←
Sarah Isgur15,612 posts
Sarah Isgur avatar

Sarah Isgur

@whignewtons

@ABC News contributor, Advisory Opinions host, @SCOTUSblog editor, putting the R in @LRCkcrw, Texas expat, @Harvard_Law grad, cat/brisket mom.

◷ Joined February 2009▧ 1,306 Photos and videos
Sarah Isgur avatar
Sarah Isgur@whignewtons·5 Nov 2025

Pre-order my book! "A myth-busting glimpse into the inner workings of the Supreme Court." Fun for lawyers and non-lawyers alike, including John Jay's head injury, why the end of the filibuster is bad for the judiciary, and who is watching Slow Horses. penguinrandomhouse.com/books…

Jesse Singal avatar
⟳ Sarah Isgur retweeted
Jesse Singal@jessesingal·Nov 14

There's a stuckness to a lot of these debates. The surge pricing is to get more drivers on the road. I'm not defending the specific way Uber does it but as with the expensive-groceries-in-NYC debate there's an assumption that greed and only greed explains the pricing.

jezz@JezziiBNov 14

The FAA literally grounded every flight in the US over a nationwide communications outage, and Uber’s immediate response is to charge stranded passengers $100–$200 just to go a few miles from the airport. Profiteering off a national travel crisis isn't "dynamic pricing." It's predatory.

Spencer Cox avatar
⟳ Sarah Isgur retweeted
Spencer Cox@SpencerJCox·Nov 14

Poor Bo French tried to do some light blood and soil to make himself feel better after losing his election…only to get owned by a notary public and youth coaching legend. Now the entire country knows he financed his waterbed and didn’t letter in 💩.

This app has peaked

Post attachmentPost attachment
Avik Roy avatar
⟳ Sarah Isgur retweeted
Avik Roy@Avik·Nov 14

I only listen to Heritage Americans whose understanding of the English language includes knowing the difference between "who's" and "whose".

Dilan Esper avatar
⟳ Sarah Isgur retweeted
Dilan Esper@dilanesper·Nov 10

Sarah's discussion of this on Advisory Opinions reminded me of something I wanted to talk about. "Resignation upon confirmation of a successor" is a violation of the Constitution, perpetrated by both the executive branch and SCOTUS.

Alito won't retire in the lame duck and he doesn't need to. Trump can nominate someone to the Supreme Court and the senate can confirm without a vacancy. Then Trump can wait to sign the commission any time in the next two years. The question isn't Alito, its Cornyn/Tillis/Thune.

Sarah Isgur avatar
Sarah Isgur@whignewtons·Nov 9

“judicial recess appointments have been made so often, by so many Presidents, in so many settings, beginning with George Washington…”

Sarah Isgur avatar
Sarah Isgur@whignewtons·Nov 9

Once again, I am *describing* an option that is contemplated by the constitution. Do I think this is a good idea? No. Would it be bad for the court as an institution? Yes. Would it be totally lawful? Also yes…

Jonah Goldberg avatar
⟳ Sarah Isgur retweeted
Jonah Goldberg@JonahDispatch·Nov 9

Me, walking through the intern pits, making sure there's not too much jocularity.

The way he’s walking.

0:10
Sarah Isgur avatar
Sarah Isgur@whignewtons·Nov 6

I’m not endorsing this idea—quite the opposite. I’m explaining why everyone should stop asking/assuming that Alito is retiring. Instead, they should get Thune on the record that they won’t confirm a lame duck nominee bc there’s nothing in the constitution that prohibits this.

Sarah Isgur avatar
Sarah Isgur@whignewtons·Nov 5

I’m against this idea. My point is that everyone focused on Alito’s retirement is asking the wrong question of the wrong person. GOP senators would be idiots to do this (and I’m confident they wouldn’t) but there’s nothing constitutionally/legally preventing it.

Alito won't retire in the lame duck and he doesn't need to. Trump can nominate someone to the Supreme Court and the senate can confirm without a vacancy. Then Trump can wait to sign the commission any time in the next two years. The question isn't Alito, its Cornyn/Tillis/Thune.