←
Uta Frith9,952 posts
Uta Frith avatar

Uta Frith

@utafrith

Golden oldie who likes Cognitive. Social. Neuroscience. But not only.

◷ Joined August 2010▧ 472 Photos and videos
Uta Frith avatar
Uta Frith@utafrith·Nov 6

A very good analysis of the implications of the findings of this carefully conducted population study.

The people who are being given an autism diagnosis have changed. This is a massive study, looking at people in Sweden and the UK diagnosed with autism in adulthood. What they find, apart from a huge increase in the number of people being diagnosed (and many more women being diagnosed), is that the people themselves are different. Previously, adults who received an autism diagnosis were more likely to have a prior history of epilepsy, intellectual disability or psychotic disorders. Now, they are more likely to have a history of anxiety, depression, ADHD or other symptoms of emotional distress. This is in line with what clinicians have been saying for a while. Mental health problems, which were previously seen as psychological or emotional in origin, are increasingly being seen as neurodevelopmental, and therefore due to brain differences. Autism is the lens through which our culture is seeing distress. This has serious implications, because autism is seen as untreatable and lifelong. Mental health problems such as anxiety or depression are seen as treatable. Recovery is possible. By bringing so many more people under the autistic umbrella, we tell them thatthey are wired this way. That’s a powerful explanation because it can bring relief and self-acceptance - but it can also bring hopelessness about change. We aren’t discovering more of the original type of autism which was there all along, we have changed what autism means. The important question is, what is the impact of diagnosing so many more people, and it is helping them to better live the lives they want? mentalhealth.bmj.com/co…

Uta Frith avatar
Uta Frith@utafrith·Oct 30

Autism then and now. How different!

There is a (usually) unstated problem in interpreting research about autism over time. The way that autism is diagnosed changed. Not just a few tweaks, but dramatically and emphatically. It has changed so much that people from the 1980s and 1990s would not recognise most of the people diagnosed today as autistic. Not because we got better at detecting autism (because autism is just a descriptive category, there is nothing underlying to detect), but because the criteria changed and expanded to include more people. This means that a study of autistic people from 2010 will be using a different definition of autism to the one we use today. It means that seminal studies from the 80s and 90s do not apply to the majority of people diagnosed with autism after 2013. This isn’t a flaw in the earlier research. It doesn’t mean that their findings have been debunked. It doesn’t mean that the earlier definitions of autism were right and the more recent are wrong. It just means, autism meant something different in the past than it does now. Without acknowledging that, I don’t see how we can start to make sense of what’s happening.

Uta Frith avatar
Uta Frith@utafrith·Oct 30

So that’s what they mean by “inclusive”!?

I read a book about neurodiversity recently which claimed to be inclusive. It was inclusive in many ways. The people whose stories were in those pages were racially and ethnically diverse. They had different sexualities and gender identities. They had a range of different backgrounds and careers. What was missing was anyone with intellectual disabilities. Anyone who lived in a residential setting. Anyone who had attended a special school as a child and had never learnt to read or write. Anyone who lived in a non-western country. They weren’t just missing, there was no reference to them at all. And, crucially, it was not inclusive of anyone who disagreed with certain ideological premises. No one who thought that we need subgroups in the autism spectrum, for example. No one who thought that perhaps overdiagnosis might be a problem. No one who questioned what neurodivergence actually meant. No one who argued for functioning labels. Despite the claims of inclusivity, it was a strangely homogenous group. And here is one of the paradoxes of neurodiversity. There’s the appearance of diversity and inclusivity, but there’s a conformity of opinion. Everyone is singing from the same hymn sheet. Book after book is published with exactly the same assumptions. Humans are social beings and we want to fit in. We learn to do this by watching what happens to those who don’t. It’s just too risky to do anything else. Don’t mistake this conformity for an objective truth. It’s a bit more complicated than that.

Paul Whiteley avatar
⟳ Uta Frith retweeted
Paul Whiteley@PaulWhiteleyPhD·Oct 20

Private providers are profiting from the expansion of ADHD and autism diagnosis bmj.com/content/395/bmj-2026… "Overmedicalisation is the inevitable side effect when there is profit to be made from convincing people that a diagnosis is the answer they’ve been looking for..."

Naomi Fisher avatar
⟳ Uta Frith retweeted
Naomi Fisher@naomicfisher·Oct 21

When we introduced the marketplace into neurodevelopmental assessments, something fundamental shifted. When there is a profit to be made from convincing people they might be autistic or have ADHD, then we are all at risk of overmedicalisation. It is in the interest of private providers to expand their audience. Once the demand is there, the incentives are to carry out assessments as cheaply as possible. And that can mean poor quality assessments leading to life long diagnoses. bmj.com/content/395/bmj-2026…

Dr Joanna Moncrieff avatar
⟳ Uta Frith retweeted
Dr Joanna Moncrieff@joannamoncrieff·Sep 30

This will be an important contribution to a long overdue debate

I’ve had misgivings about what is going on in the autism world for a while. Misgivings about the way that many clinicians are going along with narratives which are not based in science, and which seem to be largely based on the say-so of a few, very influential, activists. I’m concerned about the way that we have accepted that expanding autism to include more people is the right thing to do, and how little time we have given to asking what ‘neurodivergence’ really is - and whether it might not be such a good idea to refer to ‘neuro’ all the time when we know that people tend to understanding neurological explanations as ‘set in stone’. But the thing which makes me most concerned was how hard it is to talk about it. When pioneering researchers like @utafrith say that they think we need to rethink the autism spectrum, they are treated as if they are in the stocks. Rotten tomatoes, in the shape of internet insults, are hurled. It’s as if the crowd is shouting ‘shut up shut up shut up’. Except not as politely as that. Whenever I see something like that happening, it makes me more, rather than less, interested. I wonder what they are trying to hide. What is being covered up here? Why is it so important to stop some questions from being asked? For if we can’t disagree, then we can’t conduct science. There is no way to improve our knowledge if we can’t have balanced discussions about why something is happening. That’s why I wrote my latest book, which will be coming out in Feb 2027. It’s the inside story of how autism has expanded, and why that matters to us all. It's just too important to keep quiet about, even while the rotten tomatoes are hurled.

Post attachment
Uta Frith avatar
Uta Frith@utafrith·Sep 29

Can’t wait for this book to come out.

I’ve had misgivings about what is going on in the autism world for a while. Misgivings about the way that many clinicians are going along with narratives which are not based in science, and which seem to be largely based on the say-so of a few, very influential, activists. I’m concerned about the way that we have accepted that expanding autism to include more people is the right thing to do, and how little time we have given to asking what ‘neurodivergence’ really is - and whether it might not be such a good idea to refer to ‘neuro’ all the time when we know that people tend to understanding neurological explanations as ‘set in stone’. But the thing which makes me most concerned was how hard it is to talk about it. When pioneering researchers like @utafrith say that they think we need to rethink the autism spectrum, they are treated as if they are in the stocks. Rotten tomatoes, in the shape of internet insults, are hurled. It’s as if the crowd is shouting ‘shut up shut up shut up’. Except not as politely as that. Whenever I see something like that happening, it makes me more, rather than less, interested. I wonder what they are trying to hide. What is being covered up here? Why is it so important to stop some questions from being asked? For if we can’t disagree, then we can’t conduct science. There is no way to improve our knowledge if we can’t have balanced discussions about why something is happening. That’s why I wrote my latest book, which will be coming out in Feb 2027. It’s the inside story of how autism has expanded, and why that matters to us all. It's just too important to keep quiet about, even while the rotten tomatoes are hurled.

Post attachment
Naomi Fisher avatar
⟳ Uta Frith retweeted
Naomi Fisher@naomicfisher·Sep 27

There’s something wrong with inclusivity if, by including more people, we lose sight of the needs of the most vulnerable. I’ve recently read books called things like the ‘ultimate handbook’ or ‘everything a parent needs to know’ about neurodivergence and autism which make no mention at all of those who are severely autistic. They are simply not included. Nothing about self-injurious behaviour, or eloping, or minimal speech. Nothing about how to reach a child who seems uninterested in you or other people. Nothing about extreme repetitive behaviour or pica. Nothing about cognitive delay or aggression. Instead they write about anxiety, and school distress, and trauma. I’m not saying that these things aren’t important. Of course they are (and I often write about them myself) but it should not be possible to publish a book which claims to cover everything, while leaving out the very people who cannot speak up to say ‘we are missing’. This is not inclusivity.

Uta Frith avatar
Uta Frith@utafrith·Sep 17

Very concerning

Last week I saw a post by someone who identified as AuDHD. It told of their terrible year, punctuated by serious mental health problems. Admissions to hospital, life-threatening symptoms - they had had to quit their job and move back in with their parents as a result. The next post was their announcement that they were now a certified ND coach, and an appeal for people to get in touch to book a consultation. I’m not sure who I am most concerned for here. The coach, who is going to be dealing with potentially vulnerable people while in a state of high vulnerability themselves, or their clients, who may not find the containing presence they were hoping for. For both of them, this is high risk. Things could go really wrong. My online experience is full of adverts telling me it’s so easy to become a coach. I’m told I could be an ADHD coach with just a few hours of online study, a ND coach by this time next week and (the newest one) an AuDHD coach with a exciting and well-paid career in front of me.  All I need to do is pay my money and they’ll tell me how to ‘kick start my business’. These courses have proliferated in the last few years. They sell a dream - be self-employed! Run your own business! Make money doing something you love! There are typically no barriers to entry except cost. No assessment of whether someone is suited to this work. No regulation or professional body to uphold ethical standards. No one to complain to when things go wrong. Even the cost can be low if the whole thing is online and recorded. I’ve just seen one which charges £77 and promises me that in 40-60 online hours I’ll be a certified neurodiversity coach. They will attract vulnerable people, these courses. Many people decide to go into coaching because of their own life experiences. They want to help other people. Then when they get their certificate, they use their lived experience to promote their services, because there is a widely held belief that a person with a given diagnosis is best placed to help others with that diagnosis. ‘I’ll understand you like no one else can’ they promise. They may really believe it. Because they are not regulated, they can make extravagant claims which a qualified professional would not make. The general public may not know the difference between a coach who has done 40 hours online, and a psychotherapist who has studied for four years. They often charge similar prices. I know there are many really excellent coaches, but it also seems to be a Wild West out there. Working with distressed people is hard, and it’s an illusion if we think that coaching is straightforward. People don’t leave their complexity at the door. When vulnerable people work with vulnerable people without checks and balances, boundaries can go missing and real harm can be done.  We really need to talk about neurodiversity coaching.

Paul Whiteley avatar
⟳ Uta Frith retweeted
Paul Whiteley@PaulWhiteleyPhD·Sep 4

Camouflaging in autism as a dual-normative construct: a philosophical critique pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4233… It doesn't mean that 'some' impression management isn't utilised by some. Merely that 'autistic masking' is contrary to fundamentals about autism (and social communication)