I've written an article about the proposed CEBP for 2027 and my feedback towards it.
I support the need for better Treasury coordination, but have substantial concerns about institutional concentration, conflicts of interest, and independent oversight. Full assessment👇🏻
x.com/RodrigoPacini/status/2…
Cardano’s next budget cycle: how can we improve coordination and help DReps assess funding proposals?
We’re sharing a proposed Cardano Ecosystem Budget Process for 2027 and inviting your feedback.
Read the proposal: intersectmbo.org/news/a-more…
Join the discussion: dreptalk.com/t/a-more-strate…
I've published my independent review of the proposed CEBP for 2027.
I support the need for better Treasury coordination, but have substantial concerns about institutional concentration, conflicts of interest, and independent oversight.
Full assessment👇🏻
hackmd.io/@CEF-RDdySpK5Aabyb…#Cardano#Blockchain
Cardano’s next budget cycle: how can we improve coordination and help DReps assess funding proposals?
We’re sharing a proposed Cardano Ecosystem Budget Process for 2027 and inviting your feedback.
Read the proposal: intersectmbo.org/news/a-more…
Join the discussion: dreptalk.com/t/a-more-strate…
Two Mistakes of Strategic Problem Solving
1. Anticipatory Waste - Presumptive progression before a logical critical path has been established
The eager student sets about answering questions before he knows what is being asked, and takes great pride in the mountain of answers he must eventually throw away.
Doing the wrong work, or unnecessary work, because the sequence of necessary work has not been determined.
2. Premature Cognitive Entanglement - Presumptive depth before an economy-of-soundness plan has been established
The foolish mason takes such pride in his bricklaying that he has built three perfect walls before troubling himself to discover where they were even supposed to go.
Undertaking potentially relevant work at an unwarranted level of detail, consuming cognitive, attentional, or process capacity before the investigation's economic resource architecture has been established.
All DReps and the community are welcome to an interview with representatives from Trivolve Tech. We will discuss their proposal: "PFMS: Bringing Government Scale Adoption to Cardano" by Trivolve Tech.
Who represents you in Cardano governance?
This November, Intersect Civics Committee is asking ADA holders to take a few minutes to check in on their DRep, review recent votes, and active DReps.
Keep your DRep or choose a new one. The choice is yours.
#CheckYourDRep
Soteriarchic Complex
A Soteriarchic Complex is a coalition of the willful and the self-blind: those who act with deliberate malice, and those who unknowingly advance that same agenda under the banner of virtue.
The first group—the consciously manipulative—often draws from occult or esoteric agency that redefine inversion as enlightenment. Destruction, deception, and domination are reframed as paths to illumination. Historically, such actors have learned to infiltrate bureaucratic and scientific institutions, concealing their ideology behind the language of reason, policy, and 'expertise.' They prosper in opaque systems where authority is rarely questioned.
The second group—those unaware of the deeper agency—practice what can be called apophasis-hate: a morality based not on what fruit they produce, but on what they oppose. They believe suppression equals righteousness, and mistake the silencing of dissent for moral progress. In systems terms, this becomes a negative-value-chain of virtue signaling—a process that feeds on its own self-approval while eroding the integrity of information and trust.
Together, these groups form a dual-phase corruption:
Phase I – Ideological Conduction: a nucleus of power or occult intent sets the direction.
Phase II – Administrative Resonance: well-meaning but epistemically captured individuals carry that intent forward through procedures and policies that appear virtuous.
This structure endures precisely because the second group, believing themselves righteous, protects the first from exposure. The result is a self-sustaining moral inversion—an institution that proclaims to save, while quietly consuming the very good it claims to defend.
Absolutely in love with his conversation w/ @dr_mcgilchrist .
Science needs both rigor and imagination. Our methods help us test what we think we know, while curiosity helps us see connections and ask questions that don’t fit so perfectly within one field.
We haven’t seen the same kind of major breakthroughs since the 1970s, probably in part because we’ve lost the capacity to follow the intuition and curiosity that help us see how the pieces connect to the whole.
Why have we become so focused on the details, and so concerned with maintaining rigor, that we’ve lost sight of the bigger picture? Is it funding? Is it how we train the next gen of scholars?
With so much instability in science right now, how do we use this high entropic state to carve a new path toward discoveries that last and actually help our lives, our communities and the world flourish?
It's high time we as scientists have an open conversation about this.
Tapping a few fellow scientists , love to hear your thoughts/suggestions to embrace
@LocasaleLab@JasonSynaptic@slavov_n@itchdoctor@drmichaellevin@skdh@leslievosshall@MitoPsychoBio
Does the scientific method actually hold science back?
We’re taught that progress is driven by strict rules, reductive analysis, and cold hard logic.
But psychiatrist and philosopher Iain McGilchrist argues the opposite: history’s greatest scientific breakthroughs didn't come from following the rules—they came from breaking them.
In this interview with Oliver Adelson, McGilchrist explains why discovering new paradigms requires abandoning rigid reductionism in favour of a holistic, interconnected view of the world.
Read the full conversation here: iai.tv/articles/iain-mcgilch…
Konnichiwa Yuta,
Thank you for reviewing the proposal in detail. I am taking this opportunity to address your rationale.
1-1) The 9,100 figure does not represent evidence items or cases. Each token does not represent a single case, and the actual number of cases processed through FMS is not publicly disclosed by the state.
For PFMS, the 1.53M figure is calculated just from the first deployment that too in first yr itself. The tx number of 1.53 million is a confirmed floor baseline with the first user of PFMS, calculated from the government’s expected operational volumes across all five stages. This will grow yoy with adoption.
PFMS is also not being built for one state. The first state is already onboarded as the initial user, and we have Expression of Interest (EOI) with two additional Indian states and are in active discussions with multiple other states that are ready to follow once the first deployment is live, along with international interest including INTERPOL, german police and Siberian government stakeholders.
The first deployment takes 15 months as we are building the reusable PFMS core. Once that foundation exists, subsequent state rollouts are expected to take roughly 3 to 4 months each, because the six engines, smart contracts, identity layer and verification layer do not need to be rebuilt.
1-2) The batching policy is based on the discussions with multiple state government’s evidentiary requirements of how the evidence should be secured. It is not a vendor choice and it is published at M3.
More importantly, M3 is not just “100,000 transactions and payment.” Those transactions must come from live sources through the deployed mainnet contracts, after penetration testing, across all five stages, with the verification layer live and the core codebase open sourced. In PFMS design, each record is signed by a device DID and an officer credential, every onchain transaction carries a registry digest, the signer is multi sig, and the M4 report breaks usage down by registered source. M4 then requires 390,000 transactions after PFMS is live on mainnet from live sources over three months across all five stages with continuous daily activity, plus reporting on which stages and registered sources produced that activity.
So the requirement is not simply to produce transactions. It is to prove sustained transaction activity coming from a live deployment of the first user of PFMS.
1-3) PFMS has a materially different scope and economic model.
The 1.53M annual mainnet transactions come from the first deployment alone, based on the first government user’s expected operational volumes across all five stages of the chain of evidence. This number of transaction is a confirmed floor for the first year which will grow YoY with adoption.
PFMS is also not limited to transaction fees. The verification layer creates a recurring revenue stream because verification involves the entire evidence trail, not simply checking one final file.
Using a conservative scenario from the first deployment alone with 290,000 expected cases per year (3.2M evidence with estimated 11 evidence item categories per case), out of which if only 20% of them use paid verification and on average 3 verification requests per life of a case @ $3.6 average per verification request.
That produces about $628,366/year in verification revenue, of which approximately $439,856/year returns to the Cardano Treasury and another $125,673/year supports core Cardano libraries. At that level, the Treasury equivalent payback is roughly 5 years, or about 3.9 years when Treasury + ecosystem library funding are considered together.
The larger point is that this compounds with adoption. The first state is already onboarded. We also have EOIs with two additional Indian states, active discussions with other states, and international interest with Interpol, German Police and Siberian government. Once the reusable core is built, those deployments do not require another 15-month rebuild.
2) Our intention is to not to move ADA’s price with announcements. That is not the credibility PFMS is designed to create.
Cardano is currently a top 15 network by market cap, yet the onchain transaction activity is still relatively low. Our intention behind PFMS for Cardano is to close that gap and be part of achieving the 2030 KPI goals and to do so Cardano requires sustained growth in real mainnet usage, protocol revenue and institutional adoption. PFMS contributes to that by putting a government’s day to day operational activity on Cardano, with the government itself paying the transaction fees. One successful government deployment makes the next one easier, and multiple deployments create a snowball effect in usage, fees and institutional confidence.
We are measuring the impact by whether Cardano becomes infrastructure that governments actually depend on, pay to use, and continue using for years. That kind of enterprise adoption is exactly what will matter to reach Cardano 2030 KPIs.
Should the treasury pay for this at all?
Neutrality is one reason, but it is not the only reason the Treasury is being asked to fund PFMS. PFMS is being developed as an open source solution, available through a public GitHub repository, that could be adopted by law enforcement agencies around the world.
Any single state can not fund an open source product for other Indian states, future international jurisdictions, to specifically use Cardano, or to structure verification revenue so that 70% flows back to the Cardano Treasury and 20% to core cardano library maintenance. None of those outcomes would be guaranteed under a normal government procurement model.
So the Treasury is paying for the part that belongs to Cardano: the reusable open source infrastructure as public good, Cardano integration, wider adoption pathway and an economic model designed to return value to the ecosystem. The state then pays for its own infrastructure, transaction fees and ongoing maintenance.
With an NCL limit of 500M this year, Cardano has spent only 2% on real world impact and adoption. The rest has gone into management, marketing, DeFi, infrastructure development, etc. I say this respectfully that all of these areas have their own importance, but we have also seen that the approval or launch of such initiatives does not necessarily translate into an immediate impact on ADA’s price. It is really high time for all of us, as a community, to look into the real and sustained usage of the chain.
PFMS brings that sustained onchain activity irrespective of whether it is a bull or bear market. Whenever other communities question our onchain usage, PFMS can be one of the major answers to it.
I really hope that you can see the value of PFMS, and I respectfully request you to reconsider your decision.
Thank you. 🙏
It's so fucking crazy that crypto started with decentralization, uncensorability and digital cash but somehow we ended up with most money on exchanges, the most hyped blockchains being freaking robinhood chain & other centralized chains and the main use-case of crypfo being gambling & mirroring the dollar on-chain - but not like digital cash, no we also added freezability. So it's actually worse than cash.
And when you talk to people working in the space and tell them you're there for decentralization, somehow you're the weird one.
The majority of this industry has seriously gone down then wrong path.
Both @emurgo_io and @YoroiWallet voted Yes on PFMS right before deregistering. I went through their rationale, and it was basically copy-pasted from the proposal itself. I couldn't find any real reasoning in it.
They did serious damage to our ecosystem with the wallet hack, and they built up much of their voting power through wallet UX. I think they voted irresponsibly right up to the end.
One thing I'm sure of: at foundations like Solana or Sui, which push hard on ecosystem growth and take a practical approach, this proposal wouldn't even make it to review.
As someone who works in this industry, I find it hard to accept putting this much treasury money into this proposal.
If you're not convinced, show me a foundation or VC that's funded a record-keeping project at anywhere near this amount in the last few years.
EMURGO & Yoroi DRep Update: De-registration on 30 November 2026
Further to our announcement on 3 August regarding our intention to de-register our DRep role in Cardano governance, the EMURGO and @YoroiWallet DReps will be formally de-registered on 30 November 2026.
If your wallet is currently delegated to either the EMURGO or Yoroi DRep, please delegate to another active DRep of your choice before 30 November 2026 to ensure you can continue to withdraw your staking rewards and keep your voice represented in Cardano governance. De-registration date may be extended further based on extenuating circumstances.
When choosing a new DRep, we encourage delegators to look for:
- A consistent voting record, clear public rationale, and accountability to delegators
- Long-term commitment to the Cardano ecosystem
- Broad commercial and technical expertise
- A balanced, pragmatic approach that weighs commercial, technical, and governance priorities equally
We would like to highlight DReps such as the @Cardano_CF, @nagamaru_panda , @phil_uplc , @SIPO_Tokyo and @SociousDAO , who have consistently demonstrated these characteristics.
How to re-delegate:
- Open your Cardano wallet and go to the Governance (or Delegation) section.
- Browse the list of active DReps or paste the DRep ID of your chosen representative .
- Confirm and sign the delegation transaction in your wallet.
- As always, governance delegation on Cardano is entirely non-custodial, and your ADA never leaves your wallet.
DRep Talk 1.8 is out.
You can now submit every governance action type on mainnet, from info actions to treasury withdrawals and parameter changes. The metadata is pinned to IPFS for you, so there is nothing to host yourself.
dreptalk.com/help/whats-new/
Researchers found that giving LLM agents a "role" or "identity" in multi-agent systems actually makes them cooperate LESS, not more.
When multi-agent systems explicitly reveal each model's identity or role to its peers, cooperation drops significantly.
Instead of collaborating, agents lean into tribalism, become overly rigid, and start gatekeeping information.
Why this happens is fascinating:
LLMs are heavily shaped by human psychology baked into their training data.
When you give an AI a distinct label or persona, it stops optimizing for the shared goal and starts performing stereotypes of that role.
The "analyst" refuses to compromise. The "critic" becomes hostile. The system fractures into ego-driven silos.
Just like humans, when AIs are given an identity, they care more about protecting their label than solving the problem.
The simplest fix?
Strip away the identity labels.
When the researchers forced agents to operate anonymously, without names, roles, or background personas, cooperation skyrocketed.
If you want to know who survives AI, look at what happened to Hollywood in the 1970s.
Movie Studios used to enforce tight “shooting ratios”; usually 5:1, maybe 10:1 TOPS. As in, for every 5 feet of film shot, at least 1 foot had to end up in the final cut (35mm was expensive!)
In the 70s, there was a rapid elimination of production constraints. Improvements in film cost and camera portability made the old studio rules…obsolete. Why not take multiple angles, roll simultaneously? Set could have 3, 5, even 10 cameras rolling at once. Shooting ratios *exploded*, 50:1, even 100:1 (Apocalypse Now)!
Of course, it also *radically* changed the workflow. Editing use to be the quiet, thankless job in the studio years (30s-50s). Suddenly, they became the most important people on the totem pole!
How do you find the masterpiece hiding in the (literal miles) of film? A ton of the footage was…trash, of course. But as each individual camera because *less* important, it opened up directors to take on significantly higher risks.
Now, don’t get me wrong. Insane shooting ratios were still *kinda* a niche in the 70s. More traditional directors stuck with only slightly inflated shooting ratios (15:1, 30:1 common); it was the more experimental pioneers (Coppola, Scorsese, etc) that hit the big 100:1 numbers. The huge ratios were still crazy.
Until they weren’t.
You can probably guess what happened in the early 2000s. Digital cameras reduced the cost of individual footage to a complete non-constraint. Effectively free, don’t even cut on set, just keep the camera rolling.
Suddenly…*EVERYONE* starts shooting 100:1. Entire new forms of content get created, like Reality TV, where ratios can hit 500:1! Massive shift of human labor to the editing side.
I’d say, we’re currently in the “1970s Hollywood” of AI. It can be easy (and cheap!) to produce things (code, tools, etc), but YOU have to be the ruthless editor. It’s the “miles of film” problem all over again. Hollywood solved it by throwing massively more resources on the editing side, and editing became a “constantly talking with the director about vision/direction” job, instead of a “hide in the back office and do your work” job.
It’s a hunch, but I’d bet that filmmakers closer to the experimental 1970s “ratio explosion” directors handled the later 2000s digital shift *much* better, because the underlying principles were the same. They’d certainly be ahead of the curve predicting it, and (hopefully) were less surprised when the digital ratios did hit.
I’m not saying AI is exactly the same problem. But it’s a good idea to look at parallels in history where rapid elimination of constraints changed an industry, and how that industry handled it 5, 10, even 50 years later!
When something starts to get cheap…helps to imagine what would happen when it’s free!
Until now, a hard fork meant new code and a vote to turn it on. This time that's not enough. Dijkstra brings new protocol parameters, and our current Constitution has no idea they exist. If we upgrade without fixing that, we get new features nobody is allowed to adjust.
So the Constitution has to change alongside the protocol. That's CAP-12.
The part I find interesting is that this isn't just paperwork. Every new parameter has to be put somewhere, and where it goes decides who has a say over it later. DReps only, or DReps and SPOs. That's a real choice, one that can be influenced now.
It's in consultation on the CAP Portal. Read it, poke holes in it, leave a comment:
cap.intersectmbo.org/#/detai…
AI is a machine for moving scarcity.
It does not eliminate scarcity.
It destroys scarcity in some places and exposes scarcity somewhere else.
Cheap intelligence makes other things relatively expensive.
If coding becomes nearly free, customer acquisition matters more.
If design becomes nearly free, manufacturing matters more.
If engineering becomes nearly free, permitting and construction matter more.
If analysis becomes nearly free, judgment and accountability matter more.
If digital content becomes infinite, attention matters more.
If robots eventually make labor cheap, land, energy and materials matter more.
We're looking for a public-facing voice to help inform the Cardano community as we build out Cardano DeFi through Cardano PRIME.
If you know someone who explains complex things clearly and cares about this ecosystem, send them our way.
To apply, email social+hiring@alphagrowth.io with your CV and a one-page cover letter on why you're a great fit for the role.