←
Tim Young4,459 posts
Tim Young avatar

Tim Young

@TimJamesYoung

Nottingham born. Deputy Head. Teach First '14 - London. Moved to Melbourne, Aus in Jan 23 to teach. Occasional cricketing.

◷ Joined April 2011▧ 186 Photos and videos
Adam Boxer avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Adam Boxer@adamboxer1·Nov 11

I think lots of people are confused about this Alpha business. When you see someone who has advocated for a specific set of ideas for a long time go on to join or lead an organisation that seems completely antithetical to those ideas, then it's reasonable to be confused. Yesterday, I briefly discussed this with @PepsMccrea, and I argued that Alpha represents educational progressivism with a veneer of "learning science" (or what we have normally called "cognitive science" in England). Here, I'd like to expand a bit on that. I'm not going to cite every claim, because this has been part of common discourse here for at least a year (as long as Carl [and I think Peps]) have been working for Alpha. First, instrumentalism. In England, educational traditionalists (like Carl and Peps) argued that education and the education system is not designed merely to prepare students for the world of work. Instead, it is there to pass on cultural heritage, and knowledge for its own sake. Progressives on the other hand argued that it was more about "21st century skills" and railed against a system that "failed to prepare students for jobs that hadn't been invented yet." It's clear that Alpha is built in this vein. It runs courses on entrepreneurialism, media training, startup founding etc etc. NONE of their marketing that I have seen is about the joy of learning or being inculcated into a cultural or intellectual tradition. Second, long term learning. Proponents on this site have boasted about how students finish courses in a matter of days. One of the very first things I learnt from the traditionalist school was that learning is a process that occurs over the long term, and that short term performance means little. Third, "time back". Alpha uses an app called Timeback, which broadly - in my understanding - means that if students do well on their 2 hours of AI-enabled academics, they get more time to do other stuff. This again emphasises that academic education is something to be "got through" so we can get to the fun stuff: Navy SEAL training, social media, horse riding and...entrepreneurship. Fourth, in a similar vein, extrinsic motivation. Alpha has heavily pursued gamification and an extrinsic reward system. Again, English traditionalists used Self Determination Theory as a key plank of their arguments about schools and education, and extrinsic motivation as an educational lever has been widely derided based on simple findings from the SDT literature. Fifth, personalisation. Every so often someone here said we should teach shakespeare through rap or dance or whatever. Traditionalists thought this was awful. The content is the content, and it is our job to take students beyond their horizons, not pander to their narrow set of cultural experiences. And yet this is exactly what Alpha does. Writing lessons are based on students' particular interests, so Harry Potter and minecraft. Alpha students have spoken about how Romeo and Juliet etc is outdated and boring. Again, very much at odds with what proponents have said in the past. Sixth, trashing the traditional model. We suffered our way through Shift Happens and Schools on Trial (or whatever it was called) which went on and on about factory models and Gradgrind and sage on the stage etc. And yet Alpha promotional materials do the same. Seventh, children on social media. This was the most surprising thing this year, where students at Alpha schools were tasked with setting up an X account and getting a certain number of followers. This is obviously a safeguarding concern, and if an English school leader did this it is likely they would be out of a job pretty quickly. Again, opposing social media and teens on phones has been an important part of the traditionalist movement. Eighth, it's an experiment. This is a kind of trial - "we are trying to figure out if we can do this." There's a couple of problems here. First, children aren't guinea pigs (even if their parents are rich). Second, trialling it in the best possible circumstances (i.e. a rich private school) seems like a good idea because the risk is low, but it's also why it won't scale. Anyone who has tried to roll out educational change knows that there is an "adoption curve" and a chasm between your early adopters and everyone else. What works for one categorically doesn't work for the other. This is basically as close to an iron clad law of business and scaling tech as you can get. But also, if you really wanted to make change and improve the lives of children globally, you'd focus on the things we know work because we've seen them work! Everyone on that team knows about Michaela, Mercia, Ark King Solomon, West London Free School, Mossbourne, TTA and more. Schools that do incredible things for underprivileged students with a fraction of the budget. High academic expectations. Expert teachers. Brilliant behaviour. Knowledge-rich curriculums. If we really care about scaling educational solutions, let's start there. While we're at it, the focus of the traditional movement was always on disadvantaged students. What can we do for them? How can we help them? How do we serve those who need it the most? Alpha is so obviously not that. It's a hyper-expensive school for the children of elites. Of course, those students need educating too, but dedicating so much time and energy and intellectual capital to them seems at odds with everything that has come before. Ninth, and it's going to be hard to say this without being catty, but respect for academia and qualifications. I want to be super clear that I massively respect the intellectual acumen of people like Carl, Peps, Becky and others. But, they are not "learning scientists." To the best of my knowledge, nobody on the team has produced original research in that particular field. Again, that doesn't mean they are not worth listening to or whatever - but part of the traditional revolution in England was discovering these researchers who had made incredible findings about learning and the brain, within the confines of the peer-review and scientific inquiry method. I know that arguments from authority aren't empirical, but being able to rely on people like Kirschner, Willingham, Dunlosky and others was critical to the success of the traditional movement. Tenth, transferable skills. One of the founding principles of educational traditionalism is that you cannot teach generic or transferable skills like "Leadership" or "resilience", but the Alpha website and promotional materials are full of this stuff. Eleventh, track record. Alpha people have been talking about how fantastic their content is for at least a year, but we are now told that it is just "ok." Obviously most of it is proprietary, but someone posted some physics stuff last week and I thought it was pretty poor. Michael Pershan has blogged similarly, and Dan Meyer (!) has pointed to the objective data from a school that adopted Alpha and ended up doing worse. Twelfth, similar - ratification. Part of why England has succeeded is that we have objective metrics like standardised assessments and progress 8 that allow us to test the claims of schools and educationalists. Alpha has no such metrics, and instead we need to take their word for it that they are causing "2x learning." It's a surprise to see people who have been part of the positivist and outcomes-led policy movement wanting to be involved in this kind of non-verifiable model. Thirteenth, real books, but as a totem standing for traditionalism. A number of people have asked if Alpha students read real books. On paper. Great books. There hasn't been much of an answer, beyond a picture of a library. Ok, books are important, but they aren't really my point here. My point is that there is a romanticism around traditional education. Something that goes beyond the petty mechanics of pedagogy, and taps into something social and cultural about learning. That we are one link in a long chain of transmission, a chain which cherishes books not because of a fascination with bleached wood pulp, but because of what they represent: our ability to transcend the narrow confines of our lives and swim in the streams of collective human intellectual endeavour. Nothing I've seen at Alpha tells me there's anything like that idealism. Instead, it strikes me as a desiccated and hollowed-out vision of education, where students learn not from another human, but from an AI-generated screen. It doesn't surprise me that some people are interested in Alpha. It seems exciting and innovative as a business model. But it does surprise me that THESE people are interested in it. I harbour no ill will towards them, and as I've said I respect their work. I hope this comes across as respectful and measured. But it's no surprise that people are surprised.

Pamela Snow avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Pamela Snow@PCSnow1604·Oct 6

“In short, PISA is a screen-based test of problem-solving skills that requires limited specific curriculum knowledge. If you wanted to design a test that would be *least likely* to reward England’s educational approach, and *most likely* to reward the approach in Scotland & Wales, it would be PISA. And yet, England are still doing better on it.” 🎯 🎯🎯

There's a lot of talk about whether we can trust PISA scores or not. PISA is not the only international test. TIMSS & PIRLS are run by a different research group, and have a slightly different focus. They test reading, maths & science but with more of a focus on specific curriculum knowledge. England is also the only country outside East Asia to come in the top 10 on all the TIMSS & PIRLS tests too. More here. substack.nomoremarking.com/p…

Jon Hutchinson avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Jon Hutchinson@jon_hutchinson_·Sep 22

It’s always a genuine travesty when a kid is permanently excluded from school. It’s seductive to believe that simply not excluding solves all of the pain associated with them. But it’s based on a confusion of causes and consequences. Focus on the causes.

Let’s all commit to minimising school exclusions by putting the children first. This will reduce crime. It will empower young people. It will save young people and enable them to have positive lives. School exclusions are failures.

Daisy Christodoulou avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Daisy Christodoulou@daisychristo·Sep 8

The PISA 2025 results are out today. Some quick insights. - The major story is very significant global decline. The last PISA study was in 2022, and saw big declines in reading and maths scores from 2018. Obviously the pandemic played a part. - But this 2025 round has seen further falls even from the 2022 lows! Things haven't gone back to normal post-pandemic - they've got worse. Every generation thinks the generation below is less smart - but this time they might be right!

Adam Boxer avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Adam Boxer@adamboxer1·Sep 8

Untangling the factors that have led to England's educational success on the national stage isn't easy. If I were a betting man, I would say that the gradual improvements are due to: - Increased behaviour standards and expectations (led by a number of MATs) - Knowledge-rich curriculum, and the abandonment of trying to teach transferable skills - Eradication of coursework and "in class assessment" from many qualifications - Removal of soft/light qualifications like the old "GCSE equivalents" - Ditching modular assessments - Moving more teacher training out of the control of universities and directly into schools - Systematic synthetic phonics - The growth of explicit instruction and sensible classroom teaching strategies There's probably more. Off the top of my head, those are the big ones.

Daisy Christodoulou avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Daisy Christodoulou@daisychristo·Sep 8

The best evidence that the fads might be causing this problem is that one of the few countries to escape the general fall in scores is England - also one of the few countries to explicitly reject the fads and take a different approach. Contrast with Scotland - a similar country which had basically the same PISA scores as England in 2012. Since then the two countries took very different educational approaches and Scottish students are now about a year behind English ones in maths & science (and behind by a smaller amount in reading). I wrote about this in 2013, but it's even more stark now. substack.nomoremarking.com/p…

Sam Freedman avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Sam Freedman@Samfr·Sep 8

New PISA data out England is now top ten in all three areas (reading, maths, science) and the second highest performing country outside of east Asia (after Estonia). This is a huge public policy success.

Adam Boxer avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Adam Boxer@adamboxer1·Aug 30

Students using AI for educational purposes is neither desirable nor inevitable. We saw the same cycle with mobile phones. When they started up, schools were in a bit of a tizz. Nobody really knew how to respond. Then we had people talking about them as learning tools, and that we should be teaching students how to use them appropriately. Time passed, and people realised that this wasn't smart, and today there are only a handful of secondary schools in the country that allow them (or allow teachers to allow students to use them). Gone are the days of kahoot quizzes in class and kids on social media in lunch. Good, say I. Of course, we can't necessarily control what students do outside of school. But we do what we can, and we don't concede the ground when there are things we can control. The crazy thing is that most of us are looking back over the last 15 years and wondering why we didn't take these actions sooner. The writing was on the wall, and it should have been obvious to us that national bans were inevitable. The same is true for AI. It's clearly bad for students' brains*, and we need to resist them using it as much as possible. We don't need to "teach them how to use it responsibly." It's not practical, and it is almost definitely not possible. And, whilst we can't directly control what they do outside of school, we can: A. Ensure we aren't actively sending them towards it (either through unmediated chatbots or homework platforms that make use of it) B. Take simple measures to communicate its undesirability to students. Tell them it sucks. Tell them not to use it. Use strategies like The Greatest Do Now Ever** to quickly and easily check whether or not they've used it. It's not complicated. This year, my students completed tens of thousands of questions online for me. Some of them took shortcuts in their answers and some were overly lenient in their self assessment. I picked it up, we dealt with it. But - despite substantial and intensive checking and triangulating - I found absolutely ZERO evidence any of them used AI to answer questions. Getting them not to use it is not beyond the wit of man. None of this is inevitable, and in ten years time we are going to look back and wonder why we didn't do this sooner. Teachers are absolute suckers for new tech. But we don't have to be, and until someone can prove that this stuff isn't detrimental, kick it out. --- *See Benjamin Riley's EXCELLENT post on the matter: buildcognitiveresonance.subs… **carouselteachlearnlead.subst…

Colin Brazier avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Colin Brazier@ColinBrazierTV·Aug 28

The best single encapsulation of why the Jason Arday scandal damages us all.

Post attachment
Gary Marcus avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus·Aug 23

“We are not experiencing an “AI Jobs Shock”. At most, we are experiencing a reduction in hiring by executives who do not understand the technology but who have absorbed vibes that there will be a real-soon-now “AI Jobs Shock”. Where do these vibes come from? From a combination of grifters seeking money, and madmen hearing the voices in their heads of a forthcoming Digital God”. Brilliant quote from @delong’s newsletter.

Adam Boxer avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Adam Boxer@adamboxer1·Aug 6

My various positions on "behaviour is all about relationships" are (in no particular order): If you want behaviour to improve, trying to build relationships is a significantly worse option than - Having a good policy - Implementing simple behaviour management strategies like FLMOP and Golden Silence Building relationships in challenging contexts is not a straightforward undertaking. Nobody really knows how to do it. There are a few tips here and there, but there is literally nothing that is "guaranteed" or even close to "guaranteed" to work. Sure, there are some things you shouldn't do (like shout, be sarcastic, be rude), but what *should* you do? Anyone who tells you they know the answer is lying or deluded. If you work in a school where you have a good behaviour policy and culture, it's much easier to build relationships. If you work in a school where you have a good behaviour policy and culture, building relationships isn't going to help you, and if you happen to have ok behaviour it's because of a different variable. Good relationships are neither a necessary or sufficient condition of having good behaviour. Some of the students who have caused me the most grief are also the ones I had the best relationships with. I have plenty of students who I have no relationship with (i.e. ones I only just started teaching), who magically behave just fine. All the above means that correlation and causation are impossible to untangle. Ok, so Sarah over in maths has great relationships with her class and lovely behaviour? Which came first? Did they behave because of the relationships, or did the relationships flourish because of the behaviour? If you are a cover teacher, or new to a school or anything like that, you should be able to expect good behaviour without having to build relationships first. Final point: None of the above means I don't care about building relationships. In fact, I care MORE than the "behaviour is all about relationships" crew. Why? Because I think they are important in and of themselves. I couldn't care less if they mean I get better behaviour - that's not why I try and build them. I think it's part of my job to respect my students and build relationships with them because it's fundamentally important, and not for any other reason.

Stuart Lock avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Stuart Lock@StuartLock·Aug 3

8. The school named had a large legacy of poor performance. It failed thousands of pupils. Why did no journalist cover this?

Adam Boxer avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Adam Boxer@adamboxer1·Jul 27

Another excellent article about Alpha schools. I agree with so much of it, especially the points about how education isn't something to be "gotten through" as quickly as you can so you can do the fun stuff in the rest of the day. It also makes me so grateful to teach in the English system. Our assessments aren't all multiple choice and closed answers, and I have no doubt that many of these students who "ace" reading exams would get utterly obliterated in a GCSE English literature paper, and pretty much any other subject (including maths). There's certainly no way to prepare for GCSE science in the time that Alpha students have. It's just impossible. The best human 1:1 tutor in the world couldn't deliver the course in the amount of time allotted. Most students in this country will have around 6 hours of science a week. MAYBE you could half that, if you were brilliant. I moved like the absolute clappers with my Year 11s this year and barely finished, and they did SO MUCH work outside the classroom too. I'm certainly not skilled enough to be able to cut that 6 hours/week substantially even in a 1:1 setting. I'd actually love it for an Alpha school to open a state school in England. We can then get standardised data, they can sit GCSEs like everyone else, and we can validate the "we are so much better than everyone else" claims. At present, so little details have been provided by Alpha or any of its boosters that I find myself personally annoyed that I'm commenting on it. Like, why bother? Who cares? It's a magic dreamland full of stuff they've potentially made up and hasn't been validated, and it seems like we are being asked to "trust me, this time it's different." Well, I'm afraid I don't. Educational progressives have propounded these ideas for over 100 years and...it's never been different. It's a desiccated and soulless view of education, that will fail to scale and will remain the privilege of an elite few, who would have succeeded regardless of the type of education they got. The whole thing reminds me of a t-shirt I once saw that said "Citation or GTFO." Pretty much says it all.

Alpha School claims its students learn 2.6x faster than average in only 2 hrs/day, based on test scores--using an AI tutor. My questions: How do they teach social studies, novels & writing? And do test scores measure everything? More in my new post: nataliewexler.substack.com/p…

Post attachment
Daisy Christodoulou avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Daisy Christodoulou@daisychristo·Feb 26

MrBeast trains new employees at his company with a 36-page knowledge-rich PDF and a quiz at the end. Oh, and he asks them to read the PDF twice, because they won't retain everything the first time. Watch what people do, not what they say.

Post attachment
Jack@JackkkFeb 24

MrBeast explains why the education system is completely broken “Why are students today being taught the same way their parents were? Look at how much everything else has advanced. When I was in school the teacher would just stand there, read out of a book and write on a whiteboard” "Now look at Mark Rober’s videos. You can learn complex topics in 20 minutes in a way that’s engaging, fun and you retain it. Just because our parents were taught one way doesn’t mean we need to keep teaching that same way. It makes no sense to me, I think education should be reformed dramatically” “Students spend so much time in school. If we had real courses made through videos, made learning more hands on and optimised everything with modern technology, kids could probably learn more in 5 hours than they currently do in 8 hours"

1:39
Daisy Christodoulou avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Daisy Christodoulou@daisychristo·Feb 18

Sam is correct. Also, from an assessment point of view, this whole debate reveals why rank order sometimes can be really useful. EG a lot of the time you will hear people say "Well it's the absolute score that matters, not the rank order". But when there is a big external shock to a system - like a pandemic! - comparing pre and post absolute scores is misleading. Rank order is actually more useful in this situation. In this case, yes, England's absolute scores did not change much pre & post pandemic - but in the context of almost every other country's score falling!

A passage from the Phillipson profile is extremely misleading. She claims England's improvement in PISA scores isn't impressive because recent scores are not much higher than in 2009. She also claims that @michaelgove's reforms failed to close the attainment gap between rich and poor. Both are misleading. Here's some context she 'forgot' to add: - England's Maths Ranking: 27th (2009)➡️11th (2022) - England's Reading Ranking: 25th (2009)➡️13th (2022) - Scores fell during the pandemic everywhere, but England's scores fell by less. - Wales (under Labour) didn't implement Gove's reforms. Their scores are lower than England's and haven't improved. - In fact, the average Welsh pupil now performs at the same level as the most disadvantaged pupils in England. - Scotland is a similar story. They had better scores than England 20 years ago. England's are now higher in all three categories. (Scotland also withdrew from other international metrics.) - Phillipson claims our average scores might be up, but we've done little on equity/fairness. - The problem for her is that England's attainment gap between rich and poor is very low by international standards. - England's 86 point gap is below France's (113), Germany's (111), OECD average (93). The gap is marginally larger than Finland's (83), but our gap is stable while theirs is widening. I agree with the New Statesman article that Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson isn't a Marxist. But let's be clear, she is undermining successful reforms and abusing statistics in the process. Not a Marxist, not good either.

Post attachment
Sam Dumitriu avatar
⟳ Tim Young retweeted
Sam Dumitriu@Sam_Dumitriu·Feb 18

A passage from the Phillipson profile is extremely misleading. She claims England's improvement in PISA scores isn't impressive because recent scores are not much higher than in 2009. She also claims that @michaelgove's reforms failed to close the attainment gap between rich and poor. Both are misleading. Here's some context she 'forgot' to add: - England's Maths Ranking: 27th (2009)➡️11th (2022) - England's Reading Ranking: 25th (2009)➡️13th (2022) - Scores fell during the pandemic everywhere, but England's scores fell by less. - Wales (under Labour) didn't implement Gove's reforms. Their scores are lower than England's and haven't improved. - In fact, the average Welsh pupil now performs at the same level as the most disadvantaged pupils in England. - Scotland is a similar story. They had better scores than England 20 years ago. England's are now higher in all three categories. (Scotland also withdrew from other international metrics.) - Phillipson claims our average scores might be up, but we've done little on equity/fairness. - The problem for her is that England's attainment gap between rich and poor is very low by international standards. - England's 86 point gap is below France's (113), Germany's (111), OECD average (93). The gap is marginally larger than Finland's (83), but our gap is stable while theirs is widening. I agree with the New Statesman article that Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson isn't a Marxist. But let's be clear, she is undermining successful reforms and abusing statistics in the process. Not a Marxist, not good either.

Post attachment

CLASS WARRIOR by Pippa Bailey Is Bridget Phillipson really the most dangerous education secretary ever? Bridget Phillipson has certainly faced her critics since she entered the Department for Education in July 2024. She was likened to a Nazi for Labour’s promise to remove the VAT exemption on private-school fees. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill saw her derided as a “Marxist”. Her changes have been interpreted as an attack on Michael Gove’s legacy. For them, Phillipson has been labelled an enemy of progress who wants to cut down the tall poppies rather than help them grow. The Mail considers her “the most dangerous education secretary in living memory”. Phillipson and Keir Starmer are close allies. On 9 February, as pressure mounted on the Prime Minister to resign over the appointment of Peter Mandelson, Phillipson volunteered to support him on the media round. (She was “extremely keen” to do so, a Labour figure says.) Now, Phillipson faces two even more toxic challenges, the outcome of which will make or break her career, and perhaps the government itself. First, the long-awaited schools white paper is expected in the coming days. Its most difficult proposals involve reforms to special educational needs (Send) provision. Months of painstaking work have gone into building support among Labour MPs in hopes of avoiding a Welfare Bill-style rebellion that could threaten the Prime Minister’s fragile grip on power. Second, as Women and Equalities Minister, Phillipson is responsible for delivering guidance on how organisations implement the Supreme Court’s ruling that, for the purposes of the Equality Act, a woman is defined by biological sex. Businesses and services are still operating under a code of practice last updated in 2011. Pressure is mounting on Phillipson to deliver its replacement – and fast. Labour is on the brink. If Phillipson can steer through Send reform and the trans guidance, she could restore a sense of strength and confidence about this government – and perhaps even give it a sense of purpose. If she cannot, she risks becoming an emblem for a government that has neither a coherent vision nor the ability to communicate it; at once loathed and without the radicalism to justify such loathing. On Send reform in particular, the timing is crucial: Labour’s performance in the local elections in May could end Starmer’s premiership. But who is the woman at the heart of these challenges – and what does she want? Is she a radical reformer, intent on ripping up the legacy of the Gove era to set a path of her own? Or is she a more conservative figure, seeking sensible tweaks to the system she inherited? Does she – and the government more widely – know which she wants to be? Most importantly, perhaps, can she grip the challenges ahead with enough strength to save Keir Starmer’s faltering government, before time and the last vestiges of goodwill run out? (Cover photo by Kate Peters for the New Statesman)

Post attachment