←
Merlyn Thomas4,805 posts
Merlyn Thomas avatar

Merlyn Thomas

@MerlynThomas

BBC Verify correspondent / @BBCNews merlyn.thomas@bbc.co.uk Signal merlynthomas.23

◷ Joined July 2011▧ 147 Photos and videos
Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

NEW: Hundreds of Israeli military investigations into killings without public outcome, BBC Verify finds. Some of the cases are nearly three years old. One of the deadliest reportedly killed at least 93 people, including 6 women and 11 children. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c574…

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Nov 17

Ukraine accused Russia of targeting rescuers after a double-tap strike killed 72 people - one of the deadliest attacks in nearly 5 years of war. @profbensaul said this appears to be a deliberate or indiscriminate attack - either would be a war crime. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c30r…

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 16

Hundreds of IDF investigations into killings. But still no public outcomes, years on. Here’s how we investigated how the Israeli military investigates itself. Watch the full BBC Verify doc on YouTube now. youtu.be/QEKOyOMGrwI?is=qsoC…

1:29
Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

We put each of the 254 incidents to the IDF multiple times - but only received information on 2 incidents: One in which 2 women were killed in Gaza in Dec 2023, and the other in which nearly 100 people were reportedly killed. The IDF said both are still under review.

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

Former top lawyer for the IDF and director Eran Shamir-Borer @IDIsrael said there are “genuine challenges" investigating allegations in complex combat environments in "a territory which is hostile... Lots of forces on the ground, many of them executing fire”.

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

@JaninaDill said "Israel has relied heavily on the argument that it is a rule-of-law country to delegitimatise attempts by the international community to investigate".

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

Dan Owen from @Yesh_Din which has been tracking military investigations since 2006 - said he believes the IDF will often try to “prolong” investigations. "They try to stretch out these processes to the point where people forget and people don't care about them," he said.

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

The @ICRC guidelines say investigations into potential violations of international humanitarian law, whether criminal or otherwise, should be: - prompt - thorough - impartial - and as transparent as possible.

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

I asked the IDF about each case multiple times but only received info on 2 cases - which it said were still under review. "The IDF takes every allegation or report raising concerns about conduct that may be inconsistent with the law or IDF directives with the utmost seriousness"

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

Following extensive manual checking of each incident, we found 300 cases that the military said it was looking into, only 28 of which had outcomes published on the IDF website. For a further 18 incidents it was unclear if the investigation has been concluded.

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

So at BBC Verify, we developed a custom AI model to scan thousands of news articles dating back to the start of the war in Gaza. That helped us comb through thousands of news report and examine hundreds of incidents We then manually checked every single one of them.

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

For three years, the Israeli military has often responded to accusations of harm by saying it’s investigating in some form. Often, that is the last we hear. I wanted to find out just how many investigations there were and what happened to them?

Merlyn Thomas avatar
Merlyn Thomas@MerlynThomas·Oct 15

WATCH: Hundreds of Israeli military investigations into killings in Gaza, Lebanon, the occupied West Bank and Israel still have no public outcome, BBC Verify finds instagram.com/p/DegLDAHEieb/

1:40

NEW: Hundreds of Israeli military investigations into killings without public outcome, BBC Verify finds. Some of the cases are nearly three years old. One of the deadliest reportedly killed at least 93 people, including 6 women and 11 children. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c574…

Bianca Britton avatar
⟳ Merlyn Thomas retweeted
Bianca Britton@biancabritton·Sep 17

UN investigators say there are "reasonable grounds" the US committed war crimes in strikes in Minab and Lamerd, citing BBC Verify, NYT and Reuters reporting. The report also says Iran's crackdown on protesters in January amount to crimes against humanity. ohchr.org/en/press-releases/…