←
Tim Wu77 posts
Tim Wu avatar

Tim Wu

@superwuster

Professor at Columbia Contributing opinion writer at the N.Y. Times Author of THE AGE OF EXTRACTION (2025), the ATTENTION MERCHANTS and other books.

◷ Joined May 2008▧ 5 Photos and videos
Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·4h

US - Europe trade ($1.60 T) is more than 3x US-China trade (about $.496 T). US - Canada trade is also more ($.880 T). Yet Trump admin treats China with reverence while shitting all over the EU and Canada (all 2025 numbers)

Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 16

Here's maybe the most under-the-radar but highly consequential legal issue for the future of AI : the question of agent-user equivalence. Stated otherwise, when is your AI agent "you" for legal purposes; when does it get to do everything you can legally do?

Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 16

The unfortunate truth is that just throwing money around doesn't fix things, actually fixing them does

$9.1 billion remains unspent. New timeline shows the monumental financial resources that Congress has provided to support the FAA over the last two years and contrasts those investments with the questionable, unclear progress Secretary Duffy has made in using those funds⬇️

Post attachment
Aaron Rupar avatar
⟳ Tim Wu retweeted
Aaron Rupar@atrupar·Nov 16

CNBC: When you were a congressman, in 2019 you actually voted against support for the Transportation, Housing, and Urban Development Agencies Appropriation Act, and that would've given more funding to the FAA. Do you regret that vote? DUFFY: The question is, what is this Congress going to do?

0:52
Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 16

Bharat is totally right about this - the Rs in power spend money like drunken sailors, mainly on wars, and then Ds are stuck with cleanup (Bharat says it better)

I’m glad I was able to offer this thoughtful contribution in the austere pages of the WSJ. But it gets at an important dynamic underlying this deficit reduction debate. 1/

Post attachment
Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 16

Considering how disastrous US foreign policy has been of last 2 years by any measure, it is amazing that Rubio, as a Kissinger-style Secretary of State and National Security Advisor retains any standing

Matt Stoller avatar
⟳ Tim Wu retweeted
Matt Stoller@matthewstoller·Nov 13

And now let's go to opposition and support of Chuck Schumer's leadership. Why does he have so much support? Just two years ago, the Dems got absolutely wrecked, but he got reelected as leader unanimously. It's not his charming personality, it's an *institutional* question. Schumer's model of operating the Senate is very specific. He allows Senators a lot of room to legislate on their priorities, and operates as a logistical center to get them what they need to have a comfortable job. Money, staff, parking spots, whatever. But especially money for reelection. He is a very hard worker, perhaps the hardest in the Senate. Where does he get that money? Good question! Ironically, he gets it from those members themselves, indirectly. If they push legislation that challenges powerful interests, he uses that as leverage to get support from those interests, and then redirects that money to get those same people reelected. The legislation tends to die, as that is often the price for the money. Schumer also offers some adjacent useful policy choices that are incrementally useful to Senators on their pet questions. So it's a sort of odd dynamic, where Senators spend their time doing busywork in order for Schumer to generate the funds to get them reelected to keep doing busywork. I'll give you an example, but everyone who has dealt with Schumer has seen something similar. In 2019-2020, the House of Representatives Antitrust Subcommittee actually did its job, a throwback investigation of big tech firms that was exactly how New Deal Democrats of the 1930s operated. They got millions of documents, did hundreds of interviews, had a half dozen hearings, and over 18 months, put together a genuine analysis of four trillion dollar firms and the legal frameworks underpinning them. (It's not a coincidence that a key staffer for that investigation was @linamkhan, but I digress.) In 2021, House and Senate members sought to push legislation that would have addressed some of the market power problems that subcommittee uncovered (and that we're now dealing with in the form of giant AI monsters.) The bills involved things like antitrust as it applies to platforms, interoperability, app stores, advertising technology, basically the underpinnings of the big tech monopoly profits strangling our economy. Some of the legislation was great, some was poorly drafted, but it had genuine political support from 80% of Dems and 20% of Rs. The legislation all passed out of the Judiciary Committee, much of it carried by @amyklobuchar. Schumer leaked to Axios that it would get a vote on the Senate floor in the summer of 2022. A lot of Senators would have supported it if forced to take a vote, but they didn't want to have to do that because they didn't want to anger powerful interests. However, pushing a floor vote is what you do if you are interested in making Congress a functional body to address social problems. What did Schumer do? Well, Schumer told Klobuchar that to get a vote, she needed to get all the Democrats publicly on board. And Klobuchar couldn't, because that was impossible. He knew that would kill the bill. And coincidentally, Schumer then went to Seattle and raised dark money from Microsoft and other tech people for the 2022 election. Klobuchar might have been privately mad, but never voiced anything more than meek frustration. Why? Well she got something out of it too. She bragged about taking on big tech and got lots of attention. In other words, Schumer let Klobuchar do a bunch of work, and then collaborated with Mitch McConnell and Nancy Pelosi to avoid giving this legislation a vote, thus killing it and entrenching big tech's power. Much of the caucus was privately relieved, and Klobuchar got the publicity of being caught trying. That said, Schumer isn't all about blocking action. He helped move key staff to get appointed to the Biden administration, and that did help address some big tech questions. The Antitrust Subcommittee work did turn into major antitrust suits against Google, Amazon, Apple, and Meta, which got hung up in the courts because the Trump administration screwed it up. The FTC under Biden did kick some ass, and that's in part because of Schumer's management of the caucus. That's the play. That's what he's done with a whole host of legislative initiatives, on everything from big tech to the hedge fund carried interest loophole. It's why crypto legislation got strong Democratic support. His goal to get money to help other Democrats with outside spending, and the actual work of overt lawmaking is sacrificed to that goal. There is adjacent corruption, like his children working for Meta, Amazon, and now OpenAI, or his brother being a powerful antitrust defense lawyer who moves mergers. But that's not the driver, Schumer has a specific model of doing politics that is fairly common and had been, until this last election, quite popular. As with Pelosi's choice to double down on Gingrich's model of the House, Schumer actually inherited this model from Mitch McConnell, who organized the Senate around the filibuster blocking legislating. That technique was actually initiated to kill Bill Clinton's health care plan in the early 1990s, McConnell systemized it into the driver of the entire institution. Since the Senate is a bit more personality driven than the House, it is true Harry Reid for a time did things a bit differently. But it's been decades since the Senate actually functioned effectively to legislate. Schumer just did what McConnell taught him to do. It's important to recognize two things about this institutional setup. First, this strategy has a long term cost, which is increasing nihilism and cynicism from voters. They can see clearly that elections don't seem to matter when it comes to their pocketbooks. And second, Schumer isn't doing this alone, he's supported by much of the Democratic caucus and external stakeholders. A lot of the Democratic caucus in the Senate is just not interested in addressing big money interests or governing through public authority. Kirsten Gillibrand comes to mind, but there are many others. They think the system works reasonably well, and like governing by leaning on officials to get them to tweak something here or there. They do not have to marshal the evidence to make some sort of systemic change, because that isn't the job of the Senate anymore. They can just be comfy in a cushy job being modestly famous, and work on questions that don't implicate big money. Those who want actual legislating are characterized as impractical lefties. Blocking the ability to legislate has a number of other consequences. It empowers the courts, which is to say, the fancy corporate liberals who live in the elite world of courts, like Neal Katyal and Merrick Garland. It also empowers the national security world, that loves escaping from scrutiny, and the Federal Reserve, for similar reasons. And of course big business is mostly fine with the arrangement, as are economists who get to mostly dismiss the possibility of democratic action within the economy. And then there are activists, who don't have to pay attention to the actual details of votes. For instance, Jon Ossoff, who has flourished in the do-nothing Schumer world, is quite popular for giving speeches about corruption. But that's in between trips to Silicon Valley to raise money from OpenAI's Chris Lehane, or while voting for crypto interests or to harm college athletes by voting for Ted Cruz's Protect College Sports Act. In a Senate where legislating matters, Ossoff's good looks and camera angles would be less valuable. In other words, people who think Schumer is a bad pick because he seems to subvert the will of voters have it backwards. Schumer is the Senate leader precisely because he does subvert the will of voters on behalf of a whole set of stakeholders that want, for their own reasons, to have Congress dormant when it comes to lawmaking. His would-be successor, Brian Schatz, has the same approach. It's not a conflict just of personalities, but of political philosophies. They think that making real choices, doing the work of politics and governing, means retaining the support of powerful interests, who will then fund the necessary campaigns to keep the Democrats in power. The alternative to Schumer isn't just a different person, it's a different method of organizing power. One has to rebuild the institutions of governance, and then win elections based on governing effectively, not just getting the support of powerful interests. That sounds perhaps romantic, perhaps naive, but it is how the New Dealers did it. And of course there is always some balancing involved. Anyway, just recognize that when someone says 'Schumer delivered 9 Senate seats in 2026, we should keep him as leader,' they are making more than a claim about the midterms, they are endorsing a specific view of how our democratic institutions should operate.

Nate Silver avatar
⟳ Tim Wu retweeted
Nate Silver@NateSilver538·Nov 14

According to polls, approximately 1% of Americans, many of them with severe incapacities, still think Joe Biden is president. It's disturbing to see that Ari Emanuel is among them and I hope everything is well with him.

No one’s hands are clean here. However, Mr. Secretary Buttigieg, you had four years in the job and infrastructure money, yet made zero progress modernizing the FAA. You left a failing system in place. THANKS!

Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 13

While it may disappoint various conspiracy theorists, the headlines are making it clearer that Treasury, State, and/or DoD are the source of the Jensen Huang leaks (maybe with some disaffected Commerce staffers). Which is still a conspiracy in a way but one that is hiding in plain sight. washingtonpost.com/business/…

Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 13

Disadvantage of a centralized economy with heavy bets on one technology: one guy’s actions can do a lot of economic harm. Centralized systems are high performance but fragile and crash harder

Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 12

The New York Times has written a fitting and thoughtful obituary of Richard Posner which makes me happy on what is otherwise a sad day (I was one of his clerks).

Breaking News: Judge Richard A. Posner, the most-cited legal scholar of the latter half of the 20th century, has died. nyti.ms/4Aizsyo

Tim Wu avatar
Tim Wu@superwuster·Nov 11

I was a Posner clerk; he taught me to think without fear. The year I spent with him was a gift for which I will always be grateful

We mourn the loss of Senior Lecturer Richard Allen Posner, a longtime #UChicagoLaw scholar, former federal appellate judge, and pioneer in the field of law and economics, who died on November 10. Read more about his legacy: buff.ly/e3c3WdL

Post attachment
UChicago Law School avatar
⟳ Tim Wu retweeted
UChicago Law School@UChicagoLaw·Nov 11

We mourn the loss of Senior Lecturer Richard Allen Posner, a longtime #UChicagoLaw scholar, former federal appellate judge, and pioneer in the field of law and economics, who died on November 10. Read more about his legacy: buff.ly/e3c3WdL

Post attachment