←
Geoff Penington3,606 posts
Geoff Penington avatar

Geoff Penington

@quantum_geoff

Associate Professor at Stanford. Quantum Information and Quantum Gravity. Currently at @Openai

◷ Joined June 2017▧ 30 Photos and videos
Geoff Penington avatar
Geoff Penington@quantum_geoff·26 May 2021

In 1993 the Superconducting Supercollider was cancelled. Estimated cost: $8 billion. An exodus of physicists left to Wall Street, bringing fancy maths and dubious risk management. 15 years later the global financial crisis cost ~$20 trillion. This is why you don't defund physics!

roon avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
roon@tszzl·Oct 27

honestly have no idea what frontier lab equity is worth; it seems highly plausible that huge top down slowdowns are coming, which would make frontier models uncompetitive. total nationalization also seems possible. anything could happen with this technology

Alex Kontorovich avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
Alex Kontorovich@AlexKontorovich·Oct 18

This is the exact opposite interpretation of what actually happened. The case of Yitang Zhang perfectly illustrates how mathematics culture, at its best, is a pure meritocracy. Regardless of how “unknown” you may be, write a paper that proves a longstanding problem and we will read it, and if it’s right, then you will be instantly recognized as a hero by the community. This part of mathematics may now be gone forever (due to AI), and this is very sad; this is one aspect of what so many of us are mourning, even as we look with awe at all the amazing discoveries we’ve already been gifted and many more sure to come.

In other words, established mathematicians and leaders of the community, completely failed a fellow mathematician yet again, turned him into a @SUBWAY PhD, and wasted almost his entire career over BS for decades. Point Blank. Question: why do we listen to leaders like this?

Jared Duker Lichtman avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
Jared Duker Lichtman@jdlichtman·Oct 18

Amazing!! Bryce Kerr has found a simpler proof of no Siegel zeros, in only 6 pages. This is perhaps the Proof from the Book: Number fields play a key role again, in this case the bi-quatratic extension \Q(\sqrt{2},\sqrt{q}). The proof leverages a classical result of Masser on polynomial degrees.

Post attachment

My friend and colleague Bill Banks has just uploaded a very nice exposition on the proof of no Siegel zeros: arxiv.org/abs/2610.15483

Post attachment
Geoff Penington avatar
Geoff Penington@quantum_geoff·Oct 16

He’s right and I’m tired of pretending he isn’t

“I don’t like set theory. I don’t think problems should be independent of the axioms” -Scott Aaronson’s 9-year old son I wasn’t expecting such a tough crowd at the ice cream shop 😭😭😭😭😭

OpenAI avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
OpenAI@OpenAI·Oct 15

We want to support the mathematics community in turning progress in AI into deeper human understanding and new discoveries. To support that goal, we are contributing $5 million to a new Simons Foundation initiative to help mathematicians examine, understand, and build on results produced by AI, including the results we recently published. The funding, managed and awarded by the @SimonsFdn will support workshops, conferences, and special programs. We will also provide access to our models and computing resources to Simons Foundation-supported researchers.

How can the math community forge the best path forward in the AI age? We're committing $15M to workshops and initiatives — plus free AI computing resources for foundation-supported researchers — through new partnerships with @AnthropicAI and @OpenAI: bit.ly/4zpfIbW #math #science #AI

Alex Kontorovich avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
Alex Kontorovich@AlexKontorovich·Oct 14

When I was teaching at Yale, Thomas Koberda was a postdoc working with Yair Minsky. Thomas and I got to reconnect two weeks ago at an AMS meeting in DC on “What the heck is a math PhD now?” (My short answer: deeply learning difficult mathematics, being able to orally explain every detail, becoming the human world expert on some (however small) area of mathematical knowledge. Long answer: ams.org/about-us/governance/…) Anyway, we got to chatting over some beers at dinner, and Thomas was much more down on what it all means for mathematics than I was, and we wanted to get to the “bottom” of things; make explicit any assumptions that were underlying our conclusion. We had a very nice chat, not necessarily agreeing on everything, but definitely feeling like we heard each other’s arguments. So the next day, we basically had the conversation again, but this time in a shared Google Doc, at first talking as we type, but eventually just “typing at” each other in silence. We allowed ourselves to interject, to fix what we were saying from the first version, to fact check, to tighten our arguments as much as we saw fit. It was a *wonderful* way to, in good faith, debate/discuss serious topics with serious disagreement. (I would *love* to see other topics discussed this way…) We felt it may be useful to others, so cleaned it up a bit and posted to the arxiv. arxiv.org/abs/2610.14362 I was also contacted by Proofs and Prompts asking for a contribution, so we cross-posted it there. proofsandprompts.com/2026/10… I’m quite eager to hear what people think of the conversation!

Thomas Bloom avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
Thomas Bloom@thomasfbloom·Oct 14

A good reminder to those looking at the OpenAI papers that a lot of their length may be taken up with entirely redundant detours, and that even a small amount of attention can significantly reduce the length and complexity of the proofs. 12/12

roon avatar
⟳ Geoff Penington retweeted
roon@tszzl·Oct 13

the researchers at all the labs would tell you in private and sometimes in public that alignment has not been solved. if this is true, then racing into RSI is a folly that is unprecedented in world history. we will need to significantly slow the frontier of research very soon

Geoff Penington avatar
Geoff Penington@quantum_geoff·Oct 11

So she tried to reconcile those facts by guessing he had just been discharged in the last few hours and so wasn’t in either system. When she asked “what is today?”, she clearly realises that the discharges only cover up to the previous day and draws conclusions from there 2/2

Geoff Penington avatar
Geoff Penington@quantum_geoff·Oct 11

Seems obvious if you listen to the full call that a) the employee assumed the caller was correct about Talarico having been a patient but b) was confused because he wasn’t listed as either present or discharged in the last four days. 1/2

Current Revolt has the full 6:40 call that is purportedly to the Lindner Center of Hope.