←
Alireza Talakoubnejad42,489 posts
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar

Alireza Talakoubnejad

@websterkaroon

Iranian-American Muslim interested in contemporary Iranian society, sports, art, and culture. Join my newsletter: iranophilia.beehiiv.com/subs…

◷ Joined February 2020▧ 5,721 Photos and videos
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·Apr 26

🎙️ Episode 6 - "90 Million Lives" has been released This episode looks at the uncertain ceasefire in the war & discusses how the primary criteria for judging political issues should be their impact on the lives of ordinary Iranians. Listen when you have a chance!

Post attachment

🎙️ Episode 5 - "Toxic Discourse" has been released This episode looks at the toxic nature of discourse in Iranian spaces in the aftermath of the January protests and current war. Listen when you have a chance!

Post attachment
Erfan Hoseiny avatar
⟳ Alireza Talakoubnejad retweeted
Erfan Hoseiny@Eri1806·8h

I’m from the village of Kal in Fars, the home of Mahya, a poet of southern Iran whose dobeyti poems are still sung there today as "Sherveh". He’s one of my ancestors. Picture of his resting place.

Post attachment
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·4h

I really like videos like this because they highlight an aspect of Iranian that is obvious for me but often gets overlooked by outsiders. GTA is a massive global cultural phenomenon in Iran, particularly among millennials, but also younger Gen Xers and Gen Z. In fact in my own experience, I've sometimes felt that GTA is in some ways a bigger cultural phenomenon in Iran than it is in the United States. There's a tendency to imagine Iran as a culturally isolated country because of its political isolation. But certain elements of global popular culture have been absolutely enormous in Iran for decades. GTA and Counter-Strike are obvious examples. So is fandom of teams like Barcelona and Real Madrid. Even certain American television shows, like House of Cards, are massive. And this isn't simply a phenomenon among wealthy, cosmopolitan, or "Westernized" Iranians. For an entire generation, going to a game cafe to play Counter-Strike or GTA was a formative experience. It might be tempting to attribute this to one group in society, but I've seen this in secular people, religious people, pro gov, anti gov. Obviously, some families disapprove of them, but in my experience, these cultural reference points often transcend class, politics, and religiosity. They're much more generational than ideological. In fact, the GTA phenomenon has become so widespread that, as I stated in a post yesterday, Neshan, an Iranian navigation app, recently introduced an entire GTA inspired map mode. This is all a useful reminder that the cultural lives of ordinary Iranians are often considerably more connected to the rest of the world than outsiders might assume. Iran is certainly politically isolated, but it's not North Korea. I doubt you'd see a street interview like this in Pyongyang, with young people casually discussing their GTA preorders. And sometimes, two Iranians who disagree about virtually everything politically still share the same childhood memories of playing GTA.

1:52
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·4h

This is misleading. Perhaps not the hardware but Russian/Chinese satellite guidance information was very important

سردار حسین علایی: تنها تسلیحاتی کار کردند که ساخت خودمان در داخل ایران بود. تسلیحات روسی و چینی در این جنگ از کار افتادند.

1:28
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·5h

Unless this is an elaborate ruse, that refutes the "3 Aircraft Carrier" theory that Trump was waiting for the third aircraft carrier to arrive in November to launch operations. And puts heavy questions on the "Trump is doing the mother of all military buildups to hit as hard as possible" theory that is popular in some parts of the Israeli media ecosystem. Instead it seems to support that theory that he doesn't have a grand plan and is just YOLO-ing things while he hopes economic pressure will get the other side to give more concessions.

NEW: The USS George Washington has left the Middle East and is now conducting "routine operations" in the Pacific Fleet region. It was replaced earlier this week by the USS Theodore Roosevelt, so two aircraft carriers remain in the Middle East

Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·9h

Longer piece on Ayatollah Vahid

Ayatollah Hossein Vahid Khorasani, arguably the most prominent remaining traditionalist Shia marja of the old generation, passed away today in Qom at the age of 105. Khorasani's age alone made him fascinating. He was one of the few remaining Iranians that had seen the reign of six different rulers under three different regimes (Ahmad Shah Qajar, Reza Shah Pahlavi, Mohamad Reza Shah Pahlavi, Ruhollah Khomeini, Ali Khamenei, Mojtaba Khamenei). Khorasani got his early education in Mashad and then moved to Najaf in 1949 where he studied under several of the most prominent scholars of the 20th century, particularly Seyyed Mohsen al-Hakim and Ayatollah Khoei. He then returned to Mashad in the early 1970s and settled in Qom in 1973 where he stayed until his death. He is firmly in the camp of the traditionalist Shia scholars - strongly rejecting modern reformist currents (for example he took public stances against Dr. Soroush & Ayatollah Fadlallah). He argued authentic religious knowledge only came from the Quran and ahadith of the 12 Imams rather than Greek influenced philosophy or speculative mysticism. His influence was not limited to scholarly debates. Perhaps his single biggest legacy was expanding the public mourning ceremony of Fatimiyya to become something similar to the Muharram in the Shi'i calendar (he didn't invent the practice but it was not as widely commemorated in the way it was today before this). The culmination of this was him successfully lobbying President Khatami's administration to declare the martyrdom of Hazrat Zahra to be a public holiday. Khorasani's political stances were complex. He was certainly not a revolutionary activist and did not publicly participate in the 1979 Revolution in the same way some other marjas did. Similar to his teacher Ayatollah Khoei, he was a quietist - he didn't entirely stay away from politics but was extremely cautious in speaking about it and tried to keep his organizations institutionally independent from the state. As such, his most clear political stances were often from his silence. Most notably, he declined to meet with Ayatollah Khamenei in his trip to Qom in the aftermath of the disputed 2009 elections (widely interpreted to be a sign of disapproval). He also declined to meet with him in a few subsequent visits. During that time I remember overhearing from many people associated with the security apparatus or more prominently pro government marjas that they considered Ayatollah Vahid and his followers to be insufficiently loyal and even opposition. But in reality he was not entirely against the state either. One of his daughters married Sadegh Larijani, who later became head of the judiciary. He did later meet Ayatollah Khamenei at least once in Mashad and when Khamenei was in the hospital he sent his son to visit him. He has on occasion made general criticisms of the state for political repression, economic conditions, and religious observance but these are few and far between. As a whole he stayed away from politics whether for or against. I never met Ayatollah Vahid myself, though I had the pleasure of correspondence with several senior clerics in his office over the years. I found them to be quite intelligent and delightfully curious about the state of intellectual currents and people's concerns in Shi'i communities in the West (although I did always wish they had a similar feeling towards newer generations in Iran itself, something I never directly said out of politeness). They, alongside Ayatollah Vahid himself, were critical to my own religious and intellectual development, something I will be eternally grateful for. I would be negligent here not to say that in the past 10 years I also witnessed a great deal of younger believers my age grow resentful of Ayatollah Vahid, someone they previously had extreme respect for, because they became extremely frustrated that he would not speak up at all. I noticed this most keenly after the Aban 98 Gasoline Protests and these voices grew even stronger after the 2022 protests. They were frustrated why he (and Ayatollah Sistani) were not willing to take any public stance against the oppression and tyranny - compared to the level of fury they showed over, for example, a film showing the face of Hazrat Abalfazl, something they viewed as blasphemous. This has even led some younger, traditionally observant Shi'is to question the institution of marja'iyya itself. What makes this particularly noteworthy is that these criticisms are emerging not from the religious reformist currents of the previous generation, but from within the very traditionalist communities that historically held the marja'iyya in the highest regard. For better or worse, however, I think it is difficult to expect someone in his 90s or 100s to fundamentally reconsider a relationship with political power that had been shaped over nearly a century. His quietism was not a late life accommodation but a deeply ingrained approach to religious authority, one shared by many scholars of his generation. Whether that approach will remain viable for future generations of believers is another question entirely. In the last decade he had also grown increasingly frail & slowly disappeared from public appearances. In the end he was only seen once or twice a year publicly, on Ashura and the Fatemiyye. Ultimately, he was a giant in 20th and 21st century Shi'ism, whose extraordinarily long life spanned some of the most consequential transformations in modern Iranian history. Through revolution, war, political upheaval, and profound social change, he remained a towering figure in the traditional Shi'i scholarly establishment. I pray God blesses his soul, rewards him for his good deeds, and forgive him for his shortcomings.

Post attachment
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·9h

I wrote an earlier piece going into more detail about Ayatollah Vahid's relationship with politics, but in this case there's a much more straightforward reason for this. Mojtaba Khamenei studied under him (among many other teachers) for several years. Beyond any political considerations it would be surprising if he didn't say anything for his former teacher. Just like he did for Ayatollah Shobeiri Zanjani.

Iran’s Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei has issued a message of condolence following the death of Grand Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani, describing him as “one of the main pillars” of the teaching of Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) and its principles (usul) in the Shia seminaries. - The message pays tribute to Khorasani’s religious authority, scholarly achievements and lifelong contribution to the preservation of Shia Islam. - There is also a political dimension worth noting. - Khorasani was widely regarded as a senior marja who maintained considerable independence from the political establishment and whose relationship with the Islamic Republic’s leadership was not always straightforward. - Mojtaba Khamenei’s public tribute is therefore significant. It acknowledges the religious standing of a figure whose authority derived from the traditional Shia seminary system rather than the institutions of the Islamic Republic. #Iran

ein avatar
⟳ Alireza Talakoubnejad retweeted
ein@stylishdawg·Nov 17

kind of insane that anthropic ipo and gta 6 are the same day. like some guy is gonna make 100 million dollars and then get to spend the rest of the day playing a video game he’s waited 13 years for. chills.

Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·10h

You can find everything on earth in Iran ... for the right price

0:57
Alireza Talakoubnejad avatar
Alireza Talakoubnejad@websterkaroon·23h

The funny thing is you have the exact same type of person on the Iranian side who argues Iran was on the brink of total victory but the libs chose to make peace with America so Iran immediately lost all leverage over the Strait. Mirror images of each other

The idea that Iran went from the edge of defeat to completely rearmed and rallied during the short MOU period while we admit it will take maybe half a decade to rearm from our side is so risible I can’t believe anyone is saying it.