←
Whig46,461 posts
Whig avatar

Whig

@vulpine2020

Whig; limited government; freedom of exchange, expression; personal liberty. Apologist for wheat. Pronouns: ‘Your Eminence’

◷ Joined September 2020▧ 1,573 Photos and videos
Whig avatar
Whig@vulpine2020·Sep 30

Here’s a vision of the world under your rule, drawn from your posts: limited government, personal liberty, free exchange, simplified taxes, social-insurance healthcare instead of a command-and-control NHS, pro-housing development over NIMBYism, defence of private enterprise

Post attachment

"Generate an image of what the world would look like if I were in charge, based on my tweets." Tell me you wouldn't live here

Post attachment
Kristian Niemietz avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Kristian Niemietz@K_Niemietz·Nov 16

"In Starmer’s bizarre version of events, national security was just an added bonus: the real prize was the spending itself, which would make us richer. If that were so, we would actually have to thank Vladimir Putin and other warmongers, because without them, we would not have discovered that we have this amazing wealth-creation machine at our doorstep." thecritic.co.uk/net-zero-wil…

Whig avatar
Whig@vulpine2020·4h

Daft. Either it’s 16 (as it has been for 150 years) or 18. But adding complexity will not help. Rules should be clear and simple. We can’t micromanage people’s sexual behaviour though it’s typical of modern government and the left to try

We should make it illegal for anyone aged 18 or above to have sex with anyone below the age of 18. 🔹 From a cultural and neurodevelopmental perspective, there is a consensus that childhood is longer than in the past. Childhood is special and should be protected. I don’t think adults should be in sexual relations with school-aged children; there is already a cultural consensus against this. 🔹 I’m sympathetic to harmonising the minimum age for all adult activity - voting, alcohol, sex - to 18, as suggested by @KemiBadenoch, but worry this will be difficult to implement. 🔹 I therefore think that instead we should extend the current ban on those aged 18 and above who are in a Position of Trust over under 18s in their care to all adults and in regards to all children. This would create a staggered age of consent, allowing 16 and 17 year olds to have sex with one another. 🔹 As with the exemption for some of those in a Position of Trust over a 16-17 year old written into the Sexual Offences Act 2003, those 18 year olds in a pre-existing relationship with a 16-17 year old would not be banned from ongoing sexual relations. Me for @TalkTV: youtu.be/ch_HJSul5pY?si=aYt2…

1:18
Matthew Lynn avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Matthew Lynn@mattlynnwriter·16h

Inflation is 3.6%. Public sector wages are growing at 5.4%, and in the private sector at 3.1%. So in real terms, the public sector is getting richer and the private sector poorer. I am not sure that is sustainable.

Bear avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Bear@BearJFK·12h

The spend on Disability Benefit alone is about 70% of the defence budget. We must be mad. Totally mad.

Post attachment
Bjorn Lomborg avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Bjorn Lomborg@BjornLomborg·Nov 17

Net zero will cost the UK the equivalent of £40,000 ($54,000) for every person living there today That's the undiscounted cost over this century For that, the world gets 0.00376°C less warming in 2100 NetZeroCostBenefit.com/UK?s=…

Post attachment
Robert Colvile avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Robert Colvile@rcolvile·16h

'The more secure you make employment, the more likely it is that someone will stay in employment.' No, Andy. The more secure you make employment, the less likely is that employers will take a chance on hiring someone they can't get rid of.

Simon French avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Simon French@Frencheconomics·17h

The UK's fresh productivity data (released yesterday by the ONS) does present a rather awkward data backdrop to the UK-EU summit. It now reveals that since the Brexit vote in 2016 the UK's productivity performance has accelerated away from comparable EU economies - having largely tracked them (2016-2025) in the previous iteration of this data. It must call into question the validity of the (widely cited) NBER estimate that Brexit triggered a 3%-4% reduction in UK productivity. We have consistently believed the -ve Brexit impact to be closer to half this level.

Post attachment
Matthew Lynn avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Matthew Lynn@mattlynnwriter·16h

With today's rise, inflation is now rising faster than earnings. We are getting poorer.

Maurice Cousins avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Maurice Cousins@MDC12345678·23h

I think we all need to get used to this, given how AI will become an extension of our own intellectual capabilities in due course. As the distinction between human and machine authorship becomes more blurred, it seems to me that we need to reconsider what we actually value in knowledge production. Surely the important question is not how much AI someone has used, but whether the person publishing something in their name understands the arguments being made and can defend the reasoning behind them in public and under heavy scrutiny. That is where intellectual responsibility should ultimately lie. On a side note, this is potentially a big opportunity for the media and Parliament to reassert their traditional roles in holding individuals to account! But I do think that knowledge workers are just going to have to get used to this - just as other industries have had to adapt to labour-saving technologies. We don’t ordinarily regard a product or service as less valuable simply because technology has reduced the amount of human labour required to produce it. Why should intellectual work be treated any differently? I suspect we may eventually see something similar to what has happened in food, fashion etc, where different forms of production coexist. There may well be a market for slower, more expensive, artisanal intellectual and creative work, where human authorship is itself part of the appeal, alongside work produced much more quickly and cheaply with the assistance of AI. But the fact remains that the method of production tells us relatively little about the quality of the finished product. What should matter is whether the work is any good, not how laborious it was to produce.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment

20% of the Milburn Review is AI. What are the norms on this? Is it basically now just OK? Instinctively I really dislike it but I have been trying to examine that instinct and see if it is just snobbery. I have an article coming out with Google's AI Policy Perspectives Substack soon about the issue. Part of me thinks that if you are going to use AI this heavily maybe there should be some more disclosure about the prompts. What was prompted for this section? Here are some bullet points about some kids, turn them into an emotive couple of paras?

Post attachment
Crémieux avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Crémieux@cremieuxrecueil·Nov 17

This meme perfectly represents the situation with rent control wherever it's enacted.

Post attachment

You'll never believe it, but Spain did rent controls and now there's a housing shortage.

Post attachment
Ryan Bourne avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Ryan Bourne@MrRBourne·Nov 17

Milburn Review is vintage government. Massively raise cost of employing marginal workers through minimum wages & employer taxes. Then propose huge bureaucracy & new schemes to deal with problems you've created.

Whig avatar
Whig@vulpine2020·Nov 17

You simply don’t hate the Labour Party enough

Extreme leftwing delusion, even at the highest level of British politics, is not new... Take, for example, Harold Laski(1893–1950), the Labour Party's pre-eminent political theorist in the inter-war years, Professor of Political Science at the LSE, chairman of the party in 1946 and commissioned to write the lengthy introduction to the Labour Party's official centenary edition of the Communist Manifesto in 1948. In 1935, Laski wrote that ‘Communist achievement’ in Russia was of epoch-making ‘magnificence’. Between 1929 and 1934, the Soviets had deported 1.8m smallholding peasants, killed over 250,000 of them in the process and then sparked the Holodomor with killed a further 3.5m-4m people. 'Magnificent'??? 🤢 In 1946, he described the Russian Revolution as 'the greatest, and the most beneficent event in modern history.' The reality: the Russian Revolution, subsequent civil war, and the famine that resulted from it, killed 10-14 million men, women and children. 'Beneficent'??? 🤢🤢 The following year, 1947, he denied that Lenin and Stalin were dictators ('neither Lenin nor Stalin ever played the part of a dictator') … But then, in the same speech, praised the very dictatorship he had just denied: 'I accept, without question, the high and benevolent purposes of the Russian Communist Party. I understand the reasons which persuade its leaders still to insist on the maintenance of controls which operated to exclude the democratic idea of freedom from the life of the Russian citizen.' He whitewashes it with fancy phrases ('maintenance of controls' and 'exclude the democratic idea of freedom') but it doesn't change the fact - Over the previous 30 years tens of millions had died, directly or indirectly, as a result of those two monsters' rule. THIS IS DELUSION ON A SIMPLY MIND-NUMBING SCALE and, I repeat, FROM A LEADING FIGURE IN THE BRITISH LABOUR PARTY You simply can't get worse than that. In my first book, Labour and the Gulag - Russia and the Seduction of the British Left, I detail all these (there were many more across the party, equally disturbing) at length.** The consequence of that for me is that, if its leading figures can so fall for evil, I can never trust anyone on the left of British politics ever again. (**1st edn out of print but 2nd edition copies are available on my website. Link in bio.)

Post attachmentPost attachment
Steve Loftus avatar
⟳ Whig retweeted
Steve Loftus@LoftusSteve·Nov 17

So, in the end Milburn's review is just a restructure that costs more money with the hope it might break even in a decade. At a time when we're struggling to find money for defense (or anything), Labour's big answer is more welfare.

🚨 SUMMARY: The proposed changes to benefits for under-25s in the Alan Milburn review - Replace PIP and the health element of Universal Credit with a new "Youth Allowance" set at £338.58 a month - Give higher Youth Allowance payments to young people living independently, including care leavers and those who are estranged from their families - Introduce an "Additional Cost Allowance" to replace PIP for young people with significant and ongoing disability-related costs (not means tested) - Introduce a "Severe and Complex Needs Insurance" for disabled young people unable to ever work, set above the current maximum benefit rates - Establish a "Youth Opportunity Service" (YOS) in every area of England by 2029 and give every NEET a named adviser to help them secure an apprenticeship, college place or job within 4 months - Create a local "Health and Disability Fund", run by the YOS, to help cover immediate or changing costs such as equipment, mobility needs and other one-off expenses - Scrap the Work Capability Assessment for under-25s and replace it with a conversation with a named YOS adviser to discuss their needs and identify support to help them into work or training - Introduce new participation requirements for those receiving the Youth Allowance with the option to withdraw the payments after repeated refusal to engage with the YOS - Give young people two new legal rights - one to employment or training opportunities through an "Opportunity Guarantee" and another to the health and practical support needed to take up those opportunities through a "Support Guarantee" - Pay employers £3,000 if they hire a NEET for at least 6 months and an extra £2,000 if they hire someone facing greater barriers (care leavers or disabled young people) - Help employers hire young people by cutting employer National Insurance contributions for 21 to 24-year-olds over 5 years, starting with retail and hospitality, and double the earnings threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 - Guarantee a Government-funded job for 6 months at 25 hours a week on minimum wage for young people still NEET after 12 months - Allow young people to keep their Youth Allowance payments when they start working before gradually reducing them to "make work pay" - Extend the Child Disability Support Allowance from age 16 to 18 so disabled young people avoid an immediate reassessment at 16 and have more time to prepare for work and adulthood - Give under-25s already claiming benefits 6 months to prepare before moving them onto the new benefits system - Give up to £500 to NEETs wanting to test a business idea through the YOS - Milburn hopes the changes will cut the NEET rate from 13% to around 5% by 2036 and bring around 440,000 more young people into education, employment or training each year - The proposals are expected to cost £5.8bn a year but save £6bn through reduced welfare spending and increased tax revenue, leaving a net saving of around £200m a year by 2036