←
Tom Chatfield19,436 posts
Tom Chatfield avatar

Tom Chatfield

@TomChatfield

Tech philosopher, author, dad. Critical thinking, AI ethics, future skills. Not so active on here these days. Views mine.

◷ Joined November 2009▧ 1,072 Photos and videos
Tom Chatfield avatar
Tom Chatfield@TomChatfield·Oct 22

Haven't uploaded music in a long while, but having *finally* treated myself to a fine new instrument…

2:17
Tom Chatfield avatar
Tom Chatfield@TomChatfield·Sep 13

Something I've been working on for the last couple of years with some brilliant collaborators: Duologue, a learning platform that teaches you *how* to think rather than *what* to think. Do take a look. duologue.ac.uk/

STYRΞNΞ ✂️ avatar
⟳ Tom Chatfield retweeted
STYRΞNΞ ✂️@sty_defi·May 1

Stanford neuroscientists Dr. David Eagleman says AI will have a problem with selection AI is massively creative. The part of creativity that AI can’t do right now is selection… meaning, it can generate 100 pictures, but it doesn’t know which one to pick.” “It doesn’t know which one is going to be the most appealing to you, but it can remix beautifully.” “When it generates the pixels, it’s doing this magical stuff under the hood where it’s deciding which pixels and how they diffuse together to make the image. But it doesn’t know how to read that image… it’s not seeing the image except as a bunch of pixels.”

1:48
Gary Marcus avatar
⟳ Tom Chatfield retweeted
Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus·Apr 30

this is … odd. the whole problem with agentic code is that people wind up with hard to debug redundancies, security holes, deleted databases, etc., which is exactly why you need roadmaps and code reviews, with AI-written code. I am with @Grady_Booch on this one (and almost everything else). I don’t doubt that we will have more code written cheaper than ever, but a lot of it is going to be a mess unless there is serious oversight. (Companies like Amazon have already seen this.)

For 50 years, software engineering ran on code rationing. Writing code was expensive, so we rationed it carefully through roadmaps, RFCs, prioritization meetings, and scope reviews. This created a role: the No Engineer. No, that won't scale. No, we don't have bandwidth. No, that's out of scope. No, we need a design doc first. The No Engineer was valuable for 50 years. Every "no" saved real money. Their judgment was the rationing system. LLMs will be the end of code rationing. Code is cheap now. And while the No Engineer is explaining why something can't be done, the Yes Engineer has already shipped three versions of it. If you're a Yes Engineer, the next decade is yours.

Tom Chatfield avatar
Tom Chatfield@TomChatfield·Apr 29

Treated myself while passing through Charing Cross to a copy of How to Talk to AI by the brilliant @JamieJBartlett to find it was both already signed and officially bestselling. Congratulations, Jamie! Can't wait to read it.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Steven Pinker avatar
⟳ Tom Chatfield retweeted
Steven Pinker@sapinker·Apr 28

As an avid cyclist, I was amused to see ChatGPT's “powerful new image engine" draw a bicycle with the "brake" label pointing to empty space where brakes are sometimes found on other bicycles. The point of these AI fails (regularly collected by @garymarcus) is not that LLMs are useless or unintelligent but that they think differently from humans, lacking explicit knowledge of reality and instead amalgamating billions of statistical generalizations. open.substack.com/pub/garyma…

Tom Chatfield avatar
Tom Chatfield@TomChatfield·Apr 28

A fascinating experiment. And also a window into a central limitation of present LLMs. Any system pre-trained up to cutoff date X is myopic beyond it; yet convincingly and fluently willing to predict and generlize without the capacity for updating underlying assumptions.

Played with Talkie, an LLM trained only on pre-1930 data. It's pretty dumb and inconsistent, as to be expected at its size. But still very cool. Excited about "vintage LLMs." Testing a model on forecasting world events that haven't happened for decades is both badass and a promising way to understand LLMs' forecasting capabilities.

Post attachment
Kendric Tonn avatar
⟳ Tom Chatfield retweeted
Kendric Tonn@kendrictonn·Apr 24

Spent an hour messing with ChatGpt & images, and I'm increasingly convinced we're over the horizon. Not where human artists are obsolete, I don't plan to quit, but yeah, it's going to define processes, mostly in the positive, sometimes in the negative ("I don't use it") way

David Chalmers avatar
⟳ Tom Chatfield retweeted
David Chalmers@davidchalmers42·Apr 14

here's a new version of "what we talk to when we talk to language models", with an added section (pp. 16-23) on LLM interlocutors as characters, personas, or simulacra. philarchive.org/rec/CHAWWT-8 the new version discusses role-playing vs realization, the simulators framework, the persona selection hypothesis, and more -- in addition to the existing discussion of quasi-mental states, LLM identity, personal identity in severance, LLM welfare, and related topics. this version was mostly written before recent discussions of these issues on X and in NYC, but i've updated it a little in light of those discussions. any thoughts are welcome.