←
The Nuanced Writer779 posts
The Nuanced Writer avatar

The Nuanced Writer

@skriptble

Writer. Engineer. Gets lost in nuance. Always asking meta questions. @fallthroughfm host & producer; previously @GoTimeFM host. 🏳️‍🌈

◷ Joined July 2013▧ 44 Photos and videos
The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·22h

There have been a number of outages in the last week, and it might feel like something exceptional has happened. It has not. We just have much shorter term memories than we think. It was a little over a year ago when AWS, Azure, and Cloudflare had severe outages within weeks of each other. And we shouldn’t forget about CrowdStrike in 2024. It doesn’t help that the news media is running around as if a bunch of abnormal things occurred. Software has bugs in it, pretty much all of it has a bug somewhere. Looking into the preliminary causes for several of these outages it’s clear there are components that were installed long before the outage occurred. If we want to blame AI for some of this, I’d say the space for that is with engineers being force to write more and more software with the assistance of LLMs and write that software faster. Before we start thinking something nefarious has happened we should first sit down and determine whether something unusual is happening at all. In this case, the unusual aspect is that it broke into the consciousness of the public and the way in which people experienced these outages, not the outages themselves.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Nov 16

Complex systems fail in complex ways. Both the FAA ground stop on Friday and the Microsoft Outlook outage tell us a lot about our current stance on technology, but the coverage seems to get things quite wrong. People want to point fingers and blame people, and there are plenty of correlated events that could be blamed. But the reality is that the warnings about this stuff has existed for a long time, and it’s everywhere. We’ve become an industry and society obsessed with irrational thinking. We all understand that the cost of things increase overtime, but we seem unwilling to pay more to keep the same service. We think price increases should come with more: more service, new features, more capacity. The more that I’ve looked at the FAA ground stop, the more it’s obvious that not enough fund were allocated when they needed to be allocated to ensure that the required upgrades could happen before they became emergencies. The FAA was saying, going back a decade, that the copper lines were getting decommissioned and they’d need to migrate to fiber. As with most programs that provide the same service after spending quite large sums of money, this one got under funded and pushed off. The result is that these upgrades had to happen on aggressive timelines. The FAA warned this might happen again, but I’m surprised it hasn’t happened much earlier. Ultimately, what we should all be doing is asking whether there are vital services or systems that we’ve neglected that need funding or attention and focus on getting those the funding or attention they need. And we absolutely need to stop complaining about having to pay more money to maintain or upgrade things that do not change the status quo.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Nov 12

There’s something magically about writing on a page with a pen. Filling notebooks with your own words is an incredible experience and feeling.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Nov 2

Too many influencers say dumb things about companies and their products. It’s boring when people make videos listing off stats, making comparisons to other products, and saying how much things have declined. Meanwhile, the company did market research and decided where to allocate resources. It’s reasonable to criticize companies. But it’s pretty boring when people read off spec sheets and list off prices as if a company’s product portfolio is a series of independent products instead of an integrated set.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Nov 1

LLMs are terrible at making taglines. They make weird tagline shaped things that don’t make sense when you actually try to parse or think about them. The beauty of a tagline is that it’s one of those “a few words is worth a thousand pictures” moments and you can’t easily predict that sort of thing.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 31

Reading output from LLMs is like reading the partial output of someone’s thoughts. I thought I didn’t like the constant hedging and contrast that LLMs produce, but it’s actually that the hedge comes out of nowhere because it’s missing some early assumption the LLM made but never output.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 28

The d in dvcs being “distributed” instead of “decentralized” is another one of those unfortunate naming things that has cursed us. Perhaps if we called Git decentralized people would have resisted centralizing it. Or at least it would seem as silly to do that as it actually is.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 27

I really wish companies would stop shoving crappy AI features into their products unless they’ve made the core thing stable and solid.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 26

All trades are creative and all trades are analytical. The idea that some forms of work are lack creativity is falsehood we sort of made up. Disciplines like accounting, engineering, math, and plumbing all require a great deal of creativity. On the other hand, disciplines like writing, music, and art all require analytical thinking. Keeping canon correct, fitting the pieces of a poem together, making lyrics fit well with rhythm, there are rules one must follow to do it well, and specific rules one can break to create something new. We should stop thinking of disciplines as creative or analytical or technical and start thinking of them as the complex mix of those things that they actually are.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 26

“That’s the part that stuck with me” There are too many sentences now that have ascended so rapidly to cliched stereotype that it makes one’s brain twitch when read. The choppy blocks passing as sentences in LLM generated writing seem plausible only if one mixes all the genres of writing together.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 19

In hindsight, the idea of NFTs wasn’t silly, it’s that they were targeted at a market of people who doesn’t understand why easily copied objects are worth owning the original of. NFTs never reached the point of having the necessary legal structure around them either. So many of the arguments around NFTs didn’t make sense but they sounded like zingers so people gave in. Like, there are plenty of house developments with hundreds of carbon copy houses, but people don’t say those houses are worthless because there’s so many copies of them. Similarly, no one says that famous paintings are worthless because they’ve been mass reproduced. NFTs could have ascended into the class of objects used for wealth purposes, but that market never developed. But the underlying idea is actually a quite good one. It’s similar to how the idea of a decentralized public ledger is useful in a whole bunch of ways. And while NFTs didn’t work out, I’d put them in the same class of idea as the prediction-market-using-futures-contracts idea that’s exploded recently. Sometimes ideas flop, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the idea was bad, it might just be that it was aimed at the wrong demographic.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 16

Too many people don’t know what liberal arts are or what actually falls within their scope. Also, maybe people confuse liberal arts with humanities? Although even then, it doesn’t seem like enough people know the scope of the humanities either.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 15

Feels as good a time as any to remind you that *distributed* and *decentralized* are not the same thing. They are orthogonal actually, existing within different domains. It’s a lot like how serializability and lineaeizability are not the same thing and also orthogonal.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 15

It’s going to be real funny if this class of models that we’ve called “generative models” actually wind up being so much more useful as interpretation engines that we effectively stop using them for generation. That would also be 100% aligned with how naming in this industry goes.

The Nuanced Writer avatar
The Nuanced Writer@skriptble·Oct 13

As much as I dislike LLM generated writing, I think I hate it more when it winds up as the script for a YouTube video. LLM writing sounds worse when read aloud.