←
Melanie In Saskatchewan26,204 posts
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar

Melanie In Saskatchewan

@saskatchewan_in

Unapologetically Authentic | Political commentator. Rhetorical by nature, sarcastic by necessity. Collector of favourite words. #ThinkForYourself. 🧠

◷ Joined January 2021▧ 4,458 Photos and videos
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 17

📢 To Liberal voters still defending this government: I wish you understood what it costs some of us to keep living with your choices. I'm doing everything I can to afford the bare bone basics, and I'm ashamed of how I have to live. Do you know how hard that is to admit? I'm not asking for luxury. I want to afford to eat without wondering what else has to go. I want to pay my bills without worrying if my overdraft is maxed. I never voted for this. I took the time to research the men vying for my vote of confidence in their Prime Ministerial qualities. And yet somehow, I'm the one carrying the shame. You are no longer allowed to carelessly vote for a party instead of the person while moralizing how grateful we should be for our rapidly declining standard of living without some sort of pushback from people like me. The #CarneyvoreEconomy is strangling Canadians and kneecapping our ability to meet basic needs. It's time to hold Liberals accountable for the last 11 years of economic devastation and the impacts on every day Canadians. (Cue the haters... Liberals always hate on these posts... because they can't cope with reality and prefer their fantasy bubbles.)

7:07
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·11h

‼️ When did Canadians agree to become members of the European Union? Associate members or otherwise? Carney did not campaign on that. Winning an election is not a blank cheque to take Canada into a political union without asking Canadians. Read the EU's own membership rules. Full membership means adopting EU law, which takes precedence over conflicting national law within its authority. That goes far beyond trading with Americans as a threat to sovereignty. It concerns who makes the rules we live under and enforce. Any proposed associate arrangement or alliance would depend on its terms. Canadians deserve to know exactly what those terms would mean for our sovereignty before anyone agrees to them. Our country is not his blank cheque. Sign petition, e-7823, demanding full disclosure, protection of Canadian sovereignty and a national referendum before any EU associate membership agreement is signed. It's our country. It's our decision. ourcommons.ca/petitions/en/P…

Post attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 16

🧵 4/4 At this rate, @MarkJCarney will need a new equalization/transfer payment system that makes food equally priced and affordable across Canada. So let me be one to tell you Prime Minister, that you have failed in your duties, failed in your promises and failed Canadians. I don't know how much Normandy Buttertarts cost, but the prices in these images are not sustainable for any family of any income level short of multi-millionaires. WHERE IS THE PROMISED RELIEF? Your #CarneyvoreEconomy is eating us alive! #cdnpoli #UnsustainedInCanada

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 16

🧵 3/4 And the #CarneyvoreEconomy hits across all types of products, regardless of it's origins. Quite often Buy Canadian products cost more than imported products, thanks to various fuel and carbon taxes. So thank you #MarkCarney for moving at speeds never seen before, ensuring all our products are ALL overpriced and expensive. Wouldn't want to find something that is everyday affordable across the country. 🤨 Amd it galls me that papertowels are generally used once and thrown away for that price. A paper product. In a country with the boreal forest! 🤦🏼‍♀️

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 16

🧵 2/4 ‼️ This is the REAL cost of healthy eating in our new "Made in Canada" #CarneyvoreEconomy ▪︎ 3 pounds of apples... $9.99 saving 0.80 ▪︎ Small hand sized watermelon... $8.49 NOT on sale. ▪︎ Honeydew Melon... $9.59 ▪︎ Cantaloupe... $7.43 ▪︎ Loaf of Bread made in 🇨🇦 $5.99 (Elbows Up eh?) To add insult to injury, I had to drive a total of 74km for these bargain basement prices. @FoodProfessor @PierrePoilievre @foodbankscanada #cdnpoli @GasPriceWizard

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 16

🧵 1/4 Welcome to the #CarneyvoreEconomy... eating through your paycheque before you've bought anything to eat. What does that look like where you live? Post your grocery photos or receipts below. Include your general area, the price and package size. Tag your MP and @MarkJCarney. Let's give their affordability speeches a comment section full of price tags. (I uploaded prices from my closest grocery store (74km round trip) into AI for the image. Unaltered images below) #cdnpoli @foodbankscanada @FinanceCanada @PierrePoilievre

Post attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 15

‼️These #Liberals keep confidently telling us they know which companies deserve our money. Then come the layoffs, closures and broken promises, and suddenly we're told nobody - not one single soul - could possibly have seen it coming.🤦🏼‍♀️ I find it quite telling what escapes their attention. They sermonize and give patronizing word salads on how their judgment is perfectly flawless when they're handing out the taxpayer funded cheque, but suddenly nobody knows sweet dick all when we ask what happened to the money. And now we've arrived at @melaniejoly threatening to sue Stellantis while simultaneously offerring to put more taxpayer funded assistance on the table for them to stay. 🤨 So... the company allegedly breached the last agreement, and these governing Liberal morons are entertaining the next one. Has anyone considered making these Liberal judgment calls pass an inspection by a sane, competent private sector panel of professional mental health experts and economists, before issuing another cheque? At my kitchen table, you'd be explaining yourself while I hold your bank card over the paper shredder. But in Ottawa, you get a microphone and another chance to call yourself a job protector. This perfectly demonstrates the farcical disconnect of the liberal government: the workers can lose their livelihoods, and taxpayers can lose their money. But heaven forbid the minister lose confidence in herself.🙄 Please, people of Canada 🇨🇦 #StopElectingIncompetence

"We said the sale would never happen without Unifor and the union supporting it," insists Industry Minister Mélanie Joly about the meetings her most senior staff held with Roshel in advance of its announced purchase of the Stellantis Brampton assembly plant. "There was no side deal."

7:15
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 15

🚨 So @MarkJCarney has found up to $560 million for an international tropical-forest fund. Canadians struggling to afford groceries will be relieved to know their government has located an emergency elsewhere. #Ottawa calls this a "landmark contribution." Well of course it does! Nothing dresses up a questionable spending priority quite like an adjective nobody can deposit.🤦🏼‍♀️ Read the backgrounder: it’s a loan from an existing climate-finance envelope. Okay then... Money already earmarked is still Canadian money. Calling it a loan does not make it spare change. NOTICE WHAT'S MISSING: • What interest will Canada receive? • When is repayment due? • What happens if the investments underperform? The announcement supplies enough congratulatory language for four ministers, but leaves those basic financial terms out. The fund is supposed to use investment returns to finance conservation payments. Before Canadians are volunteered as financiers, perhaps their government could publish the terms rather than simply admire its own generosity. And this sits within Ottawa’s goal of providing over $13 billion in international climate finance by 2031. Meanwhile, Statistics Canada reports that 9.8 million Canadians lived in food-insecure households in 2024. Sure, protecting forests has some value, but that does not settle who should pay, how much #Canada can afford, or why this commitment deserves priority over unmet needs here, at home, on our sovereign (for now) soil for Canadians. Carney was elected to serve Canadians. He keeps treating us as the unwilling sponsors of his international standing and reputation. The world gets the cheque. He gets the applause. Canadians get told what a privilege it is to pay for both. Make it stop! Canada bleeds cash while Canadians quality of life devolve further and further. Can any liberal voters out there please justify this for me like I'm 5 and tell me how impoverishing our nation and people helps us become more sovereign and our own best customers? Where should my elbows be right now? #CarneyLies #cdnpoli #KeepCanadiansFed #StopElectingIncompetence

Prime Minister Carney announces Canada’s landmark contribution to protect the world’s tropical forests: pm.gc.ca/en/news/news-releas…

Post attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 15

‼️ As we all saw, @MarkJCarney called it betrayal. Joly's office said she didn't negotiate the Stellantis sale or meet Roshel. Her chief of staff, policy director and advisers, however, appear in Roshel’s lobbying records... it puts a bit of a hole in the outrage performance if you ask me. The union's letters put more awkward dates beside Ottawa's story. Who knew what, when were they briefed, and why were workers' representatives asking to get into the discussions? Before Carney delivers another betrayal speech, somebody should ask how much of it his own government needs to explain. Read the full story 🔗 melanieinsaskatchewan.substa… 🔗 buymeacoffee.com/melanieinsa…

Post attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 15

"Stellantis betrayed Canadians!" Ottawa says. "We'll sue!" Ottawa says. Now Joly's offering MORE taxpayer money for another promise when she hasn't even enforced the last agreement, you useless bastards! Why are WE paying for the next one? "New government" my ass! Same old dogs, same bloody tricks. So really, the Liberals replaced Trudeau because replacing the bullshit was never on the table.

Joly says Stellantis could get more government money if it promised to keep Brampton plant open, @SpencerLynne reports ctvnews.ca/canada/article/jo… Find out more at nationalnewswatch.com

Post attachment
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 12

This is being heavily throttled back on this platform with limited visibility. Is it my refusal to accept and participate in the Liberal bullshit or is it the wokeness of the topic? Don't answer... I'm being facetious and rhetorical.

Dear Nancy Hamzawi, President of the Public Health Agency of Canada, @GovCanHealth @PHAC_GC : "A pregnant person is a person who is pregnant." 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🙄 That was your answer to Conservative MP @vincentneilho on November 3, 2026, before the Standing Committee on Science and Research. I watched that exchange, and I was disgusted. Canadians deserved an honest answer grounded in reproductive biology. You handed the question back with the words rearranged. We could have saved the salary and bought a photocopier. Better yet, a parrot. No toner, cheaper upkeep, and at least the conversation might be entertaining. Let's work through the exchange in that three-minute, nineteen-second clip. Because, madam, there are answers in there that need considerably more explaining than you gave them. Ho began by asking whether biological reality or gender ideology guided your agency's approach to women's health. You said you did not favour one over the other, then spoke about risks to different populations. Reproductive anatomy is not decided by a show of hands. Your agency should be able to explain what the body does without putting the answer in a little helmet and escorting it past the communications department. Then came your definition: a pregnant person is a person who is pregnant. That explains sweet dick all. Pregnancy requires female reproductive anatomy capable of sustaining it. How somebody identifies does not explain that anatomy, no matter how many focus groups have approved the keywords, adjusted the adjectives and sent the uterus back for a sensitivity review. No amount of verbal macramé changes the organs involved, and it never will! Ho then asked: "How does a pregnant person differ medically from a pregnant woman?" Your reported response began: "A person may choose to, um, (pregnant pause, pardon the pun) a pregnant person is a pregnant person.” Watching that, I thought you looked uncomfortable. I cannot know what you were thinking. I know what I expected for the public money paying for that appearance: a straight answer. Your guidance uses "pregnant women and pregnant people." I object to that wording. Women are people already. The distinction you are trying to make concerns how someone sees themselves. It does not establish a different reproductive process. When Ho pressed further, you explained that some pregnant individuals do not identify as women. Asked whether a man could become pregnant, you referred to someone identifying as a man who retained the biological capacity for pregnancy. Then answer this: when someone identifies as a man and becomes pregnant, what reproductive anatomy makes that pregnancy possible? What has changed about the biology, and what has changed about the terminology? The pregnancy still relies on female reproductive anatomy. Acknowledging that capacity does not tell us somebody’s private thoughts, but it certainly tells us that identity and reproductive sex are not interchangeable explanations. You lead a health agency. Explain the difference. We should not need a parliamentary crowbar to get that much out of you. I spent roughly twenty years in construction, working alongside men every day. Another woman on the crew was the exception. I was a tomboy. I swore, worked hard and felt like one of the boys. Never once did that make me male. Never once did I demand that the crew call me a man and let me piss standing up beside them in camaraderie just to prove they accepted me. I earned their respect by being myself, and I encouraged them to be themselves around me. My interests and personality did not change my sex. I belonged on that site as a woman. No special prefix required, hard hat notwithstanding. Then Ho asked about "birth parent" and whether that meant mother. You answered by referring to the individual who gave birth. I understand birth mother, adoptive mother, stepmother, foster mother and grandmother. Those words explain a relationship. I have given birth three times. I am a mother. That is part of my core identity, not a temporary clerical error waiting for Ottawa to correct it. And I do not call myself “cisgender,” whatever the hell I am expected to do with that. I do not recall anyone asking whether I accepted that label. Yet the same system insists that respecting people's identities means respecting the words they choose for themselves. Does that courtesy extend to me, or have I filled out the wrong form? Can you imagine arriving in Canada, excited to start a new life, doing your damnedest to learn English, then finding "pregnant women and pregnant people" in public health guidance? "Wait a second... I'm confused!" "Is this going to be on a citizenship test? Does anybody know the answer? Bueller? Bueller?" Public health information should make sense to the people trying to use it, including those already struggling with the language. Nobody should need a decoder ring to figure out which advice applies to their body. Women fought for the vote, education, our own money and equal treatment AS women. We demanded the rights and opportunities we deserved. We did not have to become men to deserve them, and equality did not require us to stop being distinctly female. I thought we had finished the chapter where women were expected to keep quiet. Should I start shopping for a cave with decent drainage? Does it come with a fire pit, or am I waiting for some bloke sporting a badgerskin loin cloth dragging a club behind him to discover fire before supper? And for the love of God… please tell me this is not going to take another round of women in the streets burning their bras. With prices where they are and a little girl to raise, every bra I own is staying on active duty. I am being blunt because there will be no mistaking my meaning. People can choose how they live and what they call themselves. They do not get to choose my labels, dictate my beliefs or demand my agreement. I am nearly fifty-two. Woman and mother have meaning in my life that I will not be lectured into treating as an inconvenience. You should be ashamed of how obediently you spewed the approved government word salad at that meeting. You hold a position of public responsibility. Canadians should be able to expect clear answers about reproductive biology from you. Your government keeps telling us to follow the science. Then explain it without tying the English language into another taxpayer-funded plant hanger. I am a woman and a mother. Neither word needs an apology. Neither needs a prefix or an account of my personal history before I am permitted to use it. People don't get pregnant. Women - and ONLY women - get pregnant. And every species save for seahorses knows this! So, in language anyone can understand, the approved government narrative as indicated by Hamzawi's reluctance to speak truthfully is as follows: A biological woman can spend years telling you she's a man. Not as a feeling, but as fact! She doesn't want to be mocked, jeered or frowned upon for conducting herself or living as a man because it will scar her psyche according to government consultants and "experts". So she threatens to end herself if she is not treated in every possible context imaginable, every measurable metric there ever was, as a man and it will always be someone else's fault (yours/ours/humanity probably) if she actually goes through with it. WE are the ones forced to comply to her preference/kink. YOUR behaviour. YOUR tolerances. YOUR thoughts. YOUR speech. YOUR lifelong principles practiced in your religion/faith must be set aside for her but never the other way around. Case in point... Cisgender, . Do you remember being consulted on that label, let alone having it ascribed to you arbitrarily with nary a thought to YOUR preferences? What about TERF? I sure don't! All of your lifelong socially acceptable and encourgaed norms, beliefs and practices, all of society forced to bend around her comfort, like we're extras in her production and she's the only one allowed a real line. Then let's say she has a serious, committed relationship. And she's the only one in it with a functioning uterus and just like that, lickety split she's suddenly a woman for a bit. So she publicly identifies as a man for years, decades even, government legislation punishes anyone refusing to play along, but the moment a baby is wanted, she embraces and engages the very biology that proves no matter how much she identifiest as a man, no matter how much we indulge her, the science says men cannot get pregnant, therefore she must admit she is in fact a woman. At least long enough to justify using her woman parts. Because everybody in that relationship, and everybody on this planet, understands the irrefutable truth she's been denying: only a woman can have a baby. Only a woman menstruates. Only a woman can be pregnant. Ms. Hamzawi studied biochemistry. Ask her to define, medically, the difference between a pregnant woman and a pregnant person. She can't. She won't. Say it plainly: pregnancy depends on female reproductive biology. Say the sentence. The microphone can handle it. Because chromosomes don't care about your wardrobe, your job title, your name, your hormones... none of it. You either have a prostate exam coming in your fifties or you don't. One or the other. Unless you're a seahorse. 👉🏻 Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary · gender /ˈjen-dər/ noun: "sex." sex /seks/ noun: "either of two divisions of organisms distinguished respectively as male or female." @vincentneilho @Tony_Baldinelli @ConnieCodyMP @AmanpreetSGill @SalmaZahid15 @DougEyolfson @JuanitaNathan @mckelvieAJAX @Taleeb #SRSR #ThinkForYourself #PregnantPeopleAreWomen

3:19
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 12

Hey, Carney! You stood before the cameras and called the proposed sale of Stellantis's Brampton plant a betrayal. Your government had known for months that a sale was being considered. You might have worked that into the performance. Canadians should not have to chase down the other people involved to find the parts missing from your speech. On August 12, Stellantis told Unifor it was seriously considering closing and selling Brampton. On September 16, the union wrote to Mélanie Joly asking what role Ottawa had played. By November 4, Unifor was asking for an urgent joint meeting and saying that months of government-company talks had taken place without the union participating. Five days later, the sale agreement was announced. Your government says it has workers' backs. Their representatives were asking to get into the talks about their own workplace. Having their backs was supposed to mean something better than leaving them outside the room. CTV then reported, citing three sources, extensive federal involvement in discussions leading to the sale, including more than a dozen meetings over several months. Joly's office denies she negotiated the deal or met Roshel. It also says the government would not approve an arrangement that failed to honour funding commitments or lacked union approval. Well, I am fresh out of trust. After being burned by Liberal assurances year after year, another denial from a minister's office does not settle a damned thing for me. Your word needs evidence. The letterhead from the PMO has exhausted its usefulness and lost any credibility it once carried. And there are records. Roshel's lobbyist reported contact with Joly's office on August 21 and September 2. Both entries name Paul Moen, Joly's chief of staff; David McFarlane, Joly's policy director; and Yasmin Atassi, a senior policy adviser. The August meeting also included Rene Sylvestre, an investment adviser in Joly's minister's office. The September meeting included Brian Botting, Joly's director of defence industrial strategy. So…Joly's chief of staff. Joly's policy director. Joly's advisers. Her own team was dealing with Roshel. The records give broad subjects, not a transcript of the conversations, but spare me the idea that saying she personally did not meet them settles the matter. Picture this: your chief of staff, policy director and advisers have contact with the company considering buying a plant at the centre of a major dispute in your own department. Somehow, nobody thinks to mention anything useful to you? What are we supposed to imagine they discussed? The weather in Brampton and a reasonably priced lunch? Given what was at stake, I find it incredibly hard to believe Joly was not briefed. If she was, she owes Canadians an account of what she knew. If her own senior staff left her in the dark, that is a different failure, but still with her name on the door. Joly had already told Parliament in October 2025 that Ottawa would use the full force of the law if Stellantis did not bring production back to Brampton. More than a year later, we get a signed sale agreement and another helping of meaningless tough talking word salads . The threat has had plenty of airtime. The result is proving much, much harder to locate. Then there was the funding contract. MPs asked to see it. They received a copy with the relevant parts blacked out. Officials initially pointed to Stellantis over the redactions. Stellantis said the government proposed them. The deputy minister later corrected his account and acknowledged that government officials had initially made them. This was the same session we learned Melanie Joly didn't read the contract she signed. The committee eventually got the full contract. All that trouble to examine the agreement, while Canadians were being told how firmly the government had things in hand. Utter bullspit! That is what I find insulting, Mr. Carney. We hear the promise, the threat and the outrage. Then union letters, committee testimony and reporting fill in what your presentation left out. Canadians should not need a detective's licence to follow their own government. We already have jobs. I can think of a few hundred people in Brampton that would very much like theirs back. Whatever Donald Trump's tariffs contributed to this mess, they do not explain your government's conduct. They do not explain why workers' representatives were asking to join the talks. They do not turn months of warning into a surprise. Trump may be useful at your microphone, but he does not get assigned responsibility for what your own government knew and did. You sold yourself as the man equipped to manage a crisis. Condemning an outcome does not establish that you managed it well. Neither does holding months of meetings before announcing that the result is unacceptable. It establishes that you either attended meetings or were briefed on the discussions. So spare those workers the wounded expression. Your government had warning. Your minister made promises. The union raised the alarm. You cannot now stand before Canadians as though your administration's contribution is to be disappointed alongside them. You called it a betrayal, Mr. Carney. Open the door. Your government belongs in the growing line of people and things that betray Canadians. You should be mortified and ashamed at being caught lying yet again. melanieinsaskatchewan.substa…

Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 12

‼️BREAKING: MORE LIES‼️ @Stellantis signs the Brampton sale agreement. #MarkCarney delivers the betrayal speech. Then the paper trail starts interrupting his performance. Joly's office says she didn't negotiate the sale or meet Roshel. However... the lobbying registry puts Roshel's lobbyist in contact with her chief of staff, her policy director and her advisers. "Oh, those meetings. Well, we are very focussed and all options are on the... look over there! Can somebody turn the camera back to Mr. Carney. He's doing the betrayal portion of his speech. We don't want the receipts spoiling his big scene." Sorry Mélanie, sorry Mark, but the union's letters and lobbying records put some awkward dates beside that contrived and phony betrayal speech. Start with September. This story gets considerably less convenient from there. Sincerely dubious out on the Prairie, Melanie in Saskatchewan Article Links 👇🏻 or read below. 🔗buymeacoffee.com/melanieinsa… 🔗 melanieinsaskatchewan.substa…

Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 12

Dear Nancy Hamzawi, President of the Public Health Agency of Canada, @GovCanHealth @PHAC_GC : "A pregnant person is a person who is pregnant." 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🙄 That was your answer to Conservative MP @vincentneilho on November 3, 2026, before the Standing Committee on Science and Research. I watched that exchange, and I was disgusted. Canadians deserved an honest answer grounded in reproductive biology. You handed the question back with the words rearranged. We could have saved the salary and bought a photocopier. Better yet, a parrot. No toner, cheaper upkeep, and at least the conversation might be entertaining. Let's work through the exchange in that three-minute, nineteen-second clip. Because, madam, there are answers in there that need considerably more explaining than you gave them. Ho began by asking whether biological reality or gender ideology guided your agency's approach to women's health. You said you did not favour one over the other, then spoke about risks to different populations. Reproductive anatomy is not decided by a show of hands. Your agency should be able to explain what the body does without putting the answer in a little helmet and escorting it past the communications department. Then came your definition: a pregnant person is a person who is pregnant. That explains sweet dick all. Pregnancy requires female reproductive anatomy capable of sustaining it. How somebody identifies does not explain that anatomy, no matter how many focus groups have approved the keywords, adjusted the adjectives and sent the uterus back for a sensitivity review. No amount of verbal macramé changes the organs involved, and it never will! Ho then asked: "How does a pregnant person differ medically from a pregnant woman?" Your reported response began: "A person may choose to, um, (pregnant pause, pardon the pun) a pregnant person is a pregnant person.” Watching that, I thought you looked uncomfortable. I cannot know what you were thinking. I know what I expected for the public money paying for that appearance: a straight answer. Your guidance uses "pregnant women and pregnant people." I object to that wording. Women are people already. The distinction you are trying to make concerns how someone sees themselves. It does not establish a different reproductive process. When Ho pressed further, you explained that some pregnant individuals do not identify as women. Asked whether a man could become pregnant, you referred to someone identifying as a man who retained the biological capacity for pregnancy. Then answer this: when someone identifies as a man and becomes pregnant, what reproductive anatomy makes that pregnancy possible? What has changed about the biology, and what has changed about the terminology? The pregnancy still relies on female reproductive anatomy. Acknowledging that capacity does not tell us somebody’s private thoughts, but it certainly tells us that identity and reproductive sex are not interchangeable explanations. You lead a health agency. Explain the difference. We should not need a parliamentary crowbar to get that much out of you. I spent roughly twenty years in construction, working alongside men every day. Another woman on the crew was the exception. I was a tomboy. I swore, worked hard and felt like one of the boys. Never once did that make me male. Never once did I demand that the crew call me a man and let me piss standing up beside them in camaraderie just to prove they accepted me. I earned their respect by being myself, and I encouraged them to be themselves around me. My interests and personality did not change my sex. I belonged on that site as a woman. No special prefix required, hard hat notwithstanding. Then Ho asked about "birth parent" and whether that meant mother. You answered by referring to the individual who gave birth. I understand birth mother, adoptive mother, stepmother, foster mother and grandmother. Those words explain a relationship. I have given birth three times. I am a mother. That is part of my core identity, not a temporary clerical error waiting for Ottawa to correct it. And I do not call myself “cisgender,” whatever the hell I am expected to do with that. I do not recall anyone asking whether I accepted that label. Yet the same system insists that respecting people's identities means respecting the words they choose for themselves. Does that courtesy extend to me, or have I filled out the wrong form? Can you imagine arriving in Canada, excited to start a new life, doing your damnedest to learn English, then finding "pregnant women and pregnant people" in public health guidance? "Wait a second... I'm confused!" "Is this going to be on a citizenship test? Does anybody know the answer? Bueller? Bueller?" Public health information should make sense to the people trying to use it, including those already struggling with the language. Nobody should need a decoder ring to figure out which advice applies to their body. Women fought for the vote, education, our own money and equal treatment AS women. We demanded the rights and opportunities we deserved. We did not have to become men to deserve them, and equality did not require us to stop being distinctly female. I thought we had finished the chapter where women were expected to keep quiet. Should I start shopping for a cave with decent drainage? Does it come with a fire pit, or am I waiting for some bloke sporting a badgerskin loin cloth dragging a club behind him to discover fire before supper? And for the love of God… please tell me this is not going to take another round of women in the streets burning their bras. With prices where they are and a little girl to raise, every bra I own is staying on active duty. I am being blunt because there will be no mistaking my meaning. People can choose how they live and what they call themselves. They do not get to choose my labels, dictate my beliefs or demand my agreement. I am nearly fifty-two. Woman and mother have meaning in my life that I will not be lectured into treating as an inconvenience. You should be ashamed of how obediently you spewed the approved government word salad at that meeting. You hold a position of public responsibility. Canadians should be able to expect clear answers about reproductive biology from you. Your government keeps telling us to follow the science. Then explain it without tying the English language into another taxpayer-funded plant hanger. I am a woman and a mother. Neither word needs an apology. Neither needs a prefix or an account of my personal history before I am permitted to use it. People don't get pregnant. Women - and ONLY women - get pregnant. And every species save for seahorses knows this! So, in language anyone can understand, the approved government narrative as indicated by Hamzawi's reluctance to speak truthfully is as follows: A biological woman can spend years telling you she's a man. Not as a feeling, but as fact! She doesn't want to be mocked, jeered or frowned upon for conducting herself or living as a man because it will scar her psyche according to government consultants and "experts". So she threatens to end herself if she is not treated in every possible context imaginable, every measurable metric there ever was, as a man and it will always be someone else's fault (yours/ours/humanity probably) if she actually goes through with it. WE are the ones forced to comply to her preference/kink. YOUR behaviour. YOUR tolerances. YOUR thoughts. YOUR speech. YOUR lifelong principles practiced in your religion/faith must be set aside for her but never the other way around. Case in point... Cisgender, . Do you remember being consulted on that label, let alone having it ascribed to you arbitrarily with nary a thought to YOUR preferences? What about TERF? I sure don't! All of your lifelong socially acceptable and encourgaed norms, beliefs and practices, all of society forced to bend around her comfort, like we're extras in her production and she's the only one allowed a real line. Then let's say she has a serious, committed relationship. And she's the only one in it with a functioning uterus and just like that, lickety split she's suddenly a woman for a bit. So she publicly identifies as a man for years, decades even, government legislation punishes anyone refusing to play along, but the moment a baby is wanted, she embraces and engages the very biology that proves no matter how much she identifiest as a man, no matter how much we indulge her, the science says men cannot get pregnant, therefore she must admit she is in fact a woman. At least long enough to justify using her woman parts. Because everybody in that relationship, and everybody on this planet, understands the irrefutable truth she's been denying: only a woman can have a baby. Only a woman menstruates. Only a woman can be pregnant. Ms. Hamzawi studied biochemistry. Ask her to define, medically, the difference between a pregnant woman and a pregnant person. She can't. She won't. Say it plainly: pregnancy depends on female reproductive biology. Say the sentence. The microphone can handle it. Because chromosomes don't care about your wardrobe, your job title, your name, your hormones... none of it. You either have a prostate exam coming in your fifties or you don't. One or the other. Unless you're a seahorse. 👉🏻 Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary · gender /ˈjen-dər/ noun: "sex." sex /seks/ noun: "either of two divisions of organisms distinguished respectively as male or female." @vincentneilho @Tony_Baldinelli @ConnieCodyMP @AmanpreetSGill @SalmaZahid15 @DougEyolfson @JuanitaNathan @mckelvieAJAX @Taleeb #SRSR #ThinkForYourself #PregnantPeopleAreWomen

3:19
Melanie In Saskatchewan avatar
Melanie In Saskatchewan@saskatchewan_in·Nov 11

🪖 There are names on cenotaphs across this country that belonged to somebody's whole world. A son who never came home. A husband whose side of the bed stayed empty. A father whose children grew up knowing his face from a photograph. A young woman who put on a uniform and accepted risks most of us will never have to imagine. Before they were names carved in stone, they were people with unfinished lives. Today, I remember them. I remember those who returned carrying wounds other people could see, and those who spent the rest of their lives carrying wounds nobody could. I remember the families who waited, the families who grieved, and the generations who lived with the consequences. My own family's history is part of that sacrifice. This is personal. And this year, alongside the gratitude, I feel an anger I cannot politely tuck behind a poppy. Because I look at Canada, and increasingly, I do not recognize what we are allowing it to become. I remember a country where a working life came with a reasonable expectation of building something. A home and some savings. A future your children might actually afford to inherit, and where being Canadian meant something more substantial than whatever slogan the government had purchased that week. Now I see people working and falling behind. Parents quietly putting things back at the grocery store. Young adults wondering whether independence is something their generation will ever afford. Seniors calculating which necessity can wait. And I see a federal government that has spent the years over the last decade asking Canadians to applaud its intentions while living with its untenable consequences. We have been lectured about compassion by politicians who expanded immigration without ensuring that housing and services could keep pace. Welcoming people requires somewhere for them to live and a functioning country for them to join. Refugees need more than a Minister's photograph. Communities need more than instructions to absorb the pressure and keep smilingwhile pilot programs become permanent routes to changing your rural demographics from what they have always been. During COVID, I watched the space for disagreement shrink. I watched neighbours become categories. I heard demands for obedience dressed up as moral superiority, and I have not forgotten how quickly asking questions became a character defect. I WILL NOT ACCEPT THAT AS THE STANDARD OF CITIZENSHIP WE OWE OUR CHILDREN! Justin Trudeau spoke of Canada having "no core identity." I think of the people who crossed an ocean wearing this country's name and flag, and I wonder how their descendants were supposed to receive that. What, exactly, were we being invited to stop belonging to? A country has a history. It has obligations. It has laws, institutions and freedoms that belong to its people. Those things require care. They require loyalty from the people entrusted to govern. Canada is not the personal property of a prime minister. It is not a branding exercise, a networking opportunity or an international announcement waiting for a backdrop. And Canadians are entitled to demand that decisions about their future be explained, debated and accountable to them. That includes Mark Carney. A different man at the microphone does not erase the record of the government behind him. "Masters of Our Destiny" is a handsome title. I would prefer a country where ordinary Canadians felt they had some control over theirs. I want my daughter to inherit a home she can maintain, a country she can belong to, and the freedom to speak without first checking whether her opinion meets government approval. I want her to understand that citizenship carries responsibilities, including the responsibility to question power. Especially power that insists questioning it makes YOU the problem. I will not pretend to know how every person we honour today would vote. Their sacrifice belongs to the country, and no political party gets to claim it. But I know what remembrance requires of me. Gratitude. Honesty. And enough backbone to defend the freedoms I was fortunate enough to inherit. The government does not become the country simply because it wins an election. Criticizing it is part of holding it responsible for the country in its care. So today, I will bow my head for those who served. I will remember the lives cut short, the families changed forever, and the terrible price paid for the peace in which I am raising my child. Then I will lift my head. Because two minutes of silence should never become a lifetime of it. Lest we forget. And having remembered, let us act like we owe them something.

Post attachment