Why ancient Greece/East Mediterranean? The combination of the early cultural stage (slow info-flow), highly structured environment conductive for semi-isolation, high competition and episodic mixing. It produced many experiments.
Bretskyan is the key here:
doi.org/10.1017/pab.2023.37
Any explanations for the emergence of scientific rationality (whether of a natural-scientific or scientific-theological nature) are flawed because they fail to explain why such rationality did not appear anywhere else but in Greece. Essentially, philosophy-science emerged exactly once in one specific place - all its subsequent forms have merely been new iterations of that same explosion of rationality in the early 6th century. The only explanation that seems relevant to me is that philosophy-science had no cause; it only had conditions. Simply by the law of large numbers, a worldview had to be born somewhere that relied neither on tradition, nor on artistic imagery, nor on everyday experience. Reason is free, and therefore it is sometimes capable of creating something entirely new without an external cause.
Modern geobiomes from the point of view of bees:
"...bioregionalization and species richness are decoupled because they arise from distinct processes: the former reflects historical dispersal and evolutionary history, the latter local diversification..."
pnas.org/doi/epdf/10.1073/pn…
Remarkable finding. Humans were using poison weapons in hunting at least 125,000 years ago. Think about the cultural complexity required to learn to safely extract poison from plants and use it for hunting.
Cyanobacteria with their O2 releasing Photosystem II, existed for a billion years. But only when the tectonic conditions were right, and the massive orogenesis with the release of nutrients ensued, the oxygen started accumulating at scale.
CC: @svalvernature.com/articles/s41467-0…
Information, was it ever the main constraint?
I can have the drawings of the "Ferrari" but would it bring me the automobile?
Is the knowledge of the dopamine molecular structure automatically makes me happier? Or the knowledge of the golds atomic structure, richer?
The evolutionary story is that our biology is central to our survival. bit.ly/4ivYPXE
However, biologist Jonathan Loh proposes the radical new idea that the transmission of cultural characteristics is more important for human survival than biological ones.
There are many systems of knowledge production: metaphysics, religion, traditional knowledge systems and so on. Some even use deductive and inductive inference. But there is only one science. No qualifiers. Just science. And anyone anywhere can use it.
"In Lakota science, there are four parts—matter, energy, relationality, and a unifying life force" That @ScienceMagazine, arguably the world's preeminent science journal, would publish this is mind boggling.
Paper accepted in Philosophical Transactions B!
Co-authored with Shaun Gallagher
We argue that interactions with artificial agents are always bidirectional and as such they deeply transform who we are as humans
Hence we need to carefully assess WHO is behind AI and their effect on human minds and bodies especially from a developmental perspective 😎👇🏼
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/te…
Why is there so much obsession with the few hundred cutting-edge math problems solved by AI but so little clamor over the thousands attempted but not solved? The profundity of the lessons about AI and human intelligence buried in that failed set is incredibly underrated.
A rational scientific response would be to meticulously survey the failed problems and the nature of each failure, and get a completely novel map of the intellectual landscape. If there are unifying properties among subclasses of currently prohibitive problems, identifying those properties would be impactful in at least two powerful ways.
First, they would point AI research in new directions as we gain a novel understanding of what is actually hard for AI and why it fails even when it has seemingly piercing superintelligence on other classes of problems.
And second, for the meantime (which could be years or even decades), it would illuminate for the human mathematicians (and ultimately all scientists) where their minds are still valuable and illustrate why it is not yet time to declare all human intellectual work as merely “astronomers pointing telescopes.”
Of course, these two implications seem eventually to come to a head with each other, but they also complement each other and feed into progress and new kinds of human-machine collaboration. Either way, we need to know what remains out of reach and why, and the possession of such knowledge is a highly underrated scientific goldmine.
Catalonia was thought to be almost devoid of palaeolithic art, but these engravings dating back 26,000 years have been found in a tourist hotspot
go.nature.com/4zFxwAf
When did cumulative cultural evolution begin? This extensive analysis of 3.3 million years of stone tools suggests a rapid increase in complexity around 600,000 years ago. The birth of cumulative culture. pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pna…
My conjecture (based on the paper by @svalver and co) is that AI is the ultimate engine for the innovation busting. It enables talentless imitators to copy the 'know-hows' of the experts, thus bankrupting them and forcing them out of their fields.
nature.com/articles/s41599-0…
We, as a species didn't changed much in 300 Ka. So, why should we think that not-so-distant ancestors of ours were indifferent to their children? They loved their offspring, they suffered for them, they enjoyed their company.
Pervasive patterns in bird songs resemble those in human speech and song. Foundational work in evolutionary cognitive science science.org/doi/10.1126/scie…