←
Bill MacLeod1,411 posts
Bill MacLeod avatar

Bill MacLeod

@MacLeodBill

Competition Lawyer; Former ABA Antitrust Chair, FTC Bureau Director, DOJ Antitrust Advisor, CFPB TF Member. Ripon College, UVA, UMLS. Views my own.

◷ Joined March 2012▧ 94 Photos and videos
Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Nov 17

Is anyone else getting tired of calls for thinking anew? If it means forgetting history and rejecting economics, it sounds like a call for Ptolemaic astrophysics to me. Maybe the headline is clickbait, but it’s click-repellent to me.

The @NRO editors: “As Lincoln said, it is a time to think anew and act anew. The GOP desperately needs something fresh and different, with ideas and policies designed to meet the challenges of the day.” nationalreview.com/article/w…

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Nov 17

Isn’t the title redundant? Is there pro-fascist economics? Neutral-fascist economics? I doubt it. But I’m buying this book. I hope it’s the “Road to Serfdom” of our day.

ANTI-FASCIST ECONOMICS is one of the Financial Times’ Best Books of 2026 in economics. So humbled! I wrote this book because I believe economics has a role to play in safeguarding democracy. I couldn’t be happier about this recognition. It gives me hope! Thank you @martinwolf_!

Post attachment
Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Nov 13

A delightful weave of the professor and the judge. I did something similar as Henry Manne’s research assistant. I combed through court decisions and brought him examples (good and bad) of economic reasoning. He used them in his law and economic seminars for judges.

I had many reasons to attend University of Chicago Law School instead of Yale or Harvard Law School, but Richard Posner was a big one, and that influenced my life in a number of ways. I never ended up in a Posner class, but as a 1L sought out work as a research assistant for him, bringing him piles of books he would presumably devour for his inexorable output of academic writing. Sometimes he would even return them to the library, though not often enough that I didn’t almost lose my library card privileges for having dozens of unreturned books. I can take absolutely no credit for any marginal improvement in his academic output; I was surely entirely fungible. I ultimately abandoned my quest to be an academic because I couldn’t be as good as Richard Posner, which is absolutely the wrong standard for deciding whether to be an academic, but definitely the best decision for me. Judge Posner’s and Judge Easterbrook’s writings on class actions had a gigantic influence on my career. Most of the briefs I wrote for the Center for Class Action Fairness were inspired by their jurisprudence and analysis, and were written for their hypothetical audience. It was a deliberate strategy of CCAF to find bad settlements in the district courts of the Seventh Circuit just to have a 25% or so chance of Posner or Easterbrook on appeal. I was exceedingly blessed to get to argue before Posner five times using this strategy, getting five victories, and four excellent Posner opinions that I still regularly cite to this day, some of which are taught to 1Ls. If I ever get back to the Supreme Court, a circuit split with a Judge Posner opinion will likely be a big reason why. RIP.

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Nov 13

Indeed, this is the best review I’ve read of his judicial influence. But I think he was more influential as an academic. Countless students, including many judges, learned law, economics, and antitrust from Richard Posner. I’d wager that legacy outweighed his decisions.

The New York Times has written a fitting and thoughtful obituary of Richard Posner which makes me happy on what is otherwise a sad day (I was one of his clerks).

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Sep 13

Most important issue in history of competitor collaboration? Maybe so, and guidelines alone won’t answer it. Details are key, as is UDAP law. Sherman 1 and FTCA 5 often balance competition and public safety — building codes, vehicle fires, security hazards. Guidelines don’t help close calls. Rules make wrong calls. When the stakes are astronomical, the danger imminent, and both type-1 and type-2 errors potentially catastrophic, the situation calls for an APB to the best specialists in competition and consumer protection.

I think it’s right that a kind of pacing agreement could be done legally. But the devil would be in the details. If the agreement just says “we’re gonna slow our roll for a while,” that’s legally precarious. But if it says “each of us promises to clear these specific safety benchmarks before advancing our models further,” that is much more likely to be okay.

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Jul 25

Indeed, and let’s not overlook the issue, a hot topic now— should we trust capitalism? Remember Friedman’s Free to Choose? It was a bestselling book, a blockbuster series when it aired on PBS, and a devastating critique of Galbraith’s pitch for government-planned economies.

If you haven’t ever seen this, watch it. It is devastating. Thing is, Milton was routinely this devastating in debates. Always with a smile. Only James Q Wison could rival him (in my acquaintance) for extemporaneous fluency.

Sox On 35th avatar
⟳ Bill MacLeod retweeted
Sox On 35th@SoxOn35th·Jun 25

A.J. Pierzynski met Pope Leo XIV and gifted him the final out ball from Game 1 of the 2005 World Series, the game he attended. (via aj_pierzynski_ft • IG)

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Jun 19

Do Economic Experts Matter in Antitrust Courts? Yes, says the Empirical Evidence! Fascinating piece by @Ciliberto, Elzinga and @daniel_sokal. I remember Ken treating us students to a preview of the experience. americanbar.org/groups/antit… Judges “increasingly rely on expert testimony….”

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Apr 9

A half century of economics in a nutshell, this is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand why the dismal science has become esoteric and uninformative. But @BrianCAlbrecht also previews a renaissance. It’s happening in antitrust. I can’t wait to see it spread.

Is price theory dead? Part of @tylercowen's new book argues basically yes. I don't dispute his evidence. But the broader picture highlights the continued relevance of price theory. Not dead yet economicforces.xyz/p/price-t…

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Mar 27

We missed @MeadorFTC at Spring Meeting. His GW speech would have earned an ovation from the worldwide competition bar. @abaantitrust and @FTC have been allies for decades, to the benefit of both. Spring Meeting is the World Cup of competition & consumer expertise. It’s best when all the stars take the field.

With everyone in town for the #ATSpring Meeting, now seems like a good time to point out that the best thing @abaantitrust could do would be some structural separation from @ABAesq. The antitrust bar shouldn’t be subsidizing far left political advocacy.

Mark Meador avatar
⟳ Bill MacLeod retweeted
Mark Meador@MeadorFTC·Mar 25

With everyone in town for the #ATSpring Meeting, now seems like a good time to point out that the best thing @abaantitrust could do would be some structural separation from @ABAesq. The antitrust bar shouldn’t be subsidizing far left political advocacy.

Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Mar 27

Visitors to my fireside chat heard that Ireland and Portugal are leading adopters of AI to detect anticompetitive conduct. New merger regs and guidelines are also on tap. I noted the HSR updates ⁦@FTC⁩ and ⁦@JusticeATR⁩ and endorsed the 2008 (not 2023) Merger Guides.

Post attachment
Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Mar 27

Antitrust enforcers from around the world stress objectivity and economics as key to pro-growth competition policy. Welcome news to the largest audience of antitrust practitioners on earth.

Post attachment
Bill MacLeod avatar
Bill MacLeod@MacLeodBill·Mar 17

A wonderful tribute to Jodie Bernstein, a giant of the FTC and a pathbreaker in the bar. (Fine print - the release doesn’t mention Jodie’s hilarioussense of humor. She still delivers!) Thanks, ⁦⁦@chris_mufarrige⁩ and @FTC⁩! ftc.gov/business-guidance/bl…