←
Torstein Bae15,239 posts
Torstein Bae avatar

Torstein Bae

@torbae

Sjakkekspert & forfatter | SJAKKLUBBEN podkast | Foredrag om verdien av engasjement!

◷ Joined November 2013▧ 1,896 Photos and videos
chess24 avatar
⟳ Torstein Bae retweeted
chess24@chess24com·3h

Magnus Carlsen, Richard Rapport, and Abhimanyu Mishra do not show up to the fast classical game. The result of the games would not have altered the final match result. #TotalChess

Post attachment
Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·10h

motstanderen slapp å vente ved brettet. Men Magnus er åpenbart mindre å klandre når han har fått beskjed som mellom linjene sier "du kan droppe partiet dersom du ønsker det".

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·10h

Slik jeg nå forstår dette: Arrangøren/dommeren sier at de informerte Magnus om at eneste konsekvens ved ikke å komme til partiet var at det ble tap. Det er ganske oppsiktsvekkende, for det pleier alltid å være ytterligere konsekvens. Så burde arrangør bedt om avklaring slik at

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·10h

Veldig merkelig at de lot Assubajeva vente ved brettet. Antar det ikke kan ha kommet tydelig beskjed fra Magnus om hvor vidt han ville spille. Hvis dette var avklart, er det en gigantisk dommertabbe.

Chief Arbiter of Total Chess Pilot, IA Anastasia Sorokina on Magnus Carlsen forfeiting his game against Bibisara Assaubayeva: "Magnus came before the game, since he already won his match... he asked what happens in such a case. From our perspective, there is no extra penalty - except the game is -+ of course."

1:53
Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·13h

Fortsetter i samme stil, nå med utspill om at det må bli strengere straff for ikke å møte til et parti

I really think it's time to consider forfeits as losses, with ratings deducted accordingly. For a last couple of years I was raising this idea internally - as we see an avalanche of walkovers in open events - most of them due to poor performances in earlier rounds, some of them due to all sort of boycotts, almost never due to force majeure. In top events it impacts the public perception of the event, it damages viewership, and also can be used to manipulate the rating system. But not less important and far more often we see it in Opens - not only it is disrespectful, and ruins the chances for norms - but just imagine someone who traveled from far away to compete. They spend time and money to actually play chess. And they can't, while the violator simply goes away smiling. Forfeiting the game became too common - it is just too simple and comfortable, but it should not be like that. It contradicts the sportive spirit and principles. Once the pairing is known, the forfeit must be punished. The founding father of rating system, Dr. Elo could have never imagined it will become a stick for so many players, and the assumption was - if you are sick, or if one has a sort of emergency, they don't lose rating. That's not the common case anymore, and the situation must be treated differently. Of course, FIDE QC shall review it carefully, and we will also need to to see what sort of exceptions may be allowed, if the concept is approved. Additionally I will also suggest FIDE Athletes commission, of which several top players are members, to analyze the situation and have their opinion on it. Kindly share your thoughts on the matter!

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Norway Chess, som er arrangør i Budapest, har nå fått et skikkelig problem i fanget. Mange har ment at opplegget var skreddersydd for Magnus. Hvis de nå lar Magnus slippe billig unna, vil enda flere mene at det nye Total-VM mangler den nødvendige nøytralitet mht spillerne.

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Om de har rett eller ikke, dette er en stor dag for alle som misliker Magnus

Whether games could count even after the match was over was discussed and agreed upon in the technical meeting. If Carlsen was playing someone with a higher rating, he might have been more inclined to play. Nevertheless, if any other player forfeited a game, disrespecting the organiser and his opponent, they would have lost the match by forfeit. It’s incredibly dissapointing to see continued favouritism towards one player. Let’s not forget the jeans, and “Co World Champion” saga. All rules must be applied equally, regardless of the player. End of story.

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Ja, VM i romjula nå enda viktigere for Magnus. Kanskje er det derfor Sutovskij prøver å sabotere for at Magnus deltar. Men det skal han ikke lykkes med.

With freestyle folding and a catastrophic total chess pilot for him, for the first time in a long long time, Magnus needs World Rapid and Blitz as much as World R&B needs him! Emil Sutovsky must be licking his lips with the newfound negotiating power!

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Tragikomisk at Sutovskij akkurat har fått ansvaret for å bygge gode partnerskap

Post attachment
Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Merkelig utsagn. At man ikke stiller til et obligatorisk parti kan åpenbart ha flere konsekvenser. For eksempel at man blir kastet ut av turneringen og blir bøtelagt. For ikke å snakke om skade på renommé.

Carlsen to TV 2: "As far as I understand, the match is over and the only consequence of not showing up is that you lose what is a totally meaningless game. If the match is over, it's over. Then if you play games, it's not rated. This is how it's always been."

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Mange som får vann på mølla nå

That is why there is an issue with modern chess, it has a clear name, INPUNITY Some are allowed doing whatever they want, knowing there will be no punishment ever. Dirty insults towards different players and profanities in public live streams like some, saying "FU" to FIDE, not appear for an official game as a caprise like others, nothing will ever happen to them. Media will treat this behaviour as normal or, more often, just wouldn't notice somehow. FIDE would follow that attitude. But if you dare telling unpleasant truth, will be punished severely, for "damaging for the image of the game" behaviour. #growingchess has clear rules that should be strictly obeyed, and honesty and truth is not part of the package. Sorry for calling the king naked, but will continue, when true ✊️

Torstein Bae avatar
Torstein Bae@torbae·Nov 17

Mange sjakkspillere i verden vil dele synspunktet til stormester Neiksans.

Meaningless to Magnus himself maybe, but not so much to Bibisara and to the entire chess world. It's just poor sportsmanship - I'm very disappointed.