←
Tim Kauffman8,691 posts
Tim Kauffman avatar

Tim Kauffman

@whpub

I monitor transmillennial patterns of apostasy. Beware the migration of the epiclesis.

◷ Joined July 2011▧ 503 Photos and videos
Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·12 Jul 2025

@CrushnSerpents has accused me of lying in my opening statement during my debate with @ArchangeloRom yesterday. The public accusation provides an opportunity as entertaining as it is instructional. No, I did not lie, and he has yet to identify "the lie" of which I am accused. And by the way, there are no "hundreds of pages of context" in Fragment 37 of Irenæus. It's a paragraph. In my opening yesterday, I stated quite clearly that the ancient Church believed the Malachi 1:11 prophecy was a Eucharist offering of the first fruits of the harvest for the poor. After the Eucharist "sacrifice" was over, they would take some bread and wine from the Eucharist offering and consecrate it, as I said, either by saying'This is My Body,' and 'This is My blood' or by invoking the Holy Spirit to similar effect. But the Eucharist offering was over before the bread and wine were consecrated, and the consecrated bread and wine were not offered. There was no offering of "Jesus' body and blood" in the ancient church. That abominable novelty came along in the late 4th century. Evidence that first-fruits was the only Eucharist oblation of the ancient church is abundant: Justin Martyr said the ONLY honour worthy of God is for us to use the fruit of the harvest "for ourselves and those who need, and with gratitude to Him to offer thanks" (First Apology, 13) and that "prayers and giving of thanks, when offered by worthy men, are the ONLY perfect and well-pleasing sacrifices to God" (Trypho 117). When he describes the ancient liturgy, there is an offering of thanks for food (First Apology 65, 67) with no mention of having consecrated the food before offering, and when there is a mention of a consecration (First Apology, 66), it is spoken over the food that had just been "eucharisted," and there is no mention of offering the now consecrated food. Thus does Justin rule out a liturgical offering of Jesus' body and blood. Unconsecrated food is offered to God. Consecrated food is given to the flock to eat. But consecrated food is not offered. Irenæus describes something similar when he says "We are bound, therefore, to offer to God the first-fruits of His creation" (Against Heresies 4.18.1), and "the Church alone offers this pure oblation to the Creator, offering to Him, with giving of thanks, [the things taken] from His creation" (4.18.4). He then criticizes the Gnostics for offering the first fruits of creation to "the Father" while not even believing the first fruits had come from "the Father," then pronouncing the consecration over over food that had just been eucharisted: "But how can they be consistent with themselves, [when they say] that the bread over which thanks have been given is the body of their Lord, and the cup His blood" (Against Heresies 4.18.5). Food is offered. Then it is consecrated. But consecrated food is not offered. Origen describes this exact same liturgical order in Against Celsus 8.34, noting that in the Eucharist "we offer first-fruits, we also send up our prayers," and in 8.57 "And we have a symbol of gratitude to God in the bread which we call the Eucharist." Thus, his liturgy is succintly summarized in 8.33 as a Eucharist offering of first fruits, followed by a meal of consecrated bread: "But we give thanks to the Creator of all, and, along with thanksgiving and prayer for the blessings we have received, we also eat the bread presented to us; and this bread becomes by prayer a sacred body, which sanctifies those who sincerely partake of it.” There is no offering of consecrated bread, and when the bread is consecrated, it is not offered. Unconsecrated food is offered to God. Consecrated food is given to the flock to eat. But consecrated food is not offered. And that gets us to Fragment 37, in which Irenæus says the Malachi 1:11 prophecy is fulfilled in the Church's oblation of first-fruits: "And therefore the oblation of the Eucharist is not a carnal one, but a spiritual; and in this respect it is pure. For we make an oblation to God of the bread and the cup of blessing, giving Him thanks in that He has commanded the earth to bring forth these fruits for our nourishment." Once that oblation is complete—as I said in my opening remarks—the minister then performs the invocation, asking that the Holy Spirit "exhibit" to the recipients the bread and cup as the body and blood of Christ: "And then, when we have perfected the oblation, we invoke the Holy Spirit, that He may exhibit this sacrifice, both the bread the body of Christ, and the cup the blood of Christ, in order that the receivers of these antitypes may obtain remission of sins and life eternal." There is an oblation of first fruits, and then AFTER the oblation is already over, there is an invocation of the Holy Spirit to "exhibit" the offerings to the recipients, as in "the body of Christ," "the blood of Christ." What is offered is not consecrated, and what gets consecrated is not then offered. An interesting point of trivia: "exhibit" here is the Greek word "apophene" from which we get the English word "apophenia," which is a condition in which the mind forms an otherwise abnormal connection between unrelated objects. So Irenæus' liturgy of the Eucharist concludes with a prayer that the Holy Spirit would form in the mind of the recipient a connection between something that is not the body of Christ (the bread) and something that is the body of Christ (His actual body). Thus showing that Irenæus understood the bread and wine to be symbolic—antitypical—of Christ's body and blood, but NOT ACTUALLY His body and blood. In my opening remarks I said exactly what I believed about the ancient liturgy (an unconsecrated Eucharist was offered, and after the offering was over, the Eucharist of the bread and cup was called the body and blood of Christ, but was not then offered), I warned about the tendency of the Roman Catholic to miss that and assume that because the ancient Church offered the Eucharist (it did) and called the Eucharist "the body and blood of Christ" (it did) that therefore the ancient Church offered the body and blood of Christ in the Eucharist (it didn't). As is now evident, @CrushnSerpents did exactly what I predicted: because after the Eucharist oblation Irenæus asks the Holy Spirit to "exhibit" the bread and wine as the body and blood of Christ, therefore THE BODY AND BLOOD OF CHRIST MUST BE WHAT IRENÆUS OFFERED IN THE EUCHARIST. But read Irenæus again and see what he offered: "For we make an oblation to God of the bread and the cup of blessing, giving Him thanks in that He has commanded the earth to bring forth these fruits for our nourishment." And of course, Irenæue did not—in Fragment 37 or anywhere else—claim that the Malachi 1:11 prophecy was fulfilled in the liturgical offering of Jesus' body and blood. Note well: to the Roman Catholic, unless you interpret the ancient liturgy consistent with their late 4th century novelty, you're lying. To an ignorant man, truth is falsehood if it undermines the foundation of his ignorance. @CrushnSerpents has provided a timely illustration of this reality.

Louis-Marie 🇻🇦 a.k.a the Queen's Goober@CrushnSerpents 11 Jul 2025 Replying to @whpub @Brosephos

Post attachment
Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·10h

This was helpful and sobering. I appreciate the work @5Solas2 did here. It is going to lead down an uncomfortable rabbit trail that is very much worth pursuing. Jorgensen's "hopeless situation" video from 2013 as it turns out, borrowed substantially from others without attribution. 1. Jorgensen's "Timothy was too young, Abraham was too old, Lazarus was dead" was lifted verbatim and without attribution from Igniter Media's 2010 "The March of the Unqualified", which was likely inspired without attribution, by Matthew Tullos' 1992 "God uses imperfect people" list, which contains almost identical language: "Abraham was to old. David was too young. ... Lazarus was dead." All—Tullos, Igniter, Jorgensen, and Huff—are making the same point from that list. 2. Jorgensen's observation, "we can never place a period where God has placed a comma," was made without attribution, but is from Gracie Allen's final letter to George Burns in the 1960s, and was cited with that attribution no later than 2001. 3. Jorgensen's "mess into messengers" was entirely lifted from another source without attribution: Jorgensen: "only God can turn a mess into a message. Only God can turn a trial into a triumph, a test into a testimony, and a victim into a victory." Els Vervolet (1990s): “God can turn a mess into a message, a test into a testimony, a trial into a triumph, a victim into a victory." Cited online, with attribution, no later than 2006. But all quoted by Jorgensen without attribution, and then apparently adapted by Huff without attribution. Of course, Jorgensen's video was in "motivational speech" style, format and diction, and such speeches lose their motivational quality if you constantly pause for attribution, and some of the things he said are so platitudinous that maybe they belong in the public domain anyway. Huff's speech was similar in delivery. But Jorgensen could not honestly claim to have been defrauded by Huff since Jorgensen borrowed so heavily from others, and I doubt Matthew Tullos (1992) is losing sleep over Igniter Media's adaptation, and neither Gracie Allen nor Els Vervolet are likely even aware of their renewed fame and accolades. And to my original point, this is a rabbit trail very much worth pursuing because all of us could probably stand to check the provenance of our words before collecting money for them.

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Nov 16

I'm old enough to have done bigger and dumber things than @WesleyLHuff is accused of doing. So, hang in there, buddy. It's not the unpardonable sin. "Yea, he shall be holden up: for God is able to make him stand" (Romans 14:4).

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Nov 5

If you’re confused by what happened in the election of Talarico in Texas on Tuesday, you need not be. Tim Keller’s exegetical chickens have simply come home to roost. Talarico was a big fan of Tim Keller’s exegetical method and has implemented it as taught. You are simply observing in real time the fruit it has borne. @chadojackson’s observation on Talarico’s misuse of Scripture: “Instead he merely uses the Bible and Christianity and deliberately misrepresents it in order to dupe certain biblically illiterate churchgoers who unfortunately don’t know the difference, who don’t know that they’re being lied to.” Tim Keller’s own professed exegetical method from his an 18-part course on how to Preach Christ in a Postmodern World: On working same-sex relationships into his sermons: “I have a bible study with three gay women artists, and me. One is a Christian, one is probably a new Christian. One is very much a non-Christian. We read the Book of Ruth. What did they see? What do you think they saw? They said, ‘This is incredible. The two women create a non-traditional family in which a woman is the breadwinner. They buck the traditional family in which you have to have a man. And the basis of it is faith. Their common faith made them a family as opposed to tradition or blood.’ I had never seen that before. I had never seen that before. Why did they see it? Well, because two of the three are in long term lesbian relationships. The couples have been together for years and years and years. They immediately thought about that. Now, what I’m trying to say is: I hear the things that they say as they’re reading through the book so then that affects the way I’m preaching. When I sit down and I study the text, I’m immediately thinking of things that they said, and that automatically gets into the sermon.” On omitting texts that are disagreeable to the postmodern mind: “That’s another problem with preaching from…Esther…. So if you’re really going to preach…Esther, you know what I’d do, in New York, I’d just never bring that out. I mean, people don’t come to church with their Bibles. They study the passage I print out in the text. So I’m just not going to bring that up.” (Session 9: Applying Christ Part IV: Getting Down to Earth Part II, 1:01:15-1:03:02) “They don’t have Bibles. Besides that, also non-Christians may not have Bibles. So we print it out [in the church bulletin]. And that works very, very well by the way. It also is a great way of keeping away from certain texts that you don’t want them to see.” (Session 13 Q&A, 9:10-9:33) More on Tim Keller’s professed (and flawed) exegetical method here: trinityfoundation.org/journa…

Some thoughts on last nights election.

2:45
Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Oct 20

So this is from last year, but @JoeHeschmeyer thinks he has the question that can finally stump the Protestants. The question is intended force the unsuspecting Protestant to paint himself into a corner: "Who was the first pope?" If the answer is "Peter," then "Why aren't you Catholic?", right? And if the answer is "someone else," then "Who was it and how do you know that they’re the first one?" Whoever is identified as the first is, to Joe, sufficiently ancient that it still comes down to, "Then why aren't you Catholic?" Oh no! An impossible trap! No, not really. There's an easy way out of this, if you're willing to take it. First, Joe's question is a little anachronistic. Cyprian of Carthage was called "Pope" by the congregation in Rome, and Athanasius of Alexandria was called "Pope" as well. It was a common title long before it came to refer singularly to the bishop of Rome. But "who was the first pope?" isn't even the real question. The real question is "Who was Bishop of Rome at the time prophesied by Scripture for the emergence of the Little Horn that arose among the fragments of the Roman Empire?" and the answer is easy: Pope Damasus (AD 366 to 384). We know this because Daniel prophesied that the Roman Empire would break into 13 fragments, and a Little Horn would arise among the fragments and claim three of them for himself (Daniel 7:20,24). (You can read why there were 13 here: x.com/whpub/status/210705402…) Sometime between about AD 370 and AD 383, during the pontificate of Damasus, the Roman empire divided into 13 dioceses, each under a metropolitan city. It was under Damasus' reign that the theory of the Three Petrine Sees originated. He claimed that the Church was built upon Peter's three seats in Rome (because that's where Peter died), in Alexandria (because that's where his disciple, Mark, ended up) and in Antioch (because that's where he started). Those three cities were by then the three metropolitan cities of the three Dioceses of Italy, Egypt and Oriens. And there began the claim that the true Church of Christ was Built upon "A See of One in Three Places." The fact that the Little Horn had already scooped them up on his rise is the reason Daniel only saw 10 horns remaining as it came to full stature, a prophecy almost a thousand years in its fulfillment. Unsurprisingly, Damasus' rise to power was accompanied by all the carnal, murderous ambition that you would expect from such a figure. Ammianus Marcellinus records the violent election: "Damasus and Ursinus, being both immoderately eager to obtain the bishopric, formed parties and carried on the conflict with great asperity, the partisans of each carrying their violence to actual battle, in which men were wounded and killed. ... Ultimately Damasus got the best of the strife by the strenuous efforts of his partisans." (Roman History 27.3.12-13). The English here is too polite. The Latin is much less dainty: "Damasus and Ursinus, burning with an intensity that transcended human bounds to seize the episcopal see..." "An intensity that transcended human bounds." I'll bet it did. When all the dust settled, the basilica was soaked in the blood of 137 men, so "immoderately eager" 🧐 were these men to occupy this newly powerful episcopate. Good times. Unsurprisingly this Little Horn would one day find itself on the receiving end of the fawning attention of a false prophet (the Apparition of Mary) that could even make the fire of heaven descend to earth in the sight of men (Fatima), urging us all to bow down before an image (the Eucharist) that is known occasionally to bleed, pulsate, and even speak (Euharistic miracles). Yes, there was a time when men were put to death for not worshiping that image. Who could've seen that coming? (Revelation 13:15). So, the first "Pope" (the way Roman Catholics really mean it) was Damasus. I know this because he arose at the time the Roman empire finally divided into 13 dioceses, and right on cue, he claimed 3 them as the seat of the new world religion, bearing the fruits of covetousness, carnal ambition and murder to attain to his throne. And that leads to Joe's most favorite question of all: "Who founded the Roman Catholic Church?" This, too, Scriptures answer plainly: "The dragon gave his power and his throne and great authority" to the Beast (Revelation 13:2). Joe's questions are carefully crafted to force the Protestant to implicitly assume Joe's premise: an unbroken unfolding of Church History from Peter to Leo XIV. If you grant that assumption, there can be no "first pope" without conceding that Roman Catholicism is the Church Jesus founded on Peter. But if you study the history of what Daniel foresaw, what happened with Damasus was a new thing, utterly unrelated to Jesus' promises to His Church, a grotesque departure from the preceding centuries. It was a new religion for a new empire, and Damasus was it's first "Pope." And the fact that practically the whole world fell for the lie should not surprise us in the least because this, too, had been foreseen: "the whole earth marveled as they followed the beast" (Revelation 13:3). As I said, you need not be stumped by Joe's questions. But you do have to be willing to avoid the trap he has laid for you. 😇 catholic.com/audio/sp/the-on…

@garrettham_esq , this is one of my favorite questions. The ancient church understood that it lived under the Roman empire, and that according to Daniel‘s prophecies, the Roman empire would soon split 10 ways and the wicked one, the beast of Revelation 13, the little Horn of Daniel 7, would scoop up three of the 10 and begin to rule over the rest as the 5th earthly empire of Daniel‘s visions. Have you ever wondered to yourself, what would happen if the Roman Empire divided into 10 horns, and the wicked one snatched away three: how many horns would be left? There would be 7. And yet in every depiction of the 5th empire in scripture, the beast of Revelation 13 has 10 horns in his entourage. Revelation 12, Revelation 13, revelation 17 all depict 10 horns all the way up to the very end when they do battle against the Lamb. But if the Roman empire divided into 10 horns and the wicked one uprooted three, why do 10 remain? That’s a question that puzzled me for decades. Scripture abhors a contradiction. It turns out that Daniel chapter 7 was written in a language that has no past perfect tense. And therefore there was no way in the original language to state that the little Horn came up among 10 horns, having already uprooted three in his uprising. That meaning can only be discerned in context, and Revelation provides that context. The solution to the apparent contradiction between Daniel 7 and Revelation chapters 12, 13 and 17 is that Daniel was in fact aware that the Roman empire would divide 13 ways and the little Horn he saw arising had already scooped up three when he arose. Daniel chapter 7, never says that there had only been 10 horns in the original division and neither does it say that the wicked one or the little Horn scooped up three of the 10. There were in fact 13 horns before the little one arose. The antagonist of Daniel chapter 7, that little Horn, also identified in Revelation 13 as the beast of the sea, is whoever scooped up three of the 13 divisions of the Roman Empire. You will therefore find it fascinating to discover that in fact, the Roman empire was divided 13 ways. Under Diocletian it was divided into 12 dioceses and over the next century through readjustment and shifts they ended up being 13 dioceses, the 13th of which was formed only in about AD 370. In AD 381, the council of Constantinople had the temerity to suggest that it was second only to Rome, and was in fact the new Rome. The bishop of Rome responded that the see of Peter existed in three places simultaneously: in Rome, in Alexandria, and Antioch, and certainly not in Constantinople. And therefore the church, he claimed, the see of Peter was in fact of see of one existing in three places. Those three cities happen to be the three chief Metropoli of the three dioceses of Italy, Egypt, and Oriens. And therefore in its carnal. Geopolitical ambition, the episcopate of Rome fulfilled Daniel‘s prophecy and became the fifth earthly empire of Daniel’s visions, scooping up three dioceses of the 13-way division of the empire and eventually subjugating the remaining 10. The rest is just details, but to prove that Roman Catholicism is apostate, does not require that I prove to your satisfaction that there is a separate church that existed throughout history. All I have to do is prove that Roman Catholicism is in fact, the apostasy that Daniel foresaw. Once you realize that, you will begin to search elsewhere for the true church. But the scripture has already informed us that that true church is not Roman Catholicism. To begin your studies I invite you to consider this article called a See of One. whitehorseblog.com/2014/05/2…

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Oct 13

Just a reminder that “trogo” was used metaphorically in the ancient church. It was not solely understood as literal chewing and munching: Barnabas (1st century): “Now, wherefore did Moses say, 'You shall not eat (τρωγειν) the swine' ... Moses spoke with a spiritual reference ... He means, 'You shall not join yourself or be like to such men as are ungodly to the end'" (Epistle of Barnabas, 10). Macarius the Egyptian (early 4th century): citing John 6:54, says trogein is a metaphor for "devouring" the Words of the Old and New Testaments, "eating the flesh and drinking the blood of Wisdom", which means that Jesus gave us His flesh and blood as food "allegorically": "Now the flesh and blood of Christ, or of Wisdom (for Christ and Wisdom are the same), are the words of the Old and New Testaments spoken with allegorical meaning, which men must devour (τρώγειν) with care and digest by calling them to mind with the understanding, and win from them not temporal but eternal life. Thus did Jeremiah eat when he received the words from the hand of Wisdom, and by eating he had life; thus did Ezekiel feel sweetness when he ate the roll of the words (Ezek. iii. 3), and the bitterness of this present life was cast away. Thus did the saints one by one, once long ago, and again and again, by eating the flesh and drinking the blood of Wisdom, that is, by receiving in themselves the knowledge and revelation of her, live for aye with a life that will never cease. It was not only to the disciples that He gave His own flesh to eat and likewise His own blood to drink (for He would not have done right in thus offering the life eternal to some at a certain season, but not supplying it to others); but it was to all men alike in whom was holiness and the spirit of prophecy, that He gave allegorically this supply of food." (Apocriticus III.23)

In celebration of Reformation Month, I have a few questions for Protestants. In John 6:53-56, Jesus switches from phago to trogo 4 times in a row. Phago means to eat, general. Trogo means to chew, gnaw, crunch, used for animals eating. He who trogo my flesh... Then in John 6:60, the disciples say This is a skleros saying, who can hear it? Skleros means hard. Question: If Jesus was speaking symbolically, meaning believe in me, why would they call a symbolic teaching hard? A metaphor about believing is not hard. Eating human flesh literally IS hard. And why does Jesus, instead of clarifying I mean symbolically, double down and let them leave in John 6:66-67, losing most of his followers? In 1 Cor 10:16, Paul uses koinonia, actual participation or sharing in, not symbolon of. The cup we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? Participation in what doesn't exist is nonsense grammar. So you have to claim: 1) trogo means believe, 2) a metaphor is called hard, 3) Jesus let disciples go to hell over a misunderstanding he could fix in one sentence, and 4) Paul uses participation language for a symbol. Question: Which early Christian in 500 years read it that way? Did the Holy Spirit let the entire Church be idolaters who literally worship bread for 1500 years?

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Oct 10

Can Bree tell us which parts of the catechism ARE infallible and binding on us?

Reminder: This part of the catechism is not infallible or binding on you. You are under no obligation to agree with it or submit to it. In fact, I’d say you’re on more solid ground by sticking with what the Church consistently taught for two millenia. 🤷‍♀️

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Oct 10

Chris Stefanick complains that “Catholics misinterpret the Church’s teaching about infallibility,” and explains that you don’t have to believe everything the pope says. Now, if only someone could tell me infallibly which papal teachings have been infallible. Anyone? Anyone?

Post attachment

This tweet is unavailable

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 23

Still, though, Vigilantius was right, and Jerome expressed dismay that Vigilantius was well received by the Alpine clergy, who agreed with him and were in fact, making successful raids on the churches in Gaul, bringing them the truth. These corruptions regarding relics began in late antiquity not in the late medieval period, and the vast majority of the professing world dove headlong into the error. @hdpayens makes a good point with which I concur: if you hold the position that the Roman Catholic corruption of the church took place in the late or high medieval period, you’re tacitly buying into and accepting a lot of Roman Catholic error not only as tolerable, but as normative for centuries before “the later corruption.“ This is why it’s so important to recognize that the Roman Catholic apostasy occurred in the late 4th century not the 15th or 16th.

In 406 AD, a priest named Vigilantius attacked the veneration of relics and the intercession of saints. He expected the Church to thank him for purifying the faith. Instead, Jerome wrote back with open contempt. His reply is a time capsule, and it demolishes the claim that these practices were medieval corruptions. A thread.

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 21

The proposed theory of Roman primacy based on Clement’s letter to Corinth falls apart upon inspection. Rome, too, had a schism. A faction of laity had refused their legitimate presbyters. And who did Rome’s troubles reach? Not a local council. Not a free-floating prophet. The church at Carthage, led by its bishop, Cyprian. Cyprian writes with unmistakable authority to a church that was not his. In fact, Cyprian commanded that his letter be read aloud in the Roman congregation to eliminate any remaining vestiges of error, for which intervention the warring Roman factions thanked him in writing! If the OP is correct, that makes Carthage the Chief Episcopate of the early church. After all, a traveling evangelist writes a letter? That's advice. A bishop correcting another church's internal discipline, and commands that his letter be read aloud to the whole congregation to settle the division? THAT’S JURISDICTION!

Clement of Rome never visited Corinth. He still wrote to correct it, and Corinth kept his letter for 70 years and read it aloud in worship. The common picture of the early Church is a loose, informal fellowship. No hierarchy. No offices. Just believers gathering with whoever felt called to lead. Then you open Clement's letter, written around 96 AD, and the picture collapses. Corinth had a schism. A faction of laity had deposed their legitimate presbyters. And who did Corinth's troubles reach? Not a local council. Not a free-floating prophet. The church at Rome, led by its bishop, Clement. Clement writes with unmistakable authority to a church that was not his. He reminds them that the Apostles preached, then appointed bishops and deacons, and that these offices were not human arrangements but instituted by God's will. And the Apostles, he says, provided for succession, so that when leaders die, other approved men take up their ministry. He tells the rebels to submit and restore the deposed men. Corinth obeyed the letter so thoroughly that decades later it was still being read aloud in their liturgy, a fact we know from a later bishop of Corinth mentioning the practice to Rome. A traveling evangelist writes a letter? That's advice. A bishop correcting another church's internal discipline, and that church treasuring it in worship for generations? That's jurisdiction. Clement is named in the Roman Canon of the Mass. He is not decoration. He is evidence. If the early Church had no hierarchy, why did Corinth treat Rome's intervention as authoritative instead of presumptuous?

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 20

To the contrary, the correct hermeneutic is to understand the deposit of faith in the context of the pope’s meaning (which has escaped Knowles). “Jesus doesn’t hear the prayers” means “Jesus doesn’t hear the prayers.” Now is not a time for nuance! In the “full context” of Leo’s meaning, we may understand that while Pope Pius V called for widespread recitation of the Rosary at the Battle of Lepanto in 1571, Mary only heard the prayers of those where weren’t waging battle, and those are the prayers she communicated to “Jesus,” Who heard and answered them. That’s the only possible way to harmonize the text (unless you’re a Nestorian, Gnostic, Manichaean, Jansenist, Sedevacantist Beneplenist). Canon 1404 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law states that “the First See is judged by no one” — certainly not by Michael Knowles! 🤣

Catholics must, of course, understand the Pope’s meaning in the full context of the deposit of faith. We recall, for instance, that the Church celebrates an annual feast to commemorate God’s hearing the prayers of a pope and saint as he waged war on Muslim invaders at Lepanto.

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 18

Birth Announcement! We've got a new Roman Catholic Denomination! It took him less than 30 seconds of labor: “Everyone has misunderstood this new papal teaching [except me].” whitehorseblog.com/2023/07/1…

EVERY Catholic account to weigh on this new Nostra doc erred either by saying a) it makes a clean/meaningful distinction (ie popesplaining) or b) it coherently/decisively ends the Great Commission (ie rupture) As the past decade's most consistent papal commentator, I explain it below (in 2 parts) **FWIW: it's actually AMAZING what catatonic, cue-card-reading drones we have amongst the American Catholic "influencers"--and what extremes these NPCs w/ teleprompters and mercurial donors oscillate between: they all glazed SSPX from 2018 until 2026 (to which I always objected), and now bizarrely they're all glazing Pope Leo (to which I always objected) These guys are feebleminded beyond expedience. A petty fog that waxes and wanes as the wind redirects

7:51
8:33
Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 6

Some of us believe the apparitions are real. As are the Eucharistic miracles. whitehorseblog.com/2014/04/2…

The doctrine that the Blessed Virgin Mary *was assumed* into heaven is not like the doctrine that Jesus Christ *ascended* visibly into heaven. Verified apparitions of the Blessed Virgin Mary, body and soul, from heaven, have confirmed the truth of her assumption. Protestants deny Marian apparitions just as atheists deny the incarnation of Christ. Unbelievers don't believe. There is no reason for them to do so and arguing, "Duh, dat's not in da Bible." is irrational and proves nothing. No one said it is.

Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 6

Just a reminder that Tim Keller was an eager and willing proponent of this destructive intellectual project. At some point the PCA needs to face and acknowledge that reality. The General Assembly has invested years deliberating overtures of repentance for historical wrongs, both real and imagined. Tolerating Keller for as long as they did is the real kind. trinityfoundation.org/journa…

The Most Destructive Intellectual Project of the Twentieth Century. The Frankfurt School. You should know what it was, what it built, and why you are still living inside it. 1. The Institute for Social Research was founded in Frankfurt in 1923 and relocated to Columbia University in 1934 when Hitler came to power. The civilization they had decided to dismantle gave them refuge when another tried to kill them. They spent the next five decades producing the theoretical infrastructure for that dismantling. Western civilization itself was the problem: reason, the Enlightenment, the family, tradition, authority. Not reformed. Dismantled. 2. They called it Critical Theory – and the name is the program. Everything is to be criticized; nothing is to be built. In The Dialectic of Enlightenment (1944), Adorno and Horkheimer argued that Western reason — the reason that produced Newton and the rule of law — contained the seeds of Auschwitz. Not that reason had been misused, but that reason itself, taken to its conclusion, produces the death camp. This was not a critique of institutions. It was an indictment of the civilization itself. 3. Adorno gave them the psychological weapon. The Authoritarian Personality (1950) classified conservatism, religious faith, patriotism, and the traditional family not as political positions but as symptoms of a proto-fascist personality. If you believe in the nation or the father’s authority, you are pre-fascist. The opponent was no longer wrong – he was sick. You don’t argue with a pathology. You treat it. This made dialogue impossible. You don’t persuade someone who is wrong; you diagnose someone who is sick. Politics becomes therapy, and disagreement becomes pathology. 4. Marcuse gave them the political weapon. Repressive Tolerance (1965) argued that tolerating wrong ideas is itself oppression. True tolerance therefore requires suppressing intolerant ideas. The left decides which ideas are intolerant. Everyone else is silenced – not despite tolerance, but "in its name." Censorship dressed in the vocabulary of liberation. 5. The generation that read Marcuse at Columbia, Berkeley, and Yale went on to run universities, media, foundations, NGOs, content moderation departments, and the EU regulatory apparatus. They implemented the argument sincerely because they had been taught it as philosophy. This was the Frankfurt School’s greatest achievement: it produced true believers. 6. French Theory picked up the tools and made them aesthetic. Foucault made the critique of power literary. Derrida made the critique of meaning philosophical. Deleuze made the critique of identity elegant. A political program became a cultural sensibility. You can argue with a program. A sensibility is in the air you breathe. By the time these ideas reached the American campus through the French conduit, they were no longer ideology. They were the water. The fish did not know they were wet. 7. A civilization stands on three pillars: truth exists and is accessible to reason; good is distinguishable from evil; and there is an inheritance worth transmitting. The Frankfurt School attacked all three – systematically and with considerable intellectual sophistication. It produced a generation that knows how to deconstruct and has forgotten how to build. That sees power everywhere and beauty nowhere. The ultimate achievement was to make destruction feel like progress. Every inherited institution became suspect; every constraint became oppression; every act of preservation became reactionary. Deconstruction became the default, while construction became something that needed to justify itself. The answer is not another theory. It is the thing the Frankfurt School most feared: the builder who simply builds, the scientist who follows the evidence, the father who transmits what was transmitted to him. The deconstruction machine runs on the assumption that nothing is worth building. Prove it wrong. Tell the truth, have courage, and build.

Post attachment
Tim Kauffman avatar
Tim Kauffman@whpub·Sep 4

I love how Michael Knowles tries to own the pRoTs for not having kneelers and altar rails and liturgical vestments for their Eucharistic liturgy (2:00 minute mark). Liturgical vestments don’t show up until the late 4th century. Kneeling was forbidden on Sundays for the first 1000 years, kneelers themselves were obviously introduced later than that, and altar rails are a 16th century counter-reformation novelty. The Protestant liturgy predates the Roman Catholic liturgy by more than a millennium. Thanks to Michael Knowles, now you know. m.youtube.com/shorts/AeXbzUS…