←
Rob Gray🧢6,933 posts
Rob Gray🧢 avatar

Rob Gray🧢

@robgraymd

✋ & Microsurgeon. Mayo Clinic, Rush & Brown. “I treat it like it’s my own hand” Opinions my own & this isn’t medical advice

◷ Joined April 2015▧ 501 Photos and videos
Preston Cooper avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Preston Cooper@PrestonCooper93·Nov 17

Post attachment

Medical students are reaching the new $200,000 lifetime cap on federal loans. This H.R.1 provision makes it harder for future doctors to pay for medical school at a time when the U.S. already faces a physician shortage. 1/5

Blake Moore avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Blake Moore@bemooremd·Nov 16

1/5 Bicondylar tibial plateau fracture with a posteromedial fragment, fixed through a dual approach: anterolateral plus posteromedial (Lobenhoffer). Teaching points below.

Post attachment
Heath Veuleman avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Heath Veuleman@HeathVeuleman·Nov 9

The problem goes well beyond paying physicians what they’re worth. In many cases, we’ve constructed an artificial market in which we don’t even allow compensation to be determined through ordinary market forces. If I own an entity that furnishes healthcare services and want to employ a physician, I may need to substantiate that compensation meets fair market value (FMV) requirements. Depending on the arrangement, that often means obtaining an independent third-party valuation. Those valuations frequently rely upon compensation benchmarks from organizations such as MGMA, along with other industry surveys. Much of that compensation data is voluntarily submitted by the very hospitals, health systems, and physician practices purchasing physician labor (be mindful that 82% of physicians are employed by hospitals and health systems). The entities purchasing the labor supply much of the data used to establish what that labor is worth. Those benchmarks then influence subsequent compensation decisions, which eventually feed back into the same datasets. It’s a self-referential system And when employers can recruit physicians at lower compensation levels, including some physicians working under immigration-related constraints such as J-1 waivers or H-1B visas, those compensation arrangements may also influence the benchmarks, depending on how the data are collected and adjusted. We’ve built a system in which the buyers of physician labor have substantial influence over the benchmarks used to determine what they can reasonably pay for that labor. A valuation can be perfectly compliant, mathematically defensible, and professionally certified while still reflecting a distorted market. Fair market value and genuine market price discovery are not necessarily the same thing. And until we acknowledge that distinction, conversations about paying physicians what they’re worth will continue to miss the larger structural problem.

Between college, medical school and residency plus often a fellowship, physicians give up a ton of years and a lot of money. Further we are horribly short physicians. Pay physicians more. Pay them what they are worth. We are better off if more if the best and brightest go to medical school.

The Rational Animal 🤔 avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
The Rational Animal 🤔@theobjectivist·Nov 9

Mark, you started by saying we have no idea what healthcare costs to buy or to provide in this country. None. Then your conclusion is to propose that the people who cannot see the costs should be the ones to run it. There is a reason nobody knows what anything costs, and you listed it yourself. Medicaid, Medicare, supplemental plans, Medicare Advantage, self insured employers under a tax code that hides the premium in the paycheck. Every layer you named is a government program or a government created structure, and in every one of them the person getting the care is not the person paying for it. That is where the price went. Prices exist where buyers pay. Remove the buyer and you get exactly the fog you are describing. Universal care removes every buyer who is left. Then look at what you are asking for. Every private contract in the industry published by federal order. Every claim in the country handed to state and federal researchers. The DOJ turned loose on the pricing structure. Bipartisan legislation to work out what care we need to provide and what it should cost. That is not a market reform. That is the state seizing the information of an entire industry so it can set the terms of trade for every doctor, hospital, and patient in the country. You call the conglomerates Too Big To Care. The entity you want running it is the only one with a monopoly on force. And the number. The post you are replying to has CBO at $3 trillion a year in new federal spending, 21.4 percent of payroll, with the author conceding it is illustrative and not scored. You respond that nobody knows the real cost and we should find out after we commit. No investor you have ever met would fund a company on those terms, and you have never funded one that way yourself. Only government gets to spend money first and discover the price later, because only government can send the bill to people who did not agree to it. The information asymmetry you are describing is not a reason to negotiate blind. It is a reason to stop having a single buyer negotiating at all. Put the patient back in the transaction and prices appear on their own. Cost Plus is proof that you already know this. Mises showed a century ago that a planner without prices cannot calculate, Hayek showed why the knowledge he needs is never in one place, and Rand showed why he has no right to try. You are proposing to prove all three wrong with a commission while you admit no one has any idea how much all of it will cost. Do you think they did not know what they were talking about, or do you just not want to find out?

We have no idea what healthcare costs to buy or costs to provide in this country. None. States cover Medicaid at some level, but not all offer the same care. Nor do they all receive federal support in the same way. Traditional Medicare requires supplemental and drug coverage. All of which differ by plan, and are offered by mostly huge conglomerates we should break up and are Too Big To Care Medicare Advantage is all offered by those same Too Big To Care conglomerates. Every contract with a provider differs and while those contracts have pricing that is transparent, the fees and other charges are not. 67 pct of employees that get coverage from work get it from a self insured employer. I can tell you with absolute certainty that most get it from the same conglomerates as well. As a results they have zero idea how much they are paying for medical care or medications (even with recent legislation) Every thing that is covered and paid for in this country has an actual cost, across the direct costs and indirect costs, that is hidden by the Too Big to Care conglomerates that should be broken up. Market Dominant hospitals and most non profit hospitals are not innocent. They play along when they have to, use their own leverage when they can. Increasing the cost of care. And the PBMs that are owned by the conglomerates have bastardized the cost of brand and specialty drugs in a way that should be investigated by the DOJ. Put simply , HUGE dominant distributors are forced by PBMs to pay RETAIL Price for drugs that make them unaffordable to everyone. If we want universal care, we can say the Feds will negotiate , but the information asymmetry is so insane, they will be negotiating blind. The first thing a bi partisan legislation should do is require that all healthcare contracts be made public with no redactions other than personal information AND All claims be de-identified and available exclusively to state and federal researchers to determine what care and medications COULD cost. Then we can start to extrapolate what care we need to provide and then determine what it costs and whether it will save or cost us money. In parallel we can determine how we will deal with the technology and processes to handle implementation of some version of universal care

Andrew Yang, MD | Hand Surgeon avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Andrew Yang, MD | Hand Surgeon@HandSurgeonMD·Nov 8

You went through 4 years of Premed, 4 years of medical school, 3-6 years of residence, 1-3 years of fellowship but you think you can't learn how to run your own business? My parents started their own business immigrating from another country. Opt out.

Rob Gray🧢 avatar
Rob Gray🧢@robgraymd·Nov 5

10/10. No notes.

Medical school taught me anatomy, physiology, and pathology. It taught me how to memorize, how to endure, and how to work longer hours than most people thought possible. What it didn't teach me was how to practice medicine with a full view of the human experience, mine included. Here's what I wish I had known from the start:

Dan Go avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Dan Go@CoachDanGo·Nov 4

I regret to inform you that regardless of what’s happening in the world you are responsible for your success. Stop blaming. Stop complaining. Take ownership. Act accordingly.

Dan Go avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Dan Go@CoachDanGo·Oct 30

Your 90-year-old self would give anything to be where you are right now. Lift weights, walk, eat healthy, and sleep well. You are living your golden years right now. You're younger than you think you are. Don't waste it.

AtlasMD avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
AtlasMD@AtlasMD·Oct 25

We’re fixing healthcare, I’d rather have 1 minute of your time :-)

Adrian Sosenko avatar
⟳ Rob Gray🧢 retweeted
Adrian Sosenko@DrDadBuilder·Oct 20

I never share reviews, but this one is long and definitely worth the read. I went independent to have time to listen, take responsibility, and make sure patients get the care they deserve. Grateful to this patient, and to my staff for making it possible every day.

Post attachmentPost attachment