←
Realist Evaluation584 posts
Realist Evaluation avatar

Realist Evaluation

@realisteval

Scan of realist evaluation and other theory-driven approaches for health. With the support of SHAPES group of @H_S_Global. Run by @prashanthns

◷ Joined June 2014▧ 17 Photos and videos
IPH Bengaluru avatar
⟳ Realist Evaluation retweeted
IPH Bengaluru@iphindia·27 Nov 2025

Day 3 of the #RealistResearchBlendedCourse began with two of our participants volunteering to share their insights and provide an overview of the Day 2 sessions. The workshop then moved to a glimpse of other theory-driven methods. One of the sessions was led by Dr Vaibhav Agavane and focused on the approach called “theory of change. ” He noted that every programme or intervention carries both implicit and explicit ideas about how change is expected to occur, and that a theory of change helps make those assumptions and the programme’s logic explicit. Through an example, he illustrated the various elements of a theory of change. Dr Upendra Bhojani described another theory-driven method, Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA). He explained how QCA combines the strengths of both qualitative and quantitative approaches to identify deterministic outcomes and examine causal pathways. Drawing on an example, he walked through the different components of QCA including cases, outcomes, conditions, and the construction of a truth table. Dr Pragati Hebbar delved into what a realist synthesis is, and how it differs from a realist evaluation or a conventional systematic review. She explained the process of realist synthesis and underscored that realist synthesis is theorydriven, it does not place literature in a strict hierarchy, and allows the use of a wide range of sources, She highlighted both the strengths and the limitations of realist synthesis and demonstrated how to conduct a realist synthesis through an example. Following this session, the participants spent time reading a selected article on realist synthesis. Afterwards, they broke into small groups to critically appraise a published realist synthesis study. Once group work was complete, each team presented their findings to the rest of the participants. The course concluded with an overview of resources and support for realist evaluation practitioners, including HSGSHAPES and RAMESES, followed by certificate distribution and a dedicated feedback session. @Chaudharyadit23 @AvishekHazra23, @commed_doc @MonicaShriv @punitrd @HiralkarSakshi @brynne_gilmore #IPHBengaluru #TTNSoAS #RealistResearch2025 #IPHEvents #blendedlearning

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
IPH Bengaluru avatar
⟳ Realist Evaluation retweeted
IPH Bengaluru@iphindia·26 Nov 2025

Day 2 of the #RealistResearchBlendedCourse opened with a short recap from two volunteer participants, who shared their most important takeaways from Day 1 of the in-person session. This was followed by a session led by Dr. Prashanth N.S., who walked us through the steps of conducting a realist evaluation from theory development to empirical testing and finally theory refinement and synthesis. He emphasised the importance of developing a priori theories, which can be constructed using multiple sources such as literature reviews, programme documents, stakeholder interviews, hunches informed by field interactions, and empirical data. Dr. Brynne Gilmore led a detailed session on data analysis and synthesis in realist evaluation and unpacked its methodological aspects. She introduced the teacher–learner approach, theory-driven interviewing, and the importance of asking questions in the right way. She also discussed in depth the concept of retroductive analysis to identify hidden causal factors, which draws on a combination of induction, deduction, and insights from intuitive reasoning (abduction). After the session, participants worked in groups on a few casestudy examples to analyze data, refine the program theory, and apply their learnings. They then shared their insights with all participants.Professor Bruno Marchal demonstrated, through a variety of real-world examples, how realist methods can be applied across multiple levels of health systems. Finally, Professor Arnab Mukherji discussed a case study to illustrate how patterns emerging from data can shape development of initial program theory for realist research.  @Chaudharyadit23 @AvishekHazra23, @commed_doc @MonicaShriv @punitrd @HiralkarSakshi @brynne_gilmore #IPHBengaluru #TTNSoAS #RealistResearch2025 #IPHEvents #blendedlearning

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
IPH Bengaluru avatar
⟳ Realist Evaluation retweeted
IPH Bengaluru@iphindia·25 Nov 2025

Kicked off Day 1 of the #RealistResearchBlendedCourse (Face-to-Face Phase) at @iimb_official The recap session explored whether research can ever be neutral, emphasizing that every method is grounded in its own philosophical roots. It revisited the philosophical foundations of realist research, highlighting realism as a bridge between the real world and the interpreted world. The session also underscored that people remain the driving force behind any programme. Dr. Prashanth N. S. led a session on concepts and terminology that explored how programmes and policies are ideas shaped by underlying assumptions and contextual factors. It also featured an interactive illustration, where participants contributed a policy or programme idea and collectively unpacked its assumptions and contextual elements. Dr. Pragati Hebbar used a variety of examples to explain how programme theories are developed, emphasizing the ontological layers. She also discussed why it is important to construct Initial Programme Theories (IPTs) and the different levels of programme theory. Although many possible programme theories exist, she pointed out that time and resource constraints force us to select only a few to address specific parts of the larger picture. Finally, Prof. Sara Van Belle unpacked CMO (Context-Mechanism-Outcome) configurations, discussed different approaches to causalityand generative causation, introduced alternative frameworks such as CIMO (Context-Intervention-Mechanism-Outcome) and ICAMO (Intervention-Context-Actor-Mechanism-Outcome), and explained its use for data analysis in realist research. @Chaudharyadit23 @AvishekHazra23, @commed_doc @MonicaShriv @punitrd @HiralkarSakshi #IPHBengaluru #TTNSoAS #RealistResearch2025 #IPHEvents #blendedlearning

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Arushi Thapar avatar
⟳ Realist Evaluation retweeted
Arushi Thapar@atpublic_health·14 Oct 2025

Applications Open: Realist Research Blended Course Theory-Driven and Realist Approaches in Health Policy & Systems Research The T.T. Narasimhan School of Advanced Studies at @iphindia is excited to announce the 5th edition of the Realist Research Blended Course! @prashanthns

Post attachment
Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Key takeaway: Digital BCC programmes must go beyond content delivery. To foster sustained engagement, they need to be emotionally supportive, context-sensitive, and equity-oriented. Tech is just the shell—context is the fuel.

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Not all mechanisms were positive. Some women felt “watched” by the government (who co-implemented mNutrition). Fear of surveillance, not trust, drove their engagement, raising concerns about coercion in digital health.

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Some mothers used SMS messages to negotiate gendered power dynamics. Credible information backed their decisions on feeding practices, helping them assert themselves in male-dominated households. #Empowerment

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Messages that opened with “Beloved Mum” offered emotional support & recognition. These cues made mothers feel seen, validated, and part of a caring network, sustaining their connection.

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Realist interviews revealed 7 key CMO configurations. Example: Mothers who felt anxious about their child’s health valued regular SMS advice. It reduced anxiety and restored a sense of control, driving continued engagement.

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Sustained engagement wasn’t due to a single factor. It emerged from interactions between programme features (like message tone, delivery mode, sender perception) and contextual inequities (like time poverty, isolation, gender dynamics). #RealistLens #HealthEquity

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

This study focused on the mNutrition programme—a large-scale SMS behaviour change intervention targeting maternal & child nutrition. Despite high reach, only 12% of users engaged consistently. So, what kept those users engaged?

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·5 Aug 2025

Why do some mothers keep engaging with SMS-based nutrition programmes while others don’t? This realist evaluation from rural Tanzania explores the mechanisms behind sustained engagement. #RealistEvaluation #DigitalHealth onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/…

Realist Evaluation avatar
Realist Evaluation@realisteval·23 Jun 2025

The authors argue that Indigenous realist evaluation is a promising pathway toward decolonising research partnerships, especially when it amplifies participant agency and foregrounds local epistemologies.