←
The Bitcoin Guide895 posts
The Bitcoin Guide avatar

The Bitcoin Guide

@yourbtcguide

Alhamdulillah for Bitcoin Nostr: #npub13nzhjmuhxyxxtxhwc9vxucydw3u5m5ykamnmtvqjqmpw3mt7k48qksfmue

◷ Joined May 2020▧ 84 Photos and videos
Muslim Bitcoiner⚡ avatar
⟳ The Bitcoin Guide retweeted
Muslim Bitcoiner⚡@MBitcoiner·Nov 14

If you were expecting some reward for holding Bitcoin, then you've missed the point. The ability to hold/transfer money, to build new forms of post-state sovereign infrastructure around a fixed supply monetary system, without asking anyone's permission, is already a huge reward.

This bear market is BRUTAL. I’ve never seen so many Bitcoiners so demoralized. We are barely hanging on here. In a time of increasingly capable super intelligence, owning Bitcoin is full of risk and uncertainty, and yet holders haven’t been rewarded at all in a long time.

The Bitcoin Guide avatar
The Bitcoin Guide@yourbtcguide·Nov 13

We cannot be naive and think Bitcoin will succeed JUST because it’s better money. Bitcoin will only succeed if Allah wills it. But we must play our part. Wise words from sheykh @c_hashreview Watch the full closing Q&A from the Muslim Bitcoin Summit on YouTube: youtu.be/e8n5T3h0VqQ?is=Wt4Q…

1:12
The Bitcoin Guide avatar
The Bitcoin Guide@yourbtcguide·Nov 13

The Jummah Majlis Ep 3 is out now! Me and @afreedommachine sat down to take a look back at the events from the week, such as the shenanigans with Jensen Huang, and the bigger picture behind it all: Late stage fiat society converges around artificial “markets”, makes celebrities out of CEOs, and seeks to squeeze every last drop it can from the people. A stark contrast to the markets we see in Islamic history and what is being built out today on open protocols like Nostr youtu.be/9YBSaNZdBXk?is=sKzA…

The Bitcoin Guide avatar
The Bitcoin Guide@yourbtcguide·Nov 11

Did you know that Palestinians are forced to use a version of the Israeli Shekel that nobody else will accept? During the Falasteen and anti-riba money panel at the Muslim Bitcoin Summit, Maher Janajri explains how this evil form of economic repression is used to keep the West Bank in a state of helplessness. The solution is not only to move our economic energy out of this system, but to help the Palestinians build around something different and truly sovereign. Watch the full talk on YouTube: youtu.be/cLi7X1J9SNc?is=JjDG…

1:09
Safdar Alam avatar
⟳ The Bitcoin Guide retweeted
Safdar Alam@SafdarAlam·Nov 9

It is simply astonishing that Muslims can consider using stablecoins USDC and USDT and consider it as advancement. Fiat is riba and slavery but it’s hard to exit it. Clearly. USDC and USDT are arguably even more Riba heavy and Riba aligned - if that is possible - and to use it is entirely a VOLUNTARY choice. This is the extent of our humiliation as Muslims. We voluntarily flock to Riba and exalt the fintechs who do this because their justification is to deliver a return. Every aspect of the above sentence is a direct indictment of the state of financial slavery we voluntarily place ourselves in today.

️️️₿lockchainology avatar
⟳ The Bitcoin Guide retweeted
️️️₿lockchainology@weareblockchain·Nov 8

#Ad | We’re proud to announce that Blockchainology is now an affiliate partner of @FrostsnapTech. Frostsnap makes multisig self-custody simple. Your keys are spread across several devices, so you have no single point of failure. It’s one of the best tools we’ve seen for real Bitcoin sovereignty. 🔑 Use code BLOCKCHAINOLOGY for 10% off the listed price of eligible Frostsnap products. We receive a small commission on purchases made through this code. frostsnap.com

Post attachment
The Bitcoin Guide avatar
The Bitcoin Guide@yourbtcguide·Nov 7

We boycott everything but the money and those who issue it. @MBitcoiner explains how the best way we can help our Palestinian brothers and sisters is to take our economic energy out of the very system which is oppressing them. Watch the full panel discussion, along with all the other talks, on the Bitcoin Majlis YouTube: youtu.be/cLi7X1J9SNc?is=09xJ…

1:09
The Bitcoin Guide avatar
The Bitcoin Guide@yourbtcguide·Nov 6

The Jummah Majlis Ep 2 is out on YouTube now: - The inevitable compromises of Muslims in western politics - Webs of trust as a prerequisite for a truly global economy - The models of leadership in Islamic history - Why Bitcoin is the only option when faced with state backed theft and fraud youtu.be/xEL1D7m3SKM?si=dFaQ…

Muslim Bitcoiner⚡ avatar
⟳ The Bitcoin Guide retweeted
Muslim Bitcoiner⚡@MBitcoiner·Nov 5

Abolishing interest would require abolishing fiat money, a task that modern Muslim institutions are not ready for. The only realistic way to abolish interest is to remove ourselves from the fiat money system as much as possible. Start by running your own bitcoin node.

i need muslims to take over the banks and abolish interest while we're at it.

Bitcoin Majlis avatar
⟳ The Bitcoin Guide retweeted
Bitcoin Majlis@BitcoinMajlis·Nov 5

That's what our movement is about! Actually, we want to take it a few steps further, we want people empowered to not need banks or usurious fiat currencies.

Safdar Alam avatar
⟳ The Bitcoin Guide retweeted
Safdar Alam@SafdarAlam·Nov 4

Thank you brother for your considered comments. In matters of Shariah - I don’t disagree with any of what you say. My position is based on market practice - which is allegedly directly from modern Shariah standards. In fact your position tends to confirm my points. Before I explain, I should clarify something important. I have always been a massive supporter of our Deen with regards to financial matters. Some years ago I delivered a series of webinars (four were originally planned) discussing Hadith (on dates and related matters) and how we can faithfully derive complex requirements for the successful operation of financial markets from them. This series extended to 26 weeks. I have always maintained that scholars in Islamic finance are sincere. This has never been in question. I have written several papers which discuss the diversion of modern Islamic finance from the principles laid out by our Deen. I mention them only to provide context for my position I also believe AAOIFI is generally making sincere attempts to align modern shariah standards to faithful requirements of our Deen. The point is that modern islamic finance operates - In spite of Shariah standards - in a cohesive and observable and repeatable manner. The market delivers interest rate products consistent with the wider debt based economic system in which the Islamic banks operate. The outcomes are observable. 95% of global Islamic finance assets (of around $6 Trillion) are interest based – my own analysis. The balance sheets of Islamic banks are around 95% dominated, both assets and liabilities, by interest rate products whose pricing and behaviour reproduce the conventional banking system. Again my own analysis and this is publicly available. These are products that deliver debt and credit while generating time-priced returns economically equivalent to interest. This is deliberate. I have also written how Islamic banks are 40x more profitable when they deliver debt and lending compared to actually investing in assets. Their actions are entirely rational. Common institutional implementations of commodity Murabaha do not comply with key AAOIFI requirements, including those concerning agency, onward sale and possession. The then Chairman of Dubai Islamic bank’s Sharia Supervisory Board and an AAOIFI Sharia Board member has publicly written about this. His stated position concerned institutional Tawarruq as a prohibited practice. One major attempt by Islamic banks to move away from commodity Murabaha has been Interbank Wakala. The white paper for this product explicitly covers practitioners stating that the return should be known and effectively guaranteed. The scholars say this is impermissible and that this cannot be communicated to the other party as this would contravene Shariah principles. Yet such institutions have Shariah approval from their Shariah board. Often involving Scholars whose institutional memberships often overlap with membership of AAOIFI’s Shariah Board In addition - the Sukuk market operates - again - not in accordance with AAOIFI Shariah standards. The additional resolutions in 2008 relating to Sukuk were not new - they were a clarification and reaffirmation of the existing Sukuk standards - again which the market was ignoring. One of the four books in my series is wholly on Sukuk and covers this in detail. I would be happy to share this book with you if you wish. All Sukuk are presented and certified as Shariah-compliant, despite their economic and contractual defects. Scholars whose membership of AAOIFI often overlap are the ones who then provide Shariah approvals for Sukuk deals that don’t align with these standards. A study at INCEIF examined nearly 900 Malaysian corporate Sukuk issued over 15 years. Only 86 used mudarabah or musharakah risk-sharing structures. None of those 86 was genuinely risk-sharing in substance, and 97% required repurchase at face value. I have personally reviewed dozens of Sukuk prospectuses and found none to be compliant with AAOIFI standards and in fact are clearly in contravention of them. I have found no legal Sukuk documentation containing unqualified issuer representation that the entire Sukuk structure and all transaction documents comply fully with all applicable AAOIFI Shariah Standards. This is market practice. All are signed off by scholars. I have a long youtube video showing precisely how market practice structures these Sukuk. The market prepares its desired and necessary outcome - which is overwhelmingly debt and credit and lending - and then introduces scholars to provide the ratification. This structurally marginalises scholars and leaves them with insufficient institutional power to alter the market’s dominant economic outcomes. Individual interventions may occur, but they have not altered those aggregate outcomes. A more precise way of restating my more sweeping statement that modern islamic finance has made Shariah and scholars irrelevant would be this: the institutional Shariah apparatus has proved incapable of stopping the market’s systematic movement towards riba replication. At the same time, that apparatus continues to approve the structures through which this systemic movement towards Riba replication occurs I personally know scholars who are troubled by this. Who refuse to operate with Islamic banks. Who are trying their best to support change. Who see the ideological capture taking place and wish to reverse it. This is why my base position has been that reform of such a captured modern Islamic banking system is not possible. Because it is operating exactly as planned. What is needed is not better products built inside the same system. What is needed is a direct abandonment of Islamic banking and the opportunity for Shariah and scholars to operate without constraint in the search for faithful financial markets and products. It is my unyielding respect for Shariah and scholars that is the driver of my criticism.

There are legitimate criticisms of Islamic finance institutions, but some important distinctions are being overlooked. Sukuk are not a single financial product. They can be structured through Ijarah, Mudarabah, Musharakah and other contracts, each governed by different Shariah principles. Crucially, we must understand why certain Sukuk were criticised. Much of the criticism concerned capital guarantees in particular investment structures. A fatwa addressing contractual defects prevalent at the time does not automatically apply to every Sukuk, particularly where those defects are absent or the structures have since changed. Three important juristic principles are relevant here: الحكم على الشيء فرع عن تصوره: A ruling requires properly understanding the transaction. We cannot judge all Sukuk as though they share the same structure. الحكم يدور مع علته وجودًا وعدمًا: A ruling follows its underlying legal cause. We must establish whether the defect prompting prohibition exists in other structures. تغيّر الفتوى بتغيّر مناطها: A fatwa may change when the underlying facts upon which it was based change. Furthermore, العبرة في العقود للمقاصد والمعاني لا للألفاظ والمباني establishes that contracts are judged by their substantive realities, not merely their names or outward forms. Economic resemblance to conventional finance does not, by itself, establish that a transaction constitutes riba. That requires examining its actual contractual structure, ownership and liabilities. As for Commodity Murabahah, there are legitimate scholarly objections to organised Tawarruq, but this must be distinguished from other forms of Murabahah and Tawarruq that may be permissible. Similarly, sale and leaseback is not prohibited in every form. Its ruling depends on genuine ownership, the allocation of liabilities, the contractual conditions and any repurchase arrangements. Nor is it accurate to suggest that scholarly criticism achieved nothing. Criticism of certain Sukuk structures contributed to changes in AAOIFI's standards, even if questions remain about implementation across the industry. Criticism is welcome, and the industry's practices are not flawless. However, declaring that Islamic finance has rendered Shariah and its scholars irrelevant is a sweeping conclusion that overlooks these important juristic distinctions.