
Is Midnight being built on Cardano? Charles says he's moving from building Cardano to building on Cardano, with Midnight as a major example. Some argue this isn't technically accurate because Midnight is an independent Layer 1 blockchain. There are very contentious arguments around this, with people calling each other stupid or ignorant. The issue I see here is that both groups use different definitions of "building on." The technical perspective From a strict blockchain architecture perspective, the criticism is valid. Midnight has its own consensus, ledger, block production and transaction settlement. Midnight transactions don't settle on Cardano L1. It is a Cardano Partner Chain, not a DApp, rollup or conventional L2. Building on the Cardano ecosystem "Building on Cardano" also means building on its ecosystem, infrastructure and architectural foundations. NIGHT is a Cardano native asset, and NIGHT holders can generate DUST for transaction execution on Midnight through a registration mechanism involving Cardano. This creates an ongoing relationship between assets held on Cardano and activity on Midnight, beyond simply transferring tokens between chains. The NIGHT distribution The Glacier Drop brought participants from eight crypto ecosystems to Cardano: Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, XRP, BNB, Avalanche, BAT and Cardano itself. Regardless of their original ecosystem, participants needed a Cardano destination address to receive NIGHT. Redeeming NIGHT also required an ADA transaction fee, unless a third party sponsored the transaction. The distribution also leveraged Cardano's Hydra scaling technology. That's actual Cardano infrastructure being used, not just an ecosystem affiliation. Cardano SPOs and Midnight validation Midnight also builds on Cardano's existing stake pool operator ecosystem. Cardano SPOs are planned to participate in Midnight validation as the network decentralizes in 2027. Combined with the Partner Chain framework and Cardano integration, this creates meaningful technical and operational relationships between the networks. ADA delegation and NIGHT rewards Even more relevant is the planned relationship between ADA delegation and NIGHT staking rewards. Once decentralized block production and rewards are enabled, Cardano delegators are expected to earn both ADA and NIGHT by delegating their ADA to participating Cardano SPOs, such as my STR8 stake pool. Their ADA remains staked on Cardano, while their delegated stake contributes to the selection of Midnight block producers, supporting the security and decentralization of both networks. This creates a direct, ongoing economic relationship between the two networks. Native NIGHT staking on Midnight is also being developed according to the roadmap, but exactly how both mechanisms will coexist remains to be seen. Personally, I expect both mechanisms to complement each other. I can imagine additional incentives for delegating ADA to a Cardano SPO that also operates a Midnight validator, while delegating NIGHT to that same validator on Midnight. Cardano's original architectural vision Cardano's early Settlement Layer (CSL) and Computation Layer (CCL) concept separated value accounting from complex computation, allowing specialized computational environments with different requirements. Cardano's architecture has evolved considerably since then. But building specialized, interoperable chains is consistent with that broader vision. So, is Midnight built on Cardano? We need to distinguish between two interpretations: "Built on Cardano L1": Technically inaccurate when referring to Midnight's execution and settlement. "Built on Cardano's infrastructure, ecosystem and architectural foundations": Undeniably. Midnight's integration with Cardano is not merely a matter of interpretation. It is demonstrated by concrete technical and economic relationships between the two networks. Why Charles's statement makes sense Charles's original statement is also about Input Output's changing role: moving from building the underlying Cardano protocol toward building products and applications within its wider ecosystem. Seen in that context, saying he's moving from "building Cardano" to "building on Cardano" makes sense. Midnight is an independent blockchain, but it is also being built on Cardano's existing infrastructure, community, staking ecosystem and broader architectural vision. We can acknowledge Midnight's independent architecture without denying its Cardano foundations. Both things can be true. Given Midnight's tight integration with the Cardano ecosystem, I believe its growth is also likely to benefit Cardano over the long term, through shared infrastructure, staking incentives, ecosystem adoption and additional economic activity. Which is why I welcome Midnight as a Cardano ecosystem project and see its success as a clear win for our ecosystem.















