←
Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS3,264 posts
Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS avatar

Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS

@dtmcdevitt

They say laughter is the best medicine. Surgery works pretty good, too.

◷ Joined May 2009▧ 40 Photos and videos
Heath Veuleman avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
Heath Veuleman@HeathVeuleman·Apr 29

We can end the velvet cabal of goobers, gomers, and grifters - with the stroke of a pen. No new legislation required. We just need @HHSGov and @CMSGov to act. Here is my 12-point framework organized into three domains. It targets the root drivers of cost inflation, restores physician independence, and redirects savings into competitive, lower-cost delivery models. No new entitlements. Domain 1: Eliminate hospital supplemental revenue streams and excess costs 1. Suspend all supplemental payments to hospitals and health systems. 2. Suspend provider-tax FMAP matches. 3. Implement full site-neutral payments. 4. Suspend technical-component reimbursement for provider-based entities. 5. Suspend reimbursement under the 340B program. 6. Cap allowable costs on hospital cost reports—including executive compensation, private aircraft, meals, entertainment, and marketing (limit to ≤1% of revenue; prohibit sports team and stadium sponsorships). Additional directive language: capitate allowable costs at 105% on annual cost reports, capitate FMAP, and prohibit provider taxes. These changes would recover substantial federal dollars. Site-neutral payment reform alone has documented Medicare savings potential in the tens of billions over a decade. Domain 2: Remove barriers to physician ownership and independent practice 7. Suspend Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute restrictions, along with ACA provisions prohibiting physician ownership of hospitals and other entities with full equity. Permit direct patient negotiation and eliminate FMV requirements that artificially cap physician compensation. 8. Prohibit hospitals, health systems, and institutional providers from imposing non-compete, non-solicitation, non-circumvention, or non-disclosure agreements on licensed independent practitioners. 9. Prohibit health insurers from terminating contracts or restricting members from direct or cash-pay arrangements with physicians. 10. Prohibit hospitals, health systems, and insurers from consolidating services beyond defined utilization thresholds by census tract. Domain 3: Tax-exempt status reform and physician-led rebuilding 11. Impose an annual collection on large non-profit hospital systems plus a one-time 30% tax on their corpus. Many operate with for-profit margins and cash reserves measured in billions while charity care has not scaled proportionally. 12. Redirect all savings and new revenue into tax credits and guaranteed debt facilities (modeled on existing USDA, SBA, and HUD programs) to enable physicians to develop independent practices, surgery centers, and hospitals. This is not incrementalism. It directly reverses decades of consolidation that increased prices without commensurate quality gains. Of course, it’s a fever dream - until someone acts. The healthcare cartel, and their Consigliere’s and capo’s, have created a market so artificial that the buyer and seller - the two principals to the transaction - are the very individuals suffering in every single transaction. Health systems and insurance companies (and their lobbies) will oppose it aggressively, but the current trajectory is indefensible.

Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Nov 13

Fix It Friday: how Congress can engage on the 2027 fee schedule CMS has made its changes and now it is time for Congress to weigh in. Government funding runs out December 11 so Congress has a short window to coalesce around solutions to attach to a likely Continuing Resolution end of year bill. 1. Pass an inflationary update. The Patients First Act is the vehicle. The medical association ask is to extend the 2.5% update through 2027, but a one-year extension of a one-year patch is how we got here in the first place. The 2026 update expired, so we started in a 2.5% hold, and the statutory 0.25% update does nothing against practice costs CMS projects to grow about 2.5%. Physicians are the only Medicare provider type with no annual update tied to their actual costs. Hospitals have one. Skilled nursing facilities have one. Home health has one. Physicians have a budgetary number that is a political hot potato. H.R. 9693, the Patients First Act, introduced by Reps. John Joyce, MD, Greg Murphy, MD, and Kim Schrier, MD, (the Republican and Democrat chairs of their respective doctors caucuses) with 65 bipartisan cosponsors as of mid-October and a House Energy and Commerce Health Subcommittee hearing, fixes that. It ties the annual update to the Medicare Economic Index minus one point, with MEI minus half a point for advanced APM participants, builds it into the baseline, and limits year-to-year swings. That is the only proposal on the table that grows the pie instead of re-slicing it, and it is the most direct response to everything the issues raised this week. Inflationary updates prevent us from having to constantly rob Peter (specialists) to pay Paul (primary care). This fix won’t be cheap. The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget has estimated MEI indexing at roughly $65 billion over ten years relative to current law. I believe the number will come back substantially higher from the CBO. 2. Block the modifier 25 cut in statute and exempt the fix from budget neutrality. MGMA has asked Congress to fix modifier 25 alongside the conversion factor. They have asked Congress to prohibit CMS from applying a payment reduction to a separately identifiable E/M service billed with modifier 25 for 2027, and direct CMS to collect observed intra-visit time and cost data before revisiting the question. That being said, if Congress blocks the cut without exempting the change from budget neutrality, CMS simply lowers the conversion factor to recover the money. 3. Keep sequestration off the table. The 2% Budget Control Act sequester has reduced every Medicare payment since 2013, but Congress has been diligent in extending it every year. Then there is statutory PAYGO. Last November Congress wiped the PAYGO scorecard that the 2025 reconciliation law had loaded with roughly $3.4 trillion in deficits, which is the only reason a 4% Medicare sequester did not happen in January 2026. Any year-end package that spends money, on physicians or anything else, will trigger PAYGO. The package must carry its own PAYGO waiver. 4. Raise and index the budget neutrality threshold. Earlier this week, we looked at how good CMS decisions can produce a worse conversion factor, which is a function of a $20 million threshold that has not changed since 1992. H.R. 8163, the Provider Reimbursement Stability Act, passed the House Ways and Means Committee on May 21. Its Senate companion, S. 5180 (Boozman, Welch, Marshall, King, Tillis, Shaheen), has similar language, and the Patients First Act incorporates the changes. The bill raises the threshold into the mid-$50 million range, indexes it to MEI every five years, requires CMS to correct utilization estimates that prove wrong, and puts practice expense data on a regular update schedule. 5. Put guardrails on how CMS values codes. This year CMS proposed to override a RUC survey value for the two highest-volume procedures in orthopaedics with a crosswalk to unrelated codes, then reversed based on overwhelming response from the physician community. Last year it applied a 2.5% efficiency adjustment to thousands of codes using a productivity proxy. Congress should require that any CMS departure from a survey-based work value be supported by published, observed time data, and that any proposed revaluation above a defined threshold come with a specialty-level impact analysis in the proposed rule, not the final one. The statute already phases in RVU cuts of 20% or more over two years. Lowering that trigger would end the whole-number cliffs that hit joint replacement two years in a row. 6. Require evidence before service-line cuts. The same-day 25 modifier policy is propped up on a theory of duplicate payment that CMS never quantified against its own practice of removing overlap time during valuation. The Patients First Act requires notice and comment before CMS introduces or changes a mandatory payment model. I would extend that concept to other aspects of payment. Before CMS reduces payment for a service on the ground that it duplicates another, it should have to publish the evidence of duplication and the specialty-level effect, and give the public a full comment cycle. 7. Fix the data problem. CMS's argument on both modifier 25 and practice expense is that the data is old. Congress should direct and pay for independent, observed collection of practice cost and physician time across independent practices, not only hospital-affiliated ones, so the next revaluation is argued over facts rather than crosswalks and theories. CMS cannot build an accurate fee schedule on 2007 surveys and claims data, but it should not be allowed to build one on assumptions either.

Post attachment
Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS avatar
Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS@dtmcdevitt·Nov 12

Elections have consequences. We are going to get Medicare for All. The political momentum is too great at this point. I think it is a huge mistake, but we are past that now. The ACA has not delivered anything that was promised. It was never going to. It was merely a steppingstone on the way to single payer. The notion that we would somehow return to a free market or some sort of hybrid/catastrophic coverage, or anything less than single payer, is essentially a forlorn hope. Physicians have spent the last 3 decades aggressively complying with every health care economic scheme. There is no reason to believe that there will be substantial resistance at this point. A lot of bluster perhaps, and quiet quitting, but that will be the extent of it. Most medical societies will develop extensive education programs for their members to help them learn to comply. The general public will be ecstatic over the first few years as it will seem like everything it's cracked up to be. But then the controls will kick in and it will be like any other government program: hurry up and wait coupled with limited benefits. Whatever the final form is going to look like, we are going to be stuck with it. Best wishes to all of us.

John Shields, MD, FAAOS avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
John Shields, MD, FAAOS@jointdocShields·Nov 7

Great quote from David Lewallen at @AAHKS annual meeting: 2000 years ago you got your name in the bible if you raised the cripple and made them walk. Now you get your reimbursement cut because you are doing too many of them.

Megan Tracci avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
Megan Tracci@MeganTracci·Nov 6

Health care dollars aren't reaching patients- or those caring for them in the clinic, at bedside or in the OR. Skyrocketing insurance premiums AND out of pocket cost, yet MD practices are closing and shortages growing in primary care and specialties. What's wrong here?🤔

In new research from the Healthcare Quality and Outcomes Lab, we have identified yet another unintended consequence of the No Surprises Act. The majority (54%) of disputes are now being filed be middlemen and intermediaries. hsph.harvard.edu/health-qual…

Krzysztof Szczawinski 🇵🇱 avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
Krzysztof Szczawinski 🇵🇱@Kristof_Poland·Oct 13

Why the Virtuous Majority Keeps Losing. Most people are decent. They work, raise their children, pay their taxes, and don’t lie more than they have to. And yet, again and again, the country is run against them. How? Turns out the mechanism has a name: Olson’s logic of collective action. An economist named Mancur Olson worked it out in 1965. The idea is simple. Imagine a subsidy worth millions to a small group of companies. It costs every taxpayer the price of a coffee. Who will organize? The few, for whom it is worth millions – they will hire lobbyists, fund campaigns, show up at every meeting. The many, each losing the price of a coffee, will do nothing. Nobody marches for the price of a coffee. Concentrated gains organize. Dispersed losses sleep. Add the free rider: in a large group, everyone hopes someone else will do the work. So nobody does. That is why the small organized minority beats the large disorganized majority, almost every time. Not because it is right. Because it shows up. Now look around. The grant-funded NGO, the bureaucracy defending its budget, the activist network with full-time staff, the lobby with an office next to the ministry. Each has a lot to gain from one more rule, one more program, one more subsidy. The families paying for it each lose a little – and they are busy raising children. Vice organizes itself, because vice pays its organizers. Virtue has to be organized, because its rewards are spread across everyone. Olson saw the long-run consequence too. In a second book he argued that stable nations slowly fill up with these organized interests, each defending its slice – until the whole country stiffens and growth stalls. Germany and Japan boomed after the war partly because defeat had swept the old coalitions away. So what do we do? Olson’s own logic gives the answer. Make the dispersed costs visible. The coffee nobody notices becomes a bill everyone can read. That is what telling the truth does. Give the virtuous a reason to show up beyond duty: friendship, community, careers, joy. Movements that last give their members something to belong to. And remember that the majority never needs to organize all at once. A committed minority is enough to start – the long march proved it. The rest follow once they see they are not alone. And it needs structure. That is what the network of patriots across Western Civilization – and the Council of Western Civilization at its center – are for. Not to give orders. To show the direction, so the energy is not scattered. To give the vocabulary, so people can name what is being done to them. And to coordinate, so no one fights alone. Olson’s lesson in one line: the organized few beat the disorganized many. So become the organized many. And here is the good news. Olson wrote in 1965, when organizing cost meetings, letters, money and years. Today it costs a post. The math that kept the decent majority asleep is changing. The majority does not win by being right. It wins by showing up – together.

Post attachment

We live in an age of complex systems. Civilization is human nature, multiplied by institutions. Every human trait, every emotion, every vice gets scaled into its systemic, civilizational expression. Envy – socialism. If I can’t have it, nobody should. Pride – central planning. The planner never pays for his plan. Wrath – cancel culture. The desire not merely to defeat an opponent, but to destroy him. Sloth – dependency by design. A system that makes idleness safer than effort eventually gets more idleness. Greed – crony capitalism. Private gains, public losses. Gluttony – debt. Consuming today what belongs to your children. Lust – pleasure without consequence, and the empty cradle. Deceit – propaganda and managed reality: the Systemic Lie. A lie told to one person is a sin; told to millions, it becomes a system. Love of power – bureaucracy. Every agency finds a reason to grow, and every procedure exists so that nobody can be blamed. Fear – the compliant society. Nothing may be tried until it is proven harmless, so nothing new is tried. The precautionary principle would have banned fire. Vanity – virtue signaling. Beliefs worn like jewelry. Conformity – groupthink. When everyone must agree, collective stupidity masquerades as consensus. Ignorance – cults and sects. Whoever knows nothing will believe anything. Resentment – revolutionary politics. The desire not merely to rise, but to bring down those who have risen higher. Cowardice – institutional silence. Everyone sees the problem. Nobody wants to be the first to name it. Distrust – surveillance and control. When people no longer trust one another, they demand a system to watch everyone. Guilt – a civilization ashamed of itself. The heir taught to despise his inheritance. And the virtues: Courage – free speech. Every right we have was first defended by someone who was afraid and spoke anyway. Curiosity – science. The willingness to ask questions that might destroy what we think we know. Ambition – meritocracy, or its corruption. Properly directed, ambition builds civilizations. Under the wrong incentives, it builds careers at civilization’s expense. Honesty – trust, and markets that work. Where a handshake holds, a contract is cheap. Shame – manners and honor. The rules nobody needs to write down. A people that loses its sense of shame needs a law for everything. Responsibility – the market and the courts. Whoever decides should bear the consequences. Patience – savings, cathedrals, families. Every cathedral was begun by people who knew they would never see it finished. Hope – investment and children. Both are bets on tomorrow. Gratitude – transmission. The willingness to receive an inheritance, preserve it and pass it on. Perseverance – institutions that outlast their founders. The ability to keep building long after the original enthusiasm has faded. Wisdom – constitutional limits. The recognition that no individual, however brilliant, should be trusted with unlimited power. Joy – the feast, the festival, the laugh. A regime that can’t take a joke can’t take the truth. Love of the particular – family and nation. Universal principles do not require us to abandon particular loyalties. And two principles that determine whether a civilization survives: Envy versus gratitude – Does a society teach its children to resent what others have, or to build upon what previous generations gave them? Irresponsibility versus stewardship – Does a generation consume its inheritance, or pass on something greater? Not merely personal virtues, but what determines whether a civilization can transmit its achievements across generations. A system is a human trait, multiplied by millions – and given a budget. And now a new multiplier is arriving: AI. Whatever a system rewards, AI can reward faster, across more decisions, at a scale previously unimaginable, everywhere, at once. Build a model that flatters, and it will flatter billions. Build one that suppresses inconvenient truths, and censorship can become automatic. Build one that seeks the truth, and truth will scale like never before. The technology is a multiplier. The incentives determine what gets multiplied. And the stakes go beyond the present generation. The decisive question about AI is not how intelligent we make it. It is which human nature we encode into the systems that will shape the next generation. That is why systems matter so much. The question is no longer only "is this person good?" It is "which of our traits does this system reward and multiply?" A civilization is made of what it rewards, what it punishes, and how. Millions of daily decisions – who gets hired, who gets promoted, who gets heard, who gets silenced – accumulating into a system that works, or doesn’t. That lives and thrives, or dies. Show me what a system rewards, and I will tell you what it will turn its people into. And the expression of traits into systems requires structures. So even if the virtuous traits are the majority, if they are not active and organized, then the vicious ones will prevail. Vice organizes itself. Virtue has to be organized. So do not be passive. Tell the truth. Have courage. And build.

Dutch Rojas avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
Dutch Rojas@DutchRojas·Oct 5

Secretary Kennedy, the cheaper operating room in Massachusetts requires the expensive hospital’s permission to open. That belongs in the speech. The Boston joint replacement gap is real. Blue Cross reported commercial claims prices ranging from $17,910 to $73,987 in the Boston market in 2015. More than a decade later, the spread is being presented as a revelation. Look at who gets permission to compete. In 2008, Massachusetts removed the exemption that let physician-owned surgery centers open without Determination of Need approval. The state’s own Health Policy Commission calls what followed an effective moratorium on new ASCs. In 2017, the state lifted it with conditions. New centers needed an affiliation with a certified accountable care organization. A center in an independent hospital’s primary service area needed that hospital’s approval. The commission’s conclusion: the requirements effectively gave hospitals approval power over most new surgery centers. The incumbent gets a say in whether its competitor opens. In the commission’s 2023 data, Boston had one ASC. Then there is the payment system you oversee. Medicare still pays hospitals more for many services that can safely be performed in independent offices or surgery centers. CMS has narrowed some of that gap. In 2026, it expanded site-neutral payment to drug administration at certain off-campus hospital departments and expanded the ASC covered-procedure list. It has proposed adding imaging without contrast at those departments for 2027. Good. Keep going! A hospital billing address is not better care. Paying extra for it grants an advantage before anyone compares outcomes. That policy does not establish what caused the Blue Cross spread. It does expose the contradiction: Washington condemns the expensive setting while still paying a premium to use it. The insurance finding is separate. Trinity College reported that economist Gerardo Ruiz Sánchez found 60 percent of the negotiated rates he studied exceeded the hospital’s own cash price. Patients pay premiums expecting bargaining power. They deserve to know when the hospital’s cash offer was better. Publishing the price is not the same as being allowed to take it. If a plan shows the cheaper option and then makes choosing it cost more out of pocket, it has built a museum of affordable care. Please enjoy the prices without touching the savings. For scheduled care, the buyer needs an offer that can be accepted: a defined episode, a named physician and facility, meaningful quality information, and a price agreed before treatment. The benefit design has to let the employer and the patient to keep the difference. The competitor has to be allowed to open. Markets cannot discipline prices they cannot see. They also cannot discipline a hospital whose competitors need permission to open. Publish the prices. Stop protecting them. @SecKennedy @DrOzCMS @CMSGov @HHSGov @GOPDoctors @GOPHELP @WaysandMeansGOP

1:15
Dutch Rojas avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
Dutch Rojas@DutchRojas·Sep 18

A physician wants to own the facility where she operates. Suddenly, everyone discovers financial incentives. The hospital wants to own the facility, employ the physician, and collect the revenue. Apparently, ethics improves when you add a boss.

AtlasMD avatar
⟳ Daniel McDevitt MD FACS FSVS retweeted
AtlasMD@AtlasMD·Sep 16

$37,824 for a family of four. Milliman’s 2026 Medical Index. Average person hit $8,460 — up 7.9%, the biggest climb in over a decade outside COVID. Pharmacy alone jumped 14.8%. Outpatient facility care is about a third of the bill and has quadrupled for that family since 2005. That’s not a benefit. That’s a second mortgage with copays. We take care of patients for a flat monthly fee. No claim. No network. The number on the door is the number you pay. milliman.com/en/insight/2026…