←
Seena Fazel4,209 posts
Seena Fazel avatar

Seena Fazel

@seenafazel

Prof of Forensic Psychiatry, Oxford University; researching adverse outcomes in mental illness, suicide prevention, forensic mental health

◷ Joined December 2014▧ 818 Photos and videos
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Nov 17

New risk assessment tools/models for suicide in people with schizophrenia and a separate one people with bipolar disorder. Developed in a national cohort in Sweden, externally validated in Finland. With a net benefit analysis - for the first time that addresses key evidence gap

In our latest paper (w/ @seenafazel & @RongqinYu), we have redeveloped the Oxford Mental Illness and Suicide tool (OxMIS) as diagnosis-specific models for schizophrenia-spectrum disorders (n = 48 373) and bipolar disorder (n = 61 684) using nationwide Swedish data, and validated them externally in equivalent data from Finland (n = 52 117 and 30 444, respectively). Discrimination was moderate for schizophrenia-spectrum disorders and good for bipolar disorder, calibration was generally good, and both models showed greater net benefit than treat-all or treat-none strategies at lower risk thresholds. Interestingly, we did not find that adding sociodemographic predictors improved predictive performance. Full-text: mentalhealth.bmj.com/content…

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 31

Forensic psych research seminar on 16 November in Oxford. Draft programme 👇 Need to register. Online attendance also possible - registration below.

Post attachment

Forensic Psychiatry Research Society annual meeting on 16 November (10am-5pm) at Pembroke College, Oxford. New research presentations in morning; risk assessment masterclass in afternoon (focus on methods and systematic reviews) To register and book: eventbrite.co.uk/e/199928154…

Crémieux avatar
⟳ Seena Fazel retweeted
Crémieux@cremieuxrecueil·Oct 19

Researchers gave 2,000 unemployed people €560/month for two years and tracked them to see how they differed from otherwise eligible nonrecipients. They didn't do any more or less crime. Nothing changed.

Post attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 12

Our response to the critique of our RNR umbrella review. The title of McGuire et Al’s critique, ‘Significantly off target’, is perhaps more apt than intended, given how much weight it places on statistical sign. Not quite nominative determinism but not miles away.

1/6 Scientific disagreement is a good thing. But criticism should accurately represent the work being criticised. We have published our response to a commentary on our umbrella review of the evidence behind the Risk–Need–Responsivity (RNR) model. #criminology #CrimTwitter

Post attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 8

Our conclusions are unchanged: some evidence supports components of RNR, but its quality, consistency and transparency are limited. Until higher-quality evidence exists, we do not think RNR should be introduced into new jurisdictions. Original review #OA: sciencedirect.com/science/ar…

Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 8

We also respond on study selection, use of AUCs, quality appraisal and overlap between reviews. RNR has influenced criminal justice policy internationally. The more influential a framework becomes, the more its evidential base needs to withstand independent examination.

Post attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 8

Nor does a well-conducted review mean the evidence it synthesises is reliable. How well a review was conducted and how much confidence can be placed in its results are different questions. Our review assessed both.

Post attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 8

Commentary places considerable weight on the number of statistically significant results. But statistically significant doesn't mean strong, reliable or meaningful in practice. An effect can be significant yet rest on studies at high risk of bias. Paper: sciencedirect.com/science/ar…

Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Oct 8

1/6 Scientific disagreement is a good thing. But criticism should accurately represent the work being criticised. We have published our response to a commentary on our umbrella review of the evidence behind the Risk–Need–Responsivity (RNR) model. #criminology #CrimTwitter

Post attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Sep 16

Performance good across discrimination + calibration 👇 Next steps include external calibration and examining clinical utility. Limitations - potential predictors not available (e.g. impulsivity, symptoms, family support), underreporting of self-harm.

Post attachment
Seena Fazel avatar
Seena Fazel@seenafazel·Sep 16

New findings on risk factors. Comorbidity with psychiatric condition strong effect - highlights importance of liaison w/ mental health services. Notable difference with other populations in effect of previous self-harm. Clear example of where multivariable models add value.

Post attachment