←
Karan Sood108 posts
Karan Sood avatar

Karan Sood

@soodk

vestfin.com/field-notes

◷ Joined February 2010▧ 14 Photos and videos
Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

“Don't put all your eggs in one basket” is good advice. But… … What if all the baskets are all on the same wagon? … What if your portfolio of stocks, bonds, private assets, and commodities gives you the illusion of being diversified but is concentrated around the same risks? … What if the machinery of our industry keeps reinforcing such concentration? … What if we are all in the grips of a Diversification Delusion?

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

Back to the eggs and baskets: the question isn't just how many we own. It's what could make them break together and what we've done about that risk. Diversification remains useful. The delusion may be believing that it has finished the risk-management job. Some concentration are unavoidable, but accepting every risk that comes with it does not need to be. The full essay: vestfin.com/field-notes/post…

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

There is no free protection. Buying a put costs money. Selling some upside can help pay for protection. You give up gains beyond an agreed level. Derivatives help reshape the return distribution of the stock. It’s investing, but with guardrails.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

An investor may want to own a stock without accepting every possible loss over the next year. A put option can give them the right to sell at an agreed price during a specified period. That is a different mechanism from adding another investment in the hope that its returns offset the stock's losses.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

Outside investing, we understand the distinction between owning something and accepting every risk that comes with it. A family doesn't buy five houses to manage the risk of one burning down. It buys insurance. Insurance doesn’t make the house fireproof. Instead, a specified financial risk is transferred to someone willing to bear it for a price. That distinction can be made in portfolio construction too. Diversification can reduce risk. Explicit risk transfer, through derivatives, can address some of the risk that remains.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

The global derivatives market stood at roughly $628 trillion in notional value, about five times world GDP and roughly four times global equity market capitalization. Numbers that large do not grow from hype. They grow from utility, and from deep structural usefulness recognized by the institutions that shape global finance. This utility is finally finding its way to the broad market.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

So if there are limits to risk management by diversification what should we do? A selection of investors has advertised a solution by voting with their dollars. $ billions have poured into a new category of products that seeks to solve this problem. Derivative-based defined outcome funds have become one of the fastest-growing segments of the investment products market.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#8. Reflexivity: success can change the investment. A strategy that finds a profitable pricing gap, will advertise a record that will attract more investors and competitors. The increasing trades narrow the gap. Some managers may borrow more to maintain returns. Now portfolios that once appeared independent share crowded positions and dependence on financing. The strategy's historical low correlation may describe how it behaved before it became popular.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#7. Gatekeeping: the scorecard can shape the product. Before an investment reaches a client, it needs approval from home-office staff, intermediary consultants, research teams or investment committees. They need comparable categories, benchmarks and track records. Understandably so. But a strategy designed to behave differently can struggle to fit the pervasively common framework used to judge it. Product developers then have commercial reasons to build similar products that the framework accepts. Nobody has to coordinate this. The committee wants a defensible decision and the manufacturer wants an approved product.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#6. Benchmarking: being different can itself become a problem. A manager may believe that the index depends too heavily on a few companies and reduces those positions. But those companies keep rising and the manager falls behind. Reducing concentration risk has increased the risk of underperforming the benchmark. Meanwhile, passive funds reproduce the index's weights, and benchmark-conscious active managers face pressure to stay close. An investor can hire several managers and still end up owning variations of the same portfolio.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#5. Occupational hazards: whose risk is being managed? An investment manager that reports losses, while competitors do so too, has a familiar explanation: “the market fell”. A manager that loses while everyone else prospers must answer difficult questions: “Why did you buy that? What did you think you knew?” These forces create professional dis-incentives to choose investments that introduce a genuinely different risk that may help diversify the client's portfolio. This doesn't require dishonesty or incompetence. Being wrong with everyone else can simply be easier to professionally survive than being wrong alone.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#4. Leverage: assets connected by the borrowing you never did A risk-parity fund owns stocks and government bonds, partly financed with borrowed money. Stocks fall, and a lender demands more collateral. The fund sells bonds to raise cash. Not because it has lost confidence in the government, but because the bonds may be easy to sell. The connection isn't necessarily between the assets' cash flows, but between the balance sheets of the people holding them.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#3. Fundamentals: different categories but part of the same economy One person's spending is another person's income. The employee buying goods from a retailer may also be paying the mortgage held in a bond portfolio. If that employee loses their job, both the retailer's revenue and the mortgage payments can suffer. We label one investment “equities” and the other “fixed income,” but the labels don't break the economic connection between them.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#2. Sentiment: different investments subject to similar emotions. A retailer and a software company sell different things. But their investors can become optimistic, or frightened, together. Both businesses may still be operating much as before, while investors become less willing to pay for an uncertain future. Their prices can fall together before either reports weaker earnings. The companies may not have much in common, but the confidence supporting their valuations may have.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

#1. Macro factors: different assets but getting pulled by the same gravity. What does a long-term bond, a rental property and a company whose profits lie far in the future have in common? Their value depends partly on what investors will pay today for money arriving later. When interest rates rise, those future cash flows become worth less today. Different investments can therefore come under pressure from the same change in the price of money. You can diversify the sources of cash flow while remaining concentrated in interest-rate risk.

Karan Sood avatar
Karan Sood@soodk·9h

The deeper problem is that assets which appear independent often share hidden links. Here are some drivers that connect them: 1. Macro factors 2. Sentiment 3. Fundamentals 4. Leverage 5. Occupational Hazards 6. Benchmarking 7. Gatekeeping 8. Reflexivity