←
Paul Xue29,590 posts
Paul Xue avatar

Paul Xue

@pxue

Reddit marketing agency. Co-host @gregoryandpaul show. ex-CTO, @uwaterloo.

◷ Joined February 2010▧ 2,445 Photos and videos
Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·2h

I'd rather have a customer tear apart a headline on Reddit than politely approve it in a meeting. One of those gives me a chance to fix the wrong assumption before I pay to show it to more people.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·3h

A marketing tool making $40,000 MRR with 135,000 users at it's peak is shutting down December 1st. This is what happened. In May 2021, solo founder Fed turned his script that found people complaining about problems on Reddit into a full fledged product called Gummysearch. The reception was overwhelmingly positive, builders and marketers paid him over $60,000 in the first year. Then, in the course of four years, he turned Gummysearch into the best Reddit tool ever existed and marketers used it daily. We were one of them... in our first six months at Spacestation Labs I practically lived inside it. In 2023 Reddit decided its API was too good to just give away for free and threw up a pay way that charged $0.24 per 1,000 calls. Apollo, the most popular Reddit app at the time, suddenly got a $20 million a year bill and decided to shut down. Redditors took it about as well as you'd expect. On June 12th nearly 9,000 subreddits went dark in protest, and Huffman responded by calling the moderators "landed gentry". When r/pics reopened, its 30 million members voted to only allow pictures of John Oliver, and other subs marked themselves NSFW so Reddit couldn't sell ads against them. Redditors were trolling the admins in protest, and it affected absolutely nothing. That August, when someone asked Fed about the API in his Indie Hackers post comments, there was no answer. This, in hindsight was the most honest answer available. Reddit then won every round after. In March 2024 it launched Reddit Pro, a free tool that offered "a lot" of what GummySearch did if you're generous with the word "a lot", and added Pro Trends in January 2025. On November 6th 2025 Fed published “The Final Chapter”. He’d tried to get a commercial license from Reddit and couldn’t reach an agreement, which left GummySearch two options, go non-commercial or shut down. He closed signups, gave paying customers one more year, and offered to sell the whole thing to Reddit or anyone holding a Reddit license, which is a bit like asking the landlord who evicted you if he wants the furniture. He called it an “emotional rollercoaster” and still said he respected Reddit’s reasons, which is more grace than I would have managed. Fast forward to September 2026, Reddit closed its public API. So now the only way to read Reddit at scale is to have a contract with Reddit and, ideally, a market cap. Fed nicely tweeted a reminder later that month, to which I replied, "oh god almost forgot I need a replacement soon". I still haven't found one. The obvious question here is why Reddit wanted to kill tools that thousands of marketers used daily. The answer is some what baffling.. Reddit primarily was looking towards AI companies to send them daily users by signing $140 million in data sharing deals with Google and OpenAI. While GummySearch at its best was doing $500,000 a year, a little more than one day of Reddit's licensing money. The juice was just not worth the squeeze. The part I find funny is what happened next. Less than a year after Gummysearch announced the shutdown, Reddit started having doubts about its favourite customers. In July the Wall Street Journal reported Reddit was weighing whether to cut Google off from its data. AI Overviews were reading Reddit threads and answering the question but not sending Reddit any visitors. On the October 29th earnings call Huffman said Reddit is "in active discussions," and that "any deal we do needs to advance our long-term strategy and has to be a fair exchange of value." He also blamed Google's AI search for Reddit's falling search traffic, and announced that Reddit is moving to logged-in only, partly to protect its "extremely valuable corpus of data." So Reddit's complaint about Google is that it takes the content and doesn't send people back. The irony is that with every insight Gummysearch surfaced about Reddit it also sent a marketer back into a thread to post, comment and usually buy ads, and Reddit priced it out anyway because it's a channel they don't control. Turns out a fair exchange of value is just something you demand once you're the smaller company in the room. Tbh, this is a tragic loss for Reddit marketers and their sales team. GummySearch was the one tool built by someone who actually understood how people use Reddit, and the replacement is a free dashboard from the company that would very much like you to buy ads blindly. From our experience with their sales process so far, they have yet to figure out how to make their ads business sticky. Fed did fine. He turned the domain into an alternatives page that's made $15–20K in affiliate revenue, and he now runs programmatic SEO sites doing over 500K organic clicks a year. The 135,000 users, along with thousands of marketers now look to other tools in the ecosystem to find insights about Reddit. For the hundreds of builders in the space, remember that access was always Reddit's to switch off. Google is finding that out too.

Post attachment
Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·5h

Developer → agency owner → professional Reddit person. Every step has been harder to explain to my parents. That is apparently my career progression.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·23h

Canadians will defend a terrible hockey team for 40 years and then get embarrassed saying Canada is a good place to build a company. Interesting allocation of confidence.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 17

The Canadian founder starter pack: Global ambitions. A winter coat that could survive a military deployment. Absolutely no plans to use either to leave Canada.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 17

Before adding 12 features, I'd read the competitor's one-star reviews. Did the product arrive? Did it work? Did anyone answer when it didn't? Sometimes the opening is doing the original job properly.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 17

Stop replying to refund complaints with your brand voice. The customer wants their money back. They do not want to discover how whimsical your social media intern is.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 16

My business passed $1M. Very glamorous number. Still a deeply unglamorous amount of email.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 16

When a business process needs one competent person, my brain immediately proposes a six-month software project. I used to be a developer. Apparently the subscription renews automatically.

Paul Xue avatar
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 15

In July, I lost hundreds of Reddit accounts with tens of thousands of karma. My Reddit marketing agency was in free falling mode and forced me to revamp our entire offer. This is what happened. In early in July, Reddit started removing posts and suspending accounts in bulk across the board regardless of their age and karma. Overnight I lost hundreds of accounts with tens of thousands of karma, our entire content pipeline grinded to a screeching halt. Bloomberg reported the same week that Reddit had turned its own AI on undisclosed marketing posts, and that its systems had been catching 25,000 spam posts a day earlier in the year. If you looked on social media, marketers were still giving advice on how to age and farm karma typically in meme subreddits, and that's all you needed to prevent an account being suspended. I knew this advice was no longer relevant, so I went back to the drawing board and spent the month testing. I had my team purchase eSim cards and farm accounts on real phones, expanded to 100 rented jailbroken iPhones clusters with Crane and still GHOST 2.0 set ups.. none of it worked. But with the testing, we realized the accounts that got suspended were ones that had built credibility in one subject and then pivoted to promoting something else. I called this personality drift. That's when I made the branded account and had them post the same content fully disclosed without any warm up. They survived. The obvious question here is what changed? For 20 years Reddit's old defence was mechanical, it prevented new accounts with no reputation from posting links on it's platform. The new LLM content policy moderator looks at who you are, what you've said, and whether the promotion is disclosed. Our finding told us that when a Reddit account changes its behavior and personality after the warming period, it triggered an internal alarm that would get it suspended. So I cancelled the Gologin subscription, archived our karma farming slack channel with overseas contractors and pivoted our agency's offer. What replaced it: brand accounts that say they're brands, real commenters with authority in one niche, and the client's own subreddit. Building an anonymous account into a genuine authority still works, as far as I can tell. It takes six or seven months. This is no different than starting a faceless X account. The AI can't speed it up. Reddit doubled down on this new direction during their last earnings call. Headline results warned that daily US users are falling but US revenue grew 50%. Reddit's north star is no longer tracking user growth but earning per user (ARPU). Revenue per user was up by 36%. Another key insight is that logged in users on the Reddit app is worth a lot more than anonymous users on the desktop, they bring in over 80% of the money. So this quarter Reddit starts testing a version you can't read without an account. That is a social network. Our prediction is that Reddit will converge to be more like the other text based social media (X and LinkedIn). The prudent marketer should pay attention to the platform's revenue per user and acknowledge accounts that exists only to promote is worth nothing to Reddit. But a brand that says it's a brand is a future advertiser. July was the first month Reddit enforced that.

Post attachment
Paul Xue avatar
⟳ Paul Xue retweeted
Paul Xue@pxue·Nov 14

I want more Canadian startup success stories where the least interesting detail is that the company stayed in Canada.