Professor of Philosophy @OU_Philosophy. Political philosophy and the ethics and metaphysics of sport. @OU_GCRN (RT ≠ endorsement, all views personal, obvs.)
Here is my latest paper, published today in the Journal of the Philosophy of Sport and co-authored with Dr Emma Hilton @fondofbeetles from Manchester University. I would like to thank @OpenUniversity for their ongoing support of my research
tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.…
.@davidcullinane acknowleges that a woman is an 'adult female' but adds: "There are also trans women who can legally transition in this State and live their lives as women, and I don’t see where the controversy is."
The women who were injured by male players in a @LadiesFootball match can see where the controversy is.
The teenage girls who played against an adolescent male with an obvious competitive advantage can see where the controversy is.
The LGFA's unsafe and unfair policy is a direct result of legislation that David says he sees no issues with.
He is not the only elected representative who doesn't have a grasp of this situation.
It's small wonder there is so much uncertainty and apprehension in Gaelic Games around eligibility policies when even our legislators cannot provide clarity on this issue.
PS - women and girls deserve 'compassion' and 'respect' too.
Hilary Cass, author of the landmark report into NHS children’s gender services, has said that the government’s planned bill to ban conversion practices could put healthcare workers and therapists at risk of “vexatious complaints”
bmj.com/content/395/bmj-2026…
... This is the 'context' to which B/S refer. And, obviously, it's a bit of sleight of hand, and not a concession at all.
Once you take a good look, B/S reinforce the criticisms of discussions of sex and gender rather than rebut them.
... No such luck, I'm afraid. The references trade on the distinction of Bettcher between the resistant 'underworld' and the oppressive 'overworld'. In the 'overworld', Bettcher says, the transphobes 'get it right' - there, trans women are not women. ...
... maybe there's some concession in the feminist philosophical literature out there, that in sport, or prisons, maybe, sex trumps gender ID. So I had a look...
... The crux is this: B/S cite a body of work to support the claim that feminist philosophers 'explicitly and deliberately endorse the idea that trans women don't count as women in every context'.
Gosh, I thought. Maybe there's a chink of light here, I've missed something...
Not before time, I've opened a Substack, for longer pieces. The first one may well put you off: it's a further criticism of Bettcher and Saul on the Fine and Rosen report, so if you've been following that you might be interested, and if not, well, not.
Concession or Sleight of Hand? profjonpike.substack.com/p/c…
Nine days ago, the Seattle Times ran a story saying "there is no serious scientific evidence that trans girls or women are better athletes than cisgender girls or women."
And despite multiple writers citing studies challenging the claim, the paper has yet to run a correction.
foxnews.com/outkick-sports/s…
At a Stonewall reception in parliament last night on the draft Bill on Conversion Practices a speaker said:
"Every day another middle aged lesbian is coming out against it. They are frightened their dating pool will get even smaller." Everyone laughed uproariously at this.
Is it funny Stonewall that a generation of young lesbians have been told that they are in fact trans and need to destroy their healthy bodies and minds? Is it funny that middle-aged lesbians want to warn against this?
When was it exactly that you lost your moral compass?Is there any lower for you to go? How dare you pretend this Bill would protect young homosexuals - all you want is to destroy them.
"How world sport fails to protect the most vulnerable": New ARD investigation on child doping. Our biggest ever research: 6 years/50 countries/25 sports and a 6-part documentary series. Summary article in English here. And please forgive long thread... 1/ sportschau.de/investigativ/g…
Baroness Cass turns against ‘chilling’ trans law
Cass tells committee Conversion Practices Bill could have ‘serious unintended consequences’
Asked do you support this bill as drafted?’
Hilary Cass: ‘No’.
telegraph.co.uk/politics/202…
Everyone should know this woman’s name but because of the East German doping era sadly most have gotten. A real superstar of her time robbed of what was rightfully hers
Kathy Cook – a star who never got their full share of the spotlight ⭐️
The Brit is one of the unsung heroes we focus on in our November magazine 🏃♀️
Considering she gathered 15 medals from major championships, at a time when doping was rife across her events, this most versatile of British sprinters arguably does not always get the credit she deserves 🇬🇧
Her national records from 100m, 200, 300m and 400m were all long-standing and, while she was never an individual champion on the world stage (she secured 400m Olympic bronze in 1984 and 200m world bronze in 1983), was a true force to be reckoned with ⚡️
Competitive sport is a pie. Numbers on a team. Lanes on a track. Places on a podium. Olympic qualification. Prize money. Competitive sport is a pie. Or rather two pies. Female & male. The female pie is already much smaller. Males should not be taking some of the female pie.
Equal rights for women ≠ fewer rights for men.
#Equality is not about taking a slice away.
It's about making rights available for EVERYONE.
Pass the pie, and join us in the fight for equality 🥧
#ForAllWomenAndGirls
Everyone can play ofc.
In the correct sex categories.
Women with trans/non-binary identities are welcome in women's sport.
See Quinn, Bacyadan, Hiltz at Olympic level.
Men's sport needs to follow this lead & welcome all males including those with trans/non-binary identities.
Being able to participate in sports is important for all young people, but #transgender and #nonbinary youth are often excluded. Let everyone play - #trans and gender-diverse youth included!🏳️⚧️
This bloke drove around looking for a victim, hit a woman from behind with his van, strangled her, then put a woman's wig on on the way to court. If it weren't for the terfs, the entire establishment would have demanded the right pronouns and sent him off to a woman's prison.