
When the pandemic lockdowns began, the philosopher Giorgio Agamben warned that they could pose an extinction-level event for a type of human “communal life.” This was misinterpreted to mean restaurants and bars and other such commercial things, or maybe to spaces for political protests. And so the misunderstood warning was easily dismissed—since of course restaurants recovered (and the pro-lockdown faction prided itself as having superior culinary taste anyway); and there have been lots of protests over various issues. But Agamben was referring to something more hidden and subtle, a “communal life” that existed in a nonsurveilled, nondigital, spontaneous, sometimes shadowy or “illegal” way. “Communal life” in the sense of people breaking the rules the “Gesellschaft” has taught them about how to behave, and instead engaging in a “Gemeinschaft” that emerges from instinct, creativity and desire. And yes I think that in a lot of cities, that existed right up until 2020, and then it died and it never really came back. Agamben was right.

























