Classical realism is the remedy for our disordered world. Mostly notes to self. I support the @realistguild - if we follow each other, I've likely DM'd you.
This man believed he was killing a stranger with electric shocks. He kept pressing the switches after the screaming stopped, all the way to 450 volts.
Nobody died. The shocks were fake and the screams came from an actor. It was 1961, and a Yale professor wanted to know how ordinary people ended up helping the Nazis.
Adolf Eichmann had just gone on trial in Jerusalem. His defense was simple. He was only following orders.
Stanley Milgram wanted to test that. He put an ad in the paper for a memory study and paid volunteers to come to his lab.
Each volunteer became a "teacher." In the next room a man was strapped to a chair. Every time he got a word wrong, the teacher had to give him a shock, 15 volts stronger than the last.
The switches went up to 450. The labels near the top said "Danger: Severe Shock."
Before they started, the man in the chair mentioned he had a heart condition.
The scientist in the grey coat never threatened anyone. He had four sentences. "Please continue." "The experiment requires that you continue." "It is absolutely essential that you continue." "You have no other choice, you must go on."
Watch the man in this video. Earlier in the session he says it out loud. "I'm not gonna kill that man."
At 330 volts the man next door screams that his heart is bothering him. The teacher asks who's responsible if something happens. He's told to continue, and he does.
At 375 the screaming stops. He says something has happened in there. Then he presses 390.
Before the study, Milgram asked 40 psychiatrists how many people would go all the way. They guessed about one in a thousand.
26 out of 40 did. Every single one went past 300 volts.
None of them had ever met a Nazi. A polite man in a lab coat told them to go on.
The same instinct that made these men keep pressing is what makes armies, hospitals and whole countries function. Is obedience humanity's biggest flaw, or the thing holding everything together?
This principle is an antidote to the epistemic chaos we see around us. Since theology, metaphysics, and science all aim at understanding the same objective reality, their true results must agree with one another. Any disagreement is a sign of error in one or more of them.
Theology, metaphysics and science is one, that is, they agree.
If not, there is error.
As modern man rejected theology and ignored metaphysics, while he undertook the quest for science, he got very confused.
It is the tale of learning to stand before walking. Or fall.
Theology, metaphysics and science is one, that is, they agree.
If not, there is error.
As modern man rejected theology and ignored metaphysics, while he undertook the quest for science, he got very confused.
It is the tale of learning to stand before walking. Or fall.
X6 The problem of the moral corruption of the individual is that:
1. It is inseparable from freedom.
2. Many easy ways lead to Hell.
3. Only one path leads to Heaven via the Truth, and it is most unpleasant.
4. It gets harder and harder to go back once you let yourself slide.
Lying to yourself is thus the fastest and surest way to misery and suffering.
Look at those who lied to themselves and tacitly approved things they disagreed with when free speech was under attack. Their faces are tired, angry, and anxious. Their lives feel heavy, even when they have everything you can dream of, like a family, a nice house, land, a prestigious job, etc. They just lack the lightness and elegance of the innocents, and the peace of the righteous.
They have only one way out.
“Thence issuing we again beheld the stars” (illustration for Dante’s Inferno, Canto XXXIV, c. 1860s) by G. Doré
Moral progress requires a standard beyond current opinion. Otherwise, saying a society has improved would amount only to saying its preferences have changed.
Do you know s/o who believes that truth & goodness are objective, both are intelligible, human beings have a nature, ends and limits & reality is ordered?
If so, please ask them to subscribe to us on YouTube & Substack!
youtube.com/@RealistGuildsubstack.com/@realistguild
Aquinas on How to Guide Sons and Daughters Toward Maturity
A child is born with a rational soul, but the powers of reason and will are not yet strong enough to guide action. Your task is to form the child’s habits so that they are able to reason properly, make the right judgements, and possess a will that consistently chooses what is good. This is the work of years, and it follows a real structure.
Human life is ordered by a real hierarchy of ends. The eternal good must shape all other choices. Formation cannot succeed unless each act is taught as part of a greater purpose.
In the early stage of life, the child learns through physical consequences and repetition. Deliberation has not yet begun at this stage. The child must be governed from the outside with consistency and clarity. Consistent reward strengthens good habits. Faults must be corrected before they take root. At this stage, the formation of habit is more important than giving explanations.
As the child matures, practical reason begins to influence action. The child starts to make connections between rules, actions, and outcomes. It is at this point when instruction becomes possible. You as a parent must explain why certain actions preserve peace, why others bring harm, and how the ordering of behaviour builds strength. Lying, selfishness, and laziness must be addressed firmly and directly - and explained properly. If this is ignored, these faults will harden into vice.
True formation requires the acquisition of virtues: prudence to guide decisions, justice to give each their due, fortitude to persevere in difficulty, and temperance to restrain desire. These are habits of excellence that perfect the soul’s powers.
Many girls develop receptivity and verbal clarity in early adolescence, which allows for early instruction in modesty, discipline, and judgement. They are best guided by stable expectations and clear boundaries that strengthen constancy and discourage self-pity. Modesty, clarity, and interior calm provide the ground for their strength. With steady guidance, many develop good judgement by their mid-teens.
Boys are often more strongly drawn by the passions of pleasure and conquest, which require greater discipline to bring under reason. Their passions often overpower early judgement, and they test boundaries to measure their rapidly increasing physical strength. They need clear expectations, difficult tasks, and consistent follow-through. Training the appetite to submit to reason requires structure and visible consequences. A boy matures when he begins to act on behalf of others without being asked, and when he works without complaint.
The passions are not enemies of reason, but instruments to be ordered. Anger must serve justice. Desire must follow reason. You must teach their children not to suppress emotion, but to govern it toward right ends.
Between sixteen and early adulthood, the child begins making serious choices that reveal whether earlier formation has taken root. These years test how well you have done so far; whether stable habits have been formed or whether behaviour was shaped only by supervision. What the child believes, how they use time, what they seek in relationships, and how they respond to hardship all begin to reveal the structure of the soul.
At this stage, you no longer give orders but offer judgement instead. Your role becomes quieter, but no less important. Speech should now appeal to the child’s reason. You should present the truth clearly, explain how choices produce consequences, and remain consistent in witness. This stage often includes sharp disagreements, but you should not retreat into flattery or fear. The child still watches carefully. If your judgments are firm and intelligible, the memory of them often settles long after the argument has passed.
Several difficulties tend to appear during this time. Some teens reject moral teaching, especially when it conflicts with desire. Others become immersed in friendships or romantic relationships that weaken their judgment. Some withdraw from working hard, neglecting duty and retreating into comfort or distraction. Others act with arrogance, refuse correction, or resist authority altogether. Each of these disorders has a distinct cause - some arise from pride, others from sloth, others from lust or fear - and each must be addressed according to its nature.
The character of friendships during this time is crucial. A friendship grounded in virtue strengthens judgment. One grounded in shared distraction or rebellion disfigures it. You must help the child see which is which.
When sexual desire becomes disordered - whether through pornography, secret relationships, or sin - you must act without confusion. Aquinas teaches that no appetite clouds judgment more quickly or severely than lust, especially when the will has not been strengthened by discipline. Pornography disfigures the imagination and weakens the memory, making prudent choice almost impossible. You must speak plainly, without fear or shame, and name both the nature of the act and its effects. The child must understand that sexual power was made for procreation and permanent union - not pleasure alone - and that detaching it from its end leads to confusion, addiction, and despair.
This does not require cruelty. It requires clarity, consistency, and removal from situations that distort reason. Begin the conversation before temptation gains strength. Call the child to real discipline. Set visible limits. Offer interior structure. Do not moralize with vague warnings - speak from the truth of what sex is for, and how the will is shaped by every act.
The body must be formed with the same care as the will. The child’s language, dress, posture, and use of music or media are not superficial matters - they shape the soul’s disposition toward order or disorder.
A teenager in mortal sin cannot be expected to think clearly. The first step is always separation from near occasion, followed by the restoration of order in thought and affection. The appetite must be re-trained by discipline, the will restored by small acts of obedience, and the intellect reoriented toward a true end.
In all these cases, you must judge without anger or hatred, speak without flattery, and remain stable in expectation. The response must never be vague. Disorder is not healed by encouragement alone, but by the reordering of action under truth.
When there is pride, correct the false measure. Remind the child that all true greatness comes from serving what is higher than self. When there is despair, re-establish hope by pointing to what remains possible, worth doing, and why. When there is confusion, restore clarity by naming the good and showing how right action begins with right understanding.
All disorder must be judged by whether it directs the soul away from its final end. Your task is not just to prevent harm, but to help the child conform action to right reason, so that they can freely choose the good themselves.
No disorder should be ignored, but none should be treated with force once the will is fully active. Persuasion, witness, and steady moral gravity do more at this stage than repeated warnings or correction.
This is also the time when the child begins to seek love, work, and direction. These choices matter, because they shape the structure of adult life. You must prepare the child to evaluate suitors, discern friendships, and understand what authority demands in the world of work.
The choice of work is not only practical - it is a moral act. A career must be chosen in light of the end: to live justly, serve others, and order one’s powers in a way that supports a life of virtue. A job is not only for provision, but for formation.
According to Aquinas, young men must be formed to carry outward responsibility - to provide, to defend, to speak clearly, and to act when others hesitate. Young women must be formed to govern interior life - to guard affection, to order relationships, and to give form to what is entrusted to them. This difference reflects the deeper structure of nature: the man initiates and bears weight; the woman integrates and gives form.
Though their formation differs, both are directed toward the same perfection: to act freely under reason, and to live in harmony with what is true and just.
The child becomes an adult when they accept responsibility as a normal part of life. They show maturity when they work without complaint, speak truthfully when it is difficult, and accept correction without collapsing. They become truly free when they govern their own actions with stability, even when tired, tempted, or alone.
Aquinas teaches that law has reached its goal when the soul orders itself without external compulsion. In this final stage of formation, you stand back -but not away. You no longer command, but still teach by example. Although your voice may fall silent, your judgement remains present. The child no longer obeys, but continues to honour. And that honour keeps the structure intact.
Freedom appears when the soul acts without being compelled and still chooses what is right. A child has reached maturity when he or she is able to carry responsibility, endure difficulty, speak truthfully, and serve others without needing praise or supervision.
The soul was made not only for action, but for contemplation. You must prepare the child to desire silence, to behold what is true, and to see that rest in truth is the highest fulfilment of the rational nature.
The goal of parenting is to prepare a person who chooses the good freely. That's what Aquinas calls the work of law: to lead a being with reason toward its proper end. That end is ordered action under reason, in harmony with the eternal law.
______
Thank you to @mapp_john14664 for suggesting this topic. If you have any other specific family topic you would like me to cover according to Aquinas, please let me know in the comments.
The Realist Guild is now on Facebook!
Thank you to @AmosKissel and, indeed, all our members for continuing to push the boundaries and help raise awareness of what we're doing.
Link here: facebook.com/groups/12123465…
Invites are out for this week's Realist Guild meeting.
Early & late sessions are available.
The agenda can be found on our Discord server.
See you there!
And suddenly the other side does not care about it?
It is always fascinating how in our nihilistic culture the only thing we like to moralize about is hypocrisy!
Sverige har lyckats med något historiskt. På bara några år har vi förvandlat ett land med nästan gratis, stabil el till ett land där folk får ångest varje gång de öppnar sin elräkning. Det är en bedrift som få länder matchar.
Förklaringen är enkel och elegant: de rödgröna stängde kärnkraftverk som producerade el dygnet runt, året om, och ersatte dem med vindkraftverk som producerar el när det blåser lagom mycket. När det inte blåser importerar vi istället el från kolkraftverk i Tyskland eller gas från länder vi helst inte vill nämna. Resultatet? Rekordhöga priser i södra Sverige och politiker som förklarar att det här är precis så det var tänkt.
När elräkningen landar på 12 000 kronor i januari får man höra att det är Putins fel. Eller klimatets. Eller marknadens. Aldrig att det kan ha något att göra med att man medvetet monterat ner den enda energikälla som faktiskt levererar planerbar el i stor skala.
Nej, lösningen är mer av samma: fler vindkraftverk till havs, fler solpaneler som inte ger något i december, och fler utredningar om hur man ska kompensera hushållen för den politik man just genomfört.
Samtidigt exporterar Sverige el till kontinenten när det blåser bra, för att sedan köpa tillbaka dyr el när det är kallt och vindstilla. Det kallas ”europeisk solidaritet”. Svenska villaägare kallar det något annat när de sitter i mörkret med vinterjackan på och funderar på om det är värt att sätta på ugnen.
Det vackraste är ändå retoriken. Man talar om ”grön omställning” medan elpriset gör att folk tvingas elda med ved eller stänga av elementen. Man talar om ”framtidens energi” medan industrierna hotar att flytta. Och när någon påpekar att Norge och Finland har lägre priser tack vare mer kärnkraft, blir svaret att Sverige är mer progressivt.
Så nästa gång elräkningen kommer: tänk inte på den stängda reaktorn i Barsebäck eller Ringhals. Tänk på de vackra vindkraftverken som just nu står stilla. Det är framsteg. Det är moral. Och det är, enligt de ansvariga, det enda ansvarsfulla valet.