←
Samson W. Fine, MD8,677 posts
Samson W. Fine, MD avatar✓

Samson W. Fine, MD ✓

@rovingatuscap

Attending Urologic Pathologist 🔬 #gupath #prostatecancer Dept Pathology & Lab Med @MSKPathology opinions=mine & do not reflect the views of my employer

◷ Joined February 2012▧ 1,815 Photos and videos
Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

At this time - overly detailed/confusing outputs from LLMs aside - it is also unlikely that existing ML/AI digital diagnostics can handle the communication aspects in a case such as this - Thanks to all for engaging!

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

#5 Would ML/AI help with Grading & Quantification in a focus like this? - AI depends on the annotations models were trained with - threshold/watershed areas of morphology and minute foci could be expected to be as difficult for an AI product as for pathologists (IMO)

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

IMO, we might be better off with re-framing as “those with expertise” who due to the interpretive and communication aspects detailed above may differ in their opinions (as we do)… Which brings us to #AI

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

#4 Moving Beyond the Era of the Sage on the Stage As @smlungpathguy highlights, we (and our patients) are often confronted with the challenge of multiple differing opinions from “experts” - indeed, we have opinions on this thread from a veritable all star team of GU pathologists

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

#3 Clinical Interpretation This is important because of recent data, including from our group at @MSKCancerCenter, demonstrating that quantity of pattern 4 - specifically, a calculated value of mm pattern 4 for the case - has important predictive value in GG2-4 prostate cancer

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

This note should convey the grading assessment challenge in a way that can be clearly understood My practice: “Accurate assessment of pattern 4 quantification is challenging due to the small size of the carcinoma focus” - points to quantity rather than grade…

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

#2 Reporting Pathologists debate whether to even assign a GS/GrdGrp to foci such as these…which is a balance between letting clinical colleagues know that this is challenging and providing a data element that can be used for management ** include a note in the report

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

A portion of this focus appears = small discrete glands on at least some of the levels provided (IMO), so that would leave some combination of pattern 3 and 4 and makes relevant the discussion points raised by @slusagar @GladellPaner and others

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

And then we are left with a threshold/watershed question: what is a small (?minute) discrete gland v. a poorly formed gland The latter is a particularly thorny area (agreement-wise) for even GU pathologists: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2609… Next step: examine multiple tissue levels…

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

A portion of the focus = poorly formed glands with attenuated cytoplasm/lumens (IMO) - seeing this glandular structure prevents me from assessing any of this as pattern 5 (single cells with vacuoles) - anecdotally, this is a challenging area for AI models So, pattern 3 v. 4…

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

Depending on how one interprets the above - one could diagnose: majority small discrete glands/no single cells (i.e., 3+4), majority poorly formed glands/some small discrete/no single cells (i.e., 4+3), all PFG (i.e., 4+4), +/- some degree of single cells (i.e., GG5) What Now?

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

Simple… Discrete glands: pattern 3 Poorly formed glands: pattern 4 Single cells: pattern 5 More Complex… A focus like ours displaying: small glands (challenge: discrete v. poorly formed) + glands/cells with small lumens/vacuoles (challenge: poorly formed v. single cells)

Samson W. Fine, MD avatar
Samson W. Fine, MD@rovingatuscap·Nov 16

#1 Morphology - with apologies to the #AI reads from @dr_coops - this focus is distinctively NOT cribriform (🚫small or large) - the focus demonstrates a scenario which could be interpreted as pattern 3, 4, or 5: hence the range of Gleason score/GG opined How does this happen?