graded exertion to expose residual physiologic intolerance.
- Treat abnormal exertion response as a progression-planning signal, not proof of failed recovery by itself.
6) Why This Matters:
It sharpens the concussion model from “symptom recovery” toward load-tested physiologic readiness.
7) What to do today:
Disruption of Autonomic nervous system regulation may be the cause of attenuated cardiopulmonary response after concussion. Measure HRV and/or other ANS marker in clinic.
Exertion testing is necessary before RTS.
Leddy JJ, et al“Cardiovascular and Respiratory Responses During Graded Exercise in Adolescents After Sport-Related Concussion.” Sports Med. 2026;56(1):271-282. PMID: 40858863. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4085…