←
Quincygitahi40,684 posts
Quincygitahi avatar

Quincygitahi

@quincygitahi

Advocate| LLM student | Fashion Connoisseur | Saxophonist |

◷ Joined October 2017▧ 2,440 Photos and videos
Citizen TV Kenya avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Citizen TV Kenya@citizentvkenya·9h

“Tunataka Pawa,” Cheers in Parliament as Siaya Senator Oburu Oginga arrives for the State of the Nation Address

1:10
Quincygitahi avatar
Quincygitahi@quincygitahi·7h

Mstahiki Meya

President Ruto impressed as Osoro, Junet force fellow broad-based MPs to stand and clap for him after narrating how SHA helped a Kenyan named Veronica Wambui living in Kiambu County

2:46
NTV Kenya avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
NTV Kenya@ntvkenya·13h

PS Kimtai warns chiefs against colluding with wealthy individuals to seize widows’ land

2:29
Moe avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Moe@moneyacademyKE·13h

KRA plans to auction 965 packages of Jack Daniel’s whiskey belonging to Maxam Limited for overstaying at its Nairobi customs warehouse. The auction is scheduled for December 28–31, 2026, unless the consignment is collected within the 30-day notice period.

EMS Law LLP avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
EMS Law LLP@Lexken_EMSLaw·14h

🚨 Can a judgment that summarises the evidence and grounds of appeal, but provides almost no independent analysis, satisfy the constitutional requirement for a reasoned judicial decision? This question arises from Peter Mathenge v Millicent Waithira Muriithi, Environment and Land Court Civil Appeal E007 of 2026, determined by Justice Mugo Kamau at Nyandarua. The appeal concerned ownership and occupation of Plot No. 167, Bamboo Farmers Co-operative Society Ltd. The trial magistrate had ruled in favour of Millicent Waithira Muriithi, granting eviction and permanent injunction orders against Peter Mathenge. Dissatisfied with the decision, Mathenge appealed, challenging the trial court’s assessment of ownership, documentary evidence, possession and the legal basis of the property transfer. However, after extensively summarising the trial proceedings and grounds of appeal, the appellate judgment reportedly disposed of the dispute with a single substantive conclusion: “I find the Judgment of the learned Trial Magistrate to be sound. The Appeal is dismissed with costs to the Respondent.” The decision raises an important question about the duty of courts to give reasons for their judgments. What does Kenyan law require? 1. A first appellate court must independently evaluate the evidence. In Selle & another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & others [1968] EA 123, the Court established that a first appellate court must reconsider the evidence, evaluate it independently and draw its own conclusions, while recognising that it did not hear or observe the witnesses. The appellate court is therefore not restricted to confirming whether it agrees with the trial court’s conclusion. It must demonstrate that it has independently considered the relevant evidence and issues. 2. Judgments must disclose the reasons supporting their conclusions. Order 21 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules requires judgments in defended suits to contain a concise statement of the case, the points for determination, the decision and the reasons for that decision. Rule 5 further requires the court to state its findings or decision on each separate issue. A summary of the parties’ arguments is not necessarily a substitute for judicial analysis. 3. Reasoned judgments promote judicial accountability. In Muya v Tribunal Appointed to Investigate the Conduct of Justice Martin Mati Muya [2022] KESC 16 (KLR), the Supreme Court emphasised that judges have a duty to give reasons for their decisions. The Court recognised that reasons enable aggrieved parties to exercise their appellate rights and promote public confidence in the judicial process. Judicial independence therefore operates alongside the responsibility to explain the basis of judicial decisions. 4. A court need not address every argument, but must explain its determination of the principal issues. In Bwire v Wayo & Sailoki [2022] KEHC 7 (KLR), the High Court examined the duty to provide adequate reasons. The Court explained that judges are not required to address every submission individually. However, their reasons should disclose the logical basis of the decision and adequately address the principal questions requiring determination. The adequacy of reasons must be assessed in the context of each case. Key takeaway: A judgment is more than a summary of proceedings followed by a final order. Judicial reasoning is essential to demonstrating how the law and evidence support the decision reached. Whether the judgment in Mathenge v Muriithi satisfies that standard is a question that must be assessed against the complete decision and the applicable appellate principles. Follow @Lexken_EMSLaw for practical legal insights on civil litigation, appellate procedure and constitutional law in Kenya.

Post attachmentPost attachment
𝐌𝐒𝐍 𝐖𝐀𝐓𝐔𝐋𝐎¶𝑴.𝑪𝒐𝒎,𝑭𝑪𝑪𝑨,𝑪𝑰𝑨 avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
𝐌𝐒𝐍 𝐖𝐀𝐓𝐔𝐋𝐎¶𝑴.𝑪𝒐𝒎,𝑭𝑪𝑪𝑨,𝑪𝑰𝑨@MSN_Watulo·12h

Is stare decisis or binding precedent optional? I think, offending decisions are per incuriam.

Confusion Galore. COA departs from its earlier decisions that a suit instituted in the wrong court cannot be transferred. Interestingly the SCORK has pronounced itself on the issue, but, the COA, like the HC, doesn’t give a hoot about stare decisis @joshuamalidzo @abdulnassir21

Post attachmentPost attachment
Omwamba 🇰🇪 avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Omwamba 🇰🇪@omwambaKE·Nov 17

Suspected phone snatcher received a thorough panel beating, public participation and leg alignment in Nyayo Stadium.

0:36
Quincygitahi avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Quincygitahi@quincygitahi·15h

Confusion Galore. COA departs from its earlier decisions that a suit instituted in the wrong court cannot be transferred. Interestingly the SCORK has pronounced itself on the issue, but, the COA, like the HC, doesn’t give a hoot about stare decisis @joshuamalidzo @abdulnassir21

Post attachmentPost attachment
Joshua Malidzo Nyawa avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Joshua Malidzo Nyawa@joshuamalidzo·Nov 17

Here is a judgment that fits the description of 'A Judgment Without Judgment' Justice Mugo Kamau authored an eight-page 'Judgment' in which he summarised the case before the trial court and the memorandum of appeal. The Learned Judge's analysis is contained in one sentence, to wit: 'I find the Judgment of the learned Trial Magistrate to be sound. The Appeal is dismissed with costs to the Respondent.' This is not a judgment! 'A judgment without reasons or with insufficient reasons has the appearance of an arbitrary decision and not of a true judgment.' Judge de Castro, Dissenting Opinion. Access this decision: drive.google.com/file/d/1rnm…

Post attachmentPost attachment
Lightcast TV Kenya avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Lightcast TV Kenya@Lightcasttvke·Nov 17

"Wewe mama OSHA yule CALEB Amisi ajue kuvaa SIRUALI." ~ Arati to Amisi's competitor in Saboti

1:27
The Kiambu Magazine avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
The Kiambu Magazine@kiambu_magazine·Nov 17

How Anne Waiguru Is Dancing, Knowing She Is the Next Deputy President of Kenya!

1:17
Donna Mugoh avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Donna Mugoh@Eddie_Mugoh·Nov 17

Broadbased government ang'owa. Look at the results and who landed the top job at TSC. Odette is from Nyeri. 😂

Post attachment
Quincygitahi avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
Quincygitahi@quincygitahi·Nov 17

Imagine you can avoid all this embarrassment if you choose Celibacy. 😭😭😭 Ni uchungu saaana.

Bro is in love a lone

0:21
The Kenyan Vigilante avatar
⟳ Quincygitahi retweeted
The Kenyan Vigilante@KenyanSays·Nov 17

"Since Kiharu MP Ndindi Nyoro is eyeing the top seat in the country, we, as DCP, will field a candidate in the constituency," – Rigathi Gachagua announces that DCP will field a candidate in Kiharu.

0:40