Added point: it's a lot easier to build systems from scratch or from a small, flexible starting point than it is to re-engineer GIANT infrastructure that's already in place, hard to evolve, and inertia-laden. At one point, that giant infrastructure was an advantage for Big CPG. Now it's an enormous burden.
I think AI is a huge net negative for Big CPG.
It *seems* like a positive - streamlined processes, lower headcount, etc.
But the reality is that the speed advantage startups / independents already had over them just got much bigger.
Because startups...
→ are adopting/implementing AI faster
→ lack the bureaucracy that hinders implementation
→ are more incentivized to embrace AI (most folks at Big CPG companies have zero - and often *negative* - incentive to do so)
Thus, in a vacuum, Big CPG will see some ostensible "wins." But on a relative basis, they'll experience a dramatic loss in competitive advantage.
Put simply: you can't AI your way around red tape.
A+ metaphor. CPG is definitely more of a jungle than a racetrack. That said...there are numerous racetracks within our operating model.
All of which we're pouncing on.
A Ferrari is 10X faster than you on a racetrack, but you're infinitely faster than it crossing a jungle. The problem with the fast takeoff crowd in AI is that they think the world is a racetrack, when in fact it's more like a jungle.
Pontificating on whether a newly launched product will succeed is silly.
The product will micro (or macro) pivot 10 times anyway before product-market fit is achieved. And the founder's journey will take 5-10 years.
So the real question is not whether some new product's packaging, positioning, etc. is "on trend" or "smart" or "terrible." The market (not pontificators) will decide that pretty quickly.
It's whether or not the founder has what it takes to iterate into success and endure a long, bumpy road.
The two most important traits of a startup team:
1. Solutions-oriented
2. Creative
Straight-line solution don't cut it over the long haul.
Thinking creatively in a vacuum doesn't either.
You need folks who can find "back door" answers over and over again.
The loudest, most arrogant voices are from those not on the playing field.
Which makes total sense…
There’s no time to be loud when you’re actually playing, and meaningful games are humbling.
Everyone agrees "long term thinking" is better. But how long is long? Given the rate of change today, one year is a really long time. 10 years is an eternity. Didn't use to be that way...but now it is.
It's a useful exercise to re-define "long" for yourself on an annual basis.