Vascular Surgeon, Professor, University of Virginia | Health Law, Policy, Advocacy | Medical Director for Surgeon Engagement, American College of Surgeons
ACS is joining physician organizations in urging Congress to act before year’s end to protect patients’ access to care.
Read the full letter here: brnw.ch/21x750e
Where the money in the fee schedule actually goes.
CMS says the goal is to pay primary care more and lower the cost of care. Follow the dollars and it is doing the opposite.
This week has focused on the problems in the physician fee schedule cuts. Today is about where the money actually goes, because once you track it, the policy makes even less sense. Paying primary care more is a goal we can all get behind. The problem is that budget neutrality means CMS cannot add money. It can only move it. In other words, every primary care raise is funded by a cut somewhere else, and where each half of that transfer lands is the part most haven’t seen.
WHERE THE CUTS COME FROM
Let’s start with total joint replacement. CMS cut the work RVUs on total hip and total knee from 19.11 to 16.70. That is an RVU-level cut. It hits every surgeon who does the procedure whether the independent surgeon through the practice's revenue or the employed surgeon through a comp plan that pays per wRVU. Everyone on the physician side pays in full.
Now let’s look at the modifier 25 cut. Starting in January, an office visit billed with modifier 25 on the same day as a 0-day global procedure is paid at 80%. That is a payment-level cut. The RVUs on the visit do not change. So the independent dermatologist, ENT, or podiatrist bills the claim, collects 80%, and eats the difference on January 1. The employed physician in the same specialty is paid on wRVUs that have not changed. The 20% comes out of what the health system collects. The policy is invisible to the employed physician and fully visible to the independent one. Adding insult to injury, dermatology and podiatry are the least hospital-employed specialties in medicine (under a third by claims data). The cut was aimed, intentional or not, at the specialties where independent practice still lives.
Last year's rule did the same thing with a third lever. CMS cut indirect practice expense RVUs for facility-based services by 50%, roughly 10% off the total RVUs for procedures like TAVR, PCI, and ablation. Practice expense does not flow into a wRVU comp plan either. This means the independent cardiologist or surgeon doing cases at the hospital lost the overhead reimbursement for the billing staff, the malpractice premium, and the credentialing she actually pays for. The employed physician in the next operating room is paid on wRVUs and felt nothing.
We need to ask what each of these does to the physician on the receiving end of the cuts.
The efficiency adjustment cut every proceduralist's wRVUs by 2.5%. The independent surgeon ate it as revenue against fixed overhead. The employed surgeon's health system raised its rate per wRVU and paid him more anyway. The compensation surveys show employed physician pay rising faster than productivity every year. Even the cut that reaches everyone hurts the independent physician more because only employed physicians have someone who stands to make money elsewhere and is therefore willing to backfill the cut.
The facility practice expense cut told the independent proceduralist that Medicare will no longer pay for overhead when they work in a hospital. The hospital, meanwhile, collects a facility fee on every one of the physician’s cases. The obvious move is to sell the practice, drop the overhead, and let the hospital collect both fees.
The modifier 25 cut told the independent dermatologist that same-day care now pays 80% of what it paid last week. The employed counterpart's paycheck did not change. Hospitals and private equity groups will notice the difference and jump on the opportunity.
Every one of these changes teaches physicians that the way to stop losing money to the fee schedule is to stop billing it in your own name. This coming from a government that says it wants to break up consolidated medicine. Meanwhile, it is doing the opposite, one rule at a time, and paying hospitals to finish the job.
WHERE THE GAINS GO
The money from those cuts was supposed to go to primary care, but that’s not the entire story.
More than half of primary care physicians are employed by hospitals or health systems, and most of those are paid on wRVUs. A growing share work for insurers like Optum and CenterWell and are paid off Medicare Advantage capitation, which the fee schedule does not touch at all. Roughly 40% remain in private practice, and they are the only ones who see a fee schedule raise in their own bank account.
For the hospital-employed majority, when CMS raises what an office visit pays, through the conversion factor or through a percentage modifier, the extra dollars show up in the health system's collections. They do not show up as wRVUs, so they do not show up in the physician's paycheck unless the system decides to share their riches.
This year it gets worse. G2211, the visit complexity add-on, was a real line item with 0.33 work RVUs that an employed PCP got credit for on every qualifying visit. In January it becomes modifier B1, a 16% bump with no RVUs of its own. CMS has not even settled whether the 16% applies to the whole visit or only the work component. The fact sheet says one thing and the crosswalk file says another. Most comp plans credit wRVUs by CPT code. A modifier does not impact physician pay. In the end, the employed PCP loses the G2211 credit and the employer collects whatever B1 turns out to pay, which under CMS's own crosswalk reading is less than G2211 on most established-patient visits.
The interesting note is that G2211 was never mostly primary care anyway. In 2024, specialists billed 43% of it, primary care 40%, and fewer than a quarter of eligible clinicians used it at all. The conversion factor took a 2.18% cut that year to fund it, on CMS's assumption that it would go on 38% of visits. It only went on about 11%. Every physician paid for a primary care code that was not mostly primary care and that most primary physicians never billed. That money will never return to the system.
Independent primary care, the only group that would actually see the raise, is a shrinking share of the workforce. The transfer was designed for them and yet mostly misses the group it intended to help.
WHERE THAT LEADS
Put the two halves together. The cuts fall hardest on independent specialists and teach them to sell. The gains are captured mostly by the health systems doing the buying. We are fueling a consolidation engine, and consolidation is the most expensive thing that can happen to Medicare. When a practice is acquired, the same visit in the same room starts generating a facility fee on top of the professional fee, because it is now billed as hospital outpatient. Studies of hospital acquisitions of physician practices consistently find prices rise afterward, and not by a little. MedPAC has spent years documenting the site-of-service differential and asking Congress to fix it. The spending CMS is trying to restrain through budget neutrality on the physician side comes back, larger, on the facility side.
CMS set out to pay primary care more, lower the cost of care, and push back on consolidated medicine. The mechanism it has to work with cuts independent physicians, routes the proceeds to health systems, leaves most primary care physicians no better off, and funds the acquisitions that raise Medicare's total bill. Every stated goal has failed.
I do not think anyone at CMS intended consolidation. I think it is what happens when the only tool the law allows is redistribution inside a fixed pot, and when the people you are trying to help do not bill Medicare in their own name. The fix cannot be a better redistribution formula. There must be an inflationary update for the whole fee schedule so that paying primary care fairly does not require taking it from someone else, and a serious look at who captures the money inside employment. Until then, every fee schedule that claims to help primary care should be read with one question in mind: who actually cashes the check the government writes?
Well, if plans can treat binding federal arbitration awards as optional when they dislike the process or number, then by the same logic physicians who view the latest PFS conversion factor, wRVU, and budget neutrality cuts as systematically unfair should simply balance bill Medicare patients for the amount they feel is fair.
Of course if that happened, we all know how many doctors would be prosecuted vs how many insurers are being prosecuted for not paying arbitration awards.
Unfortunately neither law has a “but the number feels wrong” exception.
.@sarahkliff and I reported recently on how insurers and ERISA plans have stopped paying certain arbitration awards they said were invalid or unreasonable. This piece has some new quotes on that point.
Health care dollars aren't reaching patients- or those caring for them in the clinic, at bedside or in the OR.
Skyrocketing insurance premiums AND out of pocket cost, yet MD practices are closing and shortages growing in primary care and specialties. What's wrong here?🤔
In new research from the Healthcare Quality and Outcomes Lab, we have identified yet another unintended consequence of the No Surprises Act.
The majority (54%) of disputes are now being filed be middlemen and intermediaries.
hsph.harvard.edu/health-qual…
Surgeons and trainees across the Carolinas came together for education, research, and connection at the annual meeting of the North Carolina and South Carolina Chapters of the ACS.
See how ACS chapters are strengthening local surgical communities: brnw.ch/21x69WZ
Vascular surgeons didn’t spend 10+ years training to surrender clinical autonomy to corporatization. Yet as healthcare becomes increasingly consolidated, vascular surgeons have fewer choices in how they practice and less control over the decisions that shape their work.
More than 75 million Americans currently live in a county without a vascular surgeon. And vascular surgery is projected to have the largest physician shortage, meeting just 66% of demand by 2038.
We need to grow the vascular surgery workforce. We also need to make sure the vascular surgeons already in practice can stay there.
That means keeping vascular surgeons at the center of the clinical and operational decisions that shape patient care.
It also means preserving choices in practice setting.
Private practice must remain a viable option. But every day, it is becoming harder to sustain.
Rising costs, declining reimbursement and administrative burden are putting greater pressure on independent practices, while continued consolidation leaves physicians with fewer options.
SVS advocates every day on the payment, regulatory and practice issues affecting vascular surgeons and provides resources to support members in every practice setting.
We know that does not make the current realities of independent practice any easier.
If we want patients to have access to vascular care, we have to make sure vascular surgeons can stay in the workforce, retain clinical autonomy and have viable choices in how they build their careers. That is what SVS will continue working to protect and support.
#VascSurg#PhysicianWorkforce#PrivatePractice#VascularCare@VascularOnline
It was fantastic to see so many familiar faces at the Virginia Surgery Reception during the ACS Clinical Congress in DC! Thanks to the faculty, trainees, and alumni who joined us! #ACSCC2026@AmCollSurgeons
Congratulations and welcome to my new partner Elizabeth Yates, MD- now hailing from Charlottesville, VA! All surgeons are advocates- in this case for sustainability- being conscious of energy efficiency and minimization of waste in clinical operations. @UvaVascular@UVASurgery
None of this addresses the original sin of the RBRVS system.
There is no way to optimize something that is fundamentally flawed.
Could you imagine if lawyers were paid this way? A unit of law is X dollars. Let's call it an RLU (Relative Legal Unit). A group of advisors and economists set the value of the RLU based on time/work, office overhead, geographic location, and other relevant factors.
Criminal defense, tort law, contract disputes, M&A work, etc are all priced out as multiples of the RLU based on perceptions of the factors above. There is a fixed pool of total money. Each specialty has to make the case as to why they deserve a bigger slice of the pie.
It would be absolutely nuts to even consider paying lawyers this way.
I have no idea why we put up with this.
For the 2027 PFS,@CMSGov has proposed a 50% pay cut when procedures are performed the same day as an E/M. We looked at the data: 1,458 procedure codes would be affected across a broad range of specialties.
Part 1 of our analysis below. Part 2 coming soon.
@DonJSelzer@Thomasctsai
A proposed Medicare payment change could affect 1,458 types of procedures across a broad range of office-based specialties.
ACS researchers looked at the data to understand how the proposal could affect surgeons and their patients.
Explore the findings and read the full ACS analysis: utm.guru/usy3K
This article highlights the problem that no one is talking about. Every legislator and regulator in DC wants to discuss the problems getting into a primary care doctor. They couch it as a problem within our payment system that everyone wants to be a specialist because (implied) everyone who enters medicine does so to make the most money possible and specialists tend to make more money.
Dr Pelzman outlines the real problem… specialists are just as difficult to find as primary care doctors. Even with an “inside track” as a physician in a captured system, Dr Pelzman couldn’t even get an appointment for his patient.
Policies like cutting payment by 25% for total joint replacement, paying 50% for the -25 modifier (which lets your orthopedic surgeon inject your knee the day you see them instead of waiting another several months for the follow up), and penalizing physicians who provide services at facilities, all contribute to the specialist shortage.
We have to stop the bleeding and focus on the real problems in healthcare while engaging physicians in finding those solutions
medpagetoday.com/opinion/pat…
On July 14, CMS released the proposed rule for the 2027 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule.
While the SVS Advocacy team thoroughly reviews all components of the proposed rule, you can read it here to see what could change in 2027: ow.ly/5kNU50ZGkPQ#VascSurg#Medicare