
Very well said and 💯 accurate!
McCallie's statement about the direction of high school football is all fine and good. In fact, they make some valid points. But a more honest statement would acknowledge their own role in helping create the very landscape they're now criticizing. Look at the history. McCallie has won 5 state championships in 7 years. In 2025 alone, they had approximately 10 players with D1 offers, and at least 8 members of their 2026 graduating class are headed to D1 programs. In 2024, McCallie proposed rule changes that would require Tennessee transfers entering after 9th grade to sit out a year while preserving immediate eligibility for out-of-state transfers and allowing a limited number of international transfers. Think about that. Restrict Tennessee transfers while maintaining a pathway to bring in talent from across the country and Canada. McCallie isn't necessarily wrong about where high school football is headed. There are legitimate concerns about recruiting, competitive balance, and the direction of high school athletics. But where is the accountability for their own role in creating this environment? Imagine how much more powerful their statement would have been if they had acknowledged: "We helped create this arms race. Along the way, we got away from some of the core principles that should define high school athletics. We benefited from the system, and we recognize that change needs to start with us." That would be leadership. That would be a message worth rallying behind. Instead, the statement seems to point the finger at other schools without acknowledging McCallie's own history. You can't help create the arms race, benefit from it, win championships, and then criticize everyone else for competing. The issue isn't whether McCallie is right about the problem. They may very well be. The question is whether they're willing to acknowledge that they were part of creating it.

























