←
Sean Donahue577 posts
Sean Donahue avatar

Sean Donahue

@seantankerous

Lacking in characters.

◷ Joined April 2014▧ 13 Photos and videos
Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·23 Aug 2024

On the latest effort by fossil friends -- supported by amicus US Chamber of Commerce, which is filled with companies that support climate action -- to block even the most conventional controls on emissions from our biggest sources. legal-planet.org/2024/08/23/…

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·4 Jul 2024

How about a constitutional amendment to establish what we thought was established in 1787: that the President is not above the law?

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·28 Jun 2024

But this “Chevron-violates-the-APA” ruling preserves something important: Going forward, Congress may still provide for deferential judicial review -- a position that the Article III-based theory for overturning Chevron favored by Justice Gorsuch would not have.

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·28 Jun 2024

The Court has corrected the "nitrous oxide" references in the Good Neighbor decision. In the coming days, I'll be noting add'l errors that should prompt more far-reaching changes. (Seriously, EPA should prevail -- as the Act recognizes, we need controls on interstate pollution).

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·27 Jun 2024

Justice Gorsuch's opinion refers five times to "nitrous oxide" (aka laughing gas) rather than the entirely different chemical compound -- smog-causing "nitrogen oxides" -- actually at issue in the case.

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·27 Jun 2024

There are far more serious problems with today's decision in the Ohio v. EPA staying EPA's Good Neighbor Rule, but ...

EDF avatar
⟳ Sean Donahue retweeted
EDF@EnvDefenseFund·21 May 2024

Make it make sense. Fossil fuel power plants cause about 1/4 of U.S.CO2 emissions. And the industry *seemed* to support EPA’s efforts to cut them. Now this📷 from @Edison_Electric, which reps companies like @SCE @portlandgeneral @xcelenergy @Exelon?!?📷 eenews.net/articles/edison-e…

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·17 Jan 2024

Section 706 of the APA did not apply in Chevron, which was a Clean Air Act case under a significantly different review statute. So accusing Justice Stevens of "whiffing" on Section 706 in Chevron is a self-own. Let's see if the Court goes there too.

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·17 Jan 2024

Where, exactly, does the Constitution "say" that the interpretive power rests exclusively with courts? Answer: nowhere. And there's a fair bit of language in it that would suggest that the Executive has a key interpretive role.

Sean Donahue avatar
Sean Donahue@seantankerous·15 Jan 2024

I don’t know what the Court will do. And it might recast the groundrules for judicial deference relatively benign (or maybe even salutary) ways. But adopting the sweeping arguments presented by the Deconstructionists would be a disaster for our republic and its people.