I'm starting my D.Min. at @grimkeseminary. My plan is to write a dissertation challenging the lie that “you'll own nothing and be happy,” exploring the tension between analog & digital life, the growing degradation of products & services (“enshittification” we really need a better word for this) & the importance of place, rootedness & ownership.
I’ve been talking about the dearth of fathers for a long, long time. I think it’s a huge problem, particularly in the church. I also agree that the church has become effeminate. Again, I’ve been writing and talking about that for years.
Keeping all that in mind, I’ve noticed a strange tendency lately to assume that if young men could just find strong, masculine fathers in the church, they would happily submit to them and follow their lead.
One of the difficulties of youth is prideful insubordination. This is a constant theme hammered home in wisdom literature, particularly Proverbs. Even with decent fathers, some sons remain unruly and continue making excuses. They’ll complain that the men aren’t sufficiently masculine, don’t give them enough time, or whatever else they can come up with to justify their unwillingness to follow.
If you’re not careful, you’ll fall into the same error as those who claim that the reason women become brassy feminists is simply that there aren’t enough masculine men around to lead them.
It is difficult to lead people who refuse to follow. And it is also difficult to follow people who lead poorly. This is true in the home, in the church, and really in every institution.
Still, those who have been commanded to lead must lead as well as they can, even when they have bad followers. And those commanded to follow must follow as faithfully as they can, even when they have bad leaders.
Other people’s disobedience and failures do not justify your own disobedience and failures. However, they can help explain why doing what God has commanded you to do is especially difficult.
For most people, it's a while before they begin to question how they were raised. They just assume it was normal because it was normal for them. And they assume that other people had a similar upbringing.
This has been true for my wife and me when it comes to our spiritual upbringing. After our conversions, we were in churches that taught us inductive Bible study and hermeneutics, and we went through large sections of Scripture in Bible studies and Sunday schools. We were taught the basics of logic, philosophy, and theology. All of this was so basic to us that we just assumed these were fundamentals everyone was taught, almost like the ABCs.
I went through books with my various pastors by Chesterton, C.S. Lewis, Ian Murray, and others. By the time I was 21, I had read a couple dozen Puritan paperbacks simply because they were given to me, so I read them.
Again, we thought there were lots of churches like this. A minority, no doubt, but not nearly the minority they actually seem to be. Over the last seven or eight years, we've moved outside those circles and discovered just how exceptional our spiritual upbringing was.
Now, for all that foundational teaching, there were a lot of things ignored in my discipleship, particularly teaching on biblical sexuality, church government, and a Christian view of civil government. More generally, there was a dearth of practical theology.
So a lot of what I write and teach on has been my attempt to address the areas I saw overlooked. But most of what I teach rests on all those other foundational things I was taught.
What's been interesting over the last couple of years is that now there are all sorts of podcasts, books, and reels addressing these topics. But it has been my observation that many of the people doing the teaching lack the foundations themselves.
You'll have people with very strong views on biblical sexuality who are shockingly ignorant when it comes to the basics of biblical interpretation and doctrines as fundamental as justification and sanctification.
The consequence is that we now have these trees with tall trunks and wide branches, but very little in the way of deep roots. This is why you see so many of these people quickly shifting their views after arrogantly asserting themselves as experts in the very positions they held just a short time before. It's a treacherous situation we're in.
Obviously, we have to keep teaching on biblical sexuality and civil engagement. Those are pressing needs of the day. But because the sort of discipleship I've been taking for granted is so rare, we also have to be laying down the fundamentals.
We want tall trees with wide branches, but we also want them to be standing after the storms.
As we plot out the future of East River Church, now coming up on our sixth anniversary, a lot of this is figuring into where we're directing our resources. We recently started midweek gatherings where we have more time for adult Bible study, and we're going to be working through things like the ordo salutis, biblical church government, hermeneutics, and so forth.
But I want to say something to anyone in my age bracket who was blessed to be discipled the way my wife and I were: You need to understand that, sadly, that world is largely gone. You're a bit of a unicorn, and these younger people simply don't know what they don't know. Just as your world is foreign to them, their world is foreign to you.
We need a revival of careful biblical teaching on all the fundamental topics, with an eye toward showing how they connect to practical applications.
If you do that, you'll help keep your people from being tossed about by every wind of doctrine and every hot topic promoted by unqualified teachers. You'll rescue them from the obsession with celebrity and personality-based discipleship.
Many of these people simply don't know what it's like to be discipled by a real human being who knows them and cares about them, rather than someone paraphrasing into a microphone something they ripped off Wikipedia or got from ChatGPT.
You may not know much, but give them what you do know.
Painting: Horace Verne
Analog is the future.
This isn’t meant as some hipster or nostalgic slogan.
We are embodied spirits and our desire for tactile things will never go away.
Also, you can’t delete analog things with the push of a button...
...which is advantageous in a day like ours.
Men, young and old alike, are undoubtedly leaving the church because, for whatever reason, they believe they haven’t found fathers there. In some cases, it’s true. In others, it’s not.
Some retreat into a lonely, sad existence. Others continue searching for fathers and brothers. Many instead find influencers who pose as fathers and brothers, offering friendship for a fee.
A few find healthy, godly churches where men, according to their abilities, provide godly, masculine counsel.
Such is our dilemma. Money-loving celebrity wannabes on both sides, and chaos through the middle.
This is life in the middle of a spiritual and social war zone.
We are war-torn.
Don’t forget to like and subscribe.
Young men are not leaving the church because it isn't manly enough.
They leave the church because "having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions, and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths" (2 Timothy 4:3-4).
Under the right circumstances, father hunger can mutate into father hatred.
Think of a single woman who desires nothing more than to be married and have children. But for whatever reason, that desire has gone unfulfilled. Given the right circumstances, her longing for marriage and motherhood can mutate into resentment, even contempt, for the very things she once desired.
The same thing can happen with father hunger. A deep longing for something good, when frustrated long enough, can curdle into hatred for that very thing.
I think we’re seeing quite a bit of this right now.
“I want you to know,” I told the teary-eyed man sitting across from me, “it is my practice to call the pastor of a church when someone starts attending my church, especially when they tell me things like you’ve told me. So I don’t want you to be surprised by that.”
He looked like he swallowed hard and said, “Oh, okay.”
I was a 25-year-old church planter, just several months into my first church plant. And I was quickly learning that new churches attract what you might rightly call malcontents. These are people who are upset with their last church, sometimes for legitimate reasons, but a lot of times it’s just nonsense.
This young college graduate, only two or three years younger than me, had just told me about how no one loved him, got him, understood him, or cared about him at his last church. He gave me a long story that came off as something of a sob story.
An older pastor had once told me, “The way people come to your church is the way they’ll go to the next church when they leave yours.”
That really stuck with me.
And I said, “You know, Joe, my concern is that we’re not going to live up to your expectations either, and six months to a year from now, you’ll be telling this same story to the next church.”
He assured me that wouldn’t be the case.
I called up his former pastor and got ahold of him.
“Hey, I want to talk to you about a former member of yours who started attending my church.”
I mentioned the name, and he said, “Oh man, good luck.”
“Yeah, I thought you might say that.”
I relayed the story, and the pastor told me their side of it, which definitely correlated with reality much better.
Essentially, they had challenged him repeatedly about his laziness, his failure to keep commitments, and his lack of motivation to get more than a part-time job. Eventually, he left because they weren’t loving enough.
It was only about two months later that he started posting on our church forum, repeatedly asking for prayer to help him pay basic bills like car insurance. People started asking him questions about budgeting, where he was working, and all that. And again, he had all these excuses.
It was becoming evident to everybody that he was fishing for pity, hoping someone would just give him the money.
But at the time, our church plant was mostly made up of young newlyweds who didn’t have much money themselves, while this guy was a single college graduate with a roommate.
In time, this led to a confrontation, and he too left our church because we also weren’t loving enough.
It’s the circle of church life.
I do think this is a good practice for all pastors to build into their ministry. It serves as a protection for your church, and it also strengthens relationships with other local churches.
Paintings: F. Moormans
Your capacity has limits, but those limits aren’t necessarily fixed. They’re something you discover. And often, by pushing against them, you find that you’re capable of far more than you ever imagined.
Take children, for example.
Never in a million years did I imagine my wife and I would have eleven kids. That wasn’t the plan. When we talked about having a big family, we were thinking four or five. Not a busload. But here we are.
I remember when we had six kids, someone asked me, “Where do you find the love for six children?”
I told him, “I don’t know that I had the love for even one.”
But when God gave me my first son, I learned to put someone else’s needs ahead of my own in a way I never had before. Through that little boy, God expanded my capacity to love.
And so it has been with every child God has added to our family.
My capacity to handle the chaos, endure the stress, make sacrifices, and love these children has grown far beyond anything I could have imagined twenty years ago.
A lot of what we call our limitations are really just assumptions we’ve made about ourselves. We mistake the limits of our present capacity for the limits of our potential.
It’s remarkable how God can change a man over the years.
I used to love being alone. And don’t get me wrong, I still enjoy having a few hours to myself whenever I can get them. But somewhere along the way, something changed.
Now I hate an empty house. I love the noise, the commotion, the constant interruptions. I love being surrounded by my children.
The life that would have overwhelmed the younger me has become one of my greatest joys.
I’m launching a lead pastor/church planter residency to train and equip men to lead churches in Eastern Iowa/Western Illinois. If you’re interested here’s a video with more information.
youtu.be/YRC_OG5w3Ug?is=Js07…
New episode of It's Good to Be a Man, "How to Be a Serious Man, Part Two."
"Flattery feels good, but it's often a trap. From false prophets to online influencers, manipulators exploit our pride and grievances to gain our loyalty. In this episode, Michael Foster exposes the flatterer's playbook and explains why serious men must learn to reject the kisses of enemies and cherish the wounds of faithful friends."
Listen on Spotify, iTunes, etc.
"A flatterer is mutable, inconstant, not his own man but ever-changing to be the man he thinks will appeal to his victim."
"I don't need a friend who changes when I change and who nods when I nod; my shadow does that much better.”
Plutarch on Flatterers